![]() |
Pace Line Section Sartin Guidelines
2 Attachment(s)
work in progress - check here often...
Here are some recommend reading options. These are long post from the teaching 101 area Please read these with an open mind. The posters are offering us valuable information in a friendly Pace and Cap manner. They are presented here to teach us how to win. Bill Attachment 39647 Plus, Plus within a zero and zero + (+) 0 http://paceandcap.com/forums/showpos...73&postcount=1 Best Of Last 3 Follow Up Issue #81 page 1 paragraph 2 Thank you to Tim LT1. Attachment 39648 more to come |
Great post Bill, I concur 100%.
Mitch44 |
I would also suggest Follow Up #81 page 1 paragraph 2.
|
from a PM
.
Many people, never understood the concept of always using the last line. Before one can even get to using the last line, or any other line, they have to understand that they should only be using “+” or “(+)” lines. AND, they have to understand what a + or (+) line is! You don’t use the last line when the horse ran around the racetrack “dead last”! However, if the last line is a + or (+) line, then it should be used. Of course Doc always went on to explain situations when the last “bad” line is an “unless” line, in which case it is OK to go back ONE LINE! I mean, this is not brain surgery!! Even when Doc shifted to using best of last 3 distance/surface, he told people to pay attention to the fact that he “very rarely” went back more than 3 lines. Bill's thoughts .. And I replied And If line 2 is also a non comparable, "unless" line than you go to line 3 |
PM: I go back to the early 90's with this stuff, the reason for the last line was to rate it as it was an indication of form I.e. improving or declining, as far as "+' or "o" race. No idiot would use the last line if " when the horse ran around the racetrack "dead last"."
Just because its a + line does it mean that it is the pace line to use. It better be at a comparable dis.,surface etc. Today with the advance of RDSS every line is rated in TPR, Tot. Energy, Pace of the race and Preceptor therefore IMO making the old + & O of races is obsolete, for me that is. Yea the program even rates those ugly races where the horse finished "dead last." ha ha A plus line in the last race or any line must be put in context to todays conditions and surface to be a useable line. Depending on what format I'm looking at I also use Speed Rating for improving and declining form but the tools in RDSS mention above are better and all done for you, unlike the early 90's when this all had to be done by hand. The Doc also went back past line 3 if they weren't at a comparable dis, sur. etc. In the above post, Bill's thoughts. . . . has it correct above and I'll go back further depending on what's in the horse's chart. Note: see Bill V. post above Pace line selection. . . . . from SportStat where the last line was no more predicable than line 4, Follow Up # 81,pg.1,par.#2 Galen G. Mitchell AKA Mitch44 |
Thank you Tim
Your suggestion will added I added my thoughts . The stats are based on using the last line with no consideration of being of a comparable distance surface or competition level This is why one of the first steps in phase 1 is to run the numbers on each horse last line . The winner will be amount the top 5 TPR almost ( nothing works always ) every time . Now once you have the top 5 off the last line Now lines can be looked at for the line that is the best of the last 3 Bill |
Do it your way!
Bill,
This is your thread and you have long experience with TPR or Phase I. It is your handicapping program of choice. You can educate from experience which is very gracious of you. This stuff takes time!!. Some of us, self included have gone in different directions or altered the strict interpretation of Doc and Jim's work. That's good as we need to make some money doing this or it is just gambling and we are all at liberty to put our own experience to work for us. However, I was thinking that your efforts are more directed to new users or those that have never had much experience with the Sartin Methodology or TPR. I commend you highly giving of your time and knowledge. Thank you!! |
Hi Bill Ive been away for many years and just bgetting back after re reading Pace makes the Race.
Ive read now that instead of using L.A.S.T , the best of last three (relavent) should be used. i.e. if todays race is a dirt sprint the best of last three dirt sprints should be used, but only if its last is not a SNAIL. have I got that right? a second question involves 3 yrolds and especially now with newly turned ones. 2 year olds grow up a lot from 2 to 3 and continue to grow up until they mature around breeders Cup. Does the Sartin Methodology have a formula for assigning grow up points to TPR . i have been using Quirin style adjustments of 3 speed points per month for 2 yrolds and 2 points per month for 3 yrolds til June then 1 point per month. I double this for TPR assigning half the additional points to both EPR and FFR. I relize that some times it makes for ridiculous ratings ,so when it does i just fudge them to make them realistic e.g. . im not going to add 5 points to a 110 EPR. can you help with this or direct me to the relevant F.U. tx barryt |
advanced
Hi
There is not too much info about phase 1 TPR in the followups The original PMTR was written by Doc and Dick Schmidt The book was to be read and followed. There is nothing I know of about such adjustments. For 2 and 3 year olds The numbers one gets form entering the last line of each horse give you a base for which to judge how far back you can go for a pace line. Always start with most recent paceline and then work down from there. |
barryt:
In reference to your second question the answer is that, no Sartin did not have a formula for assigning growth points to TPR or any other factor. Your on the correct path in using Quirin adjustments. This is what I use and use either 1 or 1.5 for those adjustments. I use it now and than in certain situations. Its tricky to use and not all that accurate because each horse's growth pattern is different, or in other words some don't progress until age 5 etc. I have found also that like humans horses grow in spurts or in other words all in a short time span such as only late in the year and not gradually throughout the year. Vino Rosso is a perfect example that won the BC Classic in that he really matured late in the year. So these projections can be very iffy and they do have merit,but we don't know precisely when that will occur. Many never progress because they have no inherit class to begin with therefore I would caution against as its just a crapshoot. I do it now and than under certain circumstances but not for all horses or every situation. Someone once said "it works when it works and it don't when it doesn't. The truth also is that form is very hard to predict and if we could do that with precision the game would be dead, so it is with projections. This also includes projection of a horse from a sprint to a route where Sartin does have a formula. Its more accurate to extract than to project anything. Mitch44 |
Hi Mitch
Thanx for the useful reply. Yes it is hard to apply and sometimes it does not work but when it does it yields box car prices e.g like #11 in Tam derby. As an aside the #11 was also TANDEm to the race favourite #7 when the 11 last raced in NOV.so here the adjustment was easy and validated.( but one race doesn’t a season make.) Another instance where I may use projections is for 2TS. Does Sartin have any recommendation here. Marc Cramer did lots of study on this which showed an average increase of 15, yes 15, in SR from race 1 to race 2. I cap this at 20 for TPR and distribute it equally between EPR and FFR unless some thing indicates otherwise. I also let the FTS odds be a guide as to wether to credit the 20 or not. I’d appreciate your, and Bills, comment on this. Many times there are 3 yrold 2TS coming off long layoffs of 6 months or so then I either give them the grow up points or the 2TS pointsNot both As an aside would RDSS allow one to make these adjustments? |
Hi barryt:
Your right that when it works the payoffs are good. Sartin has no recommendation for 2nd time starters and never got into that kind of stuff. In fact Sartin never believed in Pars which Qurin stuff was based on and most all Speed Ratings are based on, nor the maturity factor as well, however it is a valid concept. The problem is all horses don't mature at the same rate. Some are precocious while others may mature late or not till their 5 or even 6 yr.'s of age, even when trained by the best.This is why it doesn't work on a consistent basis. If used as a nothing burger one will lose their butt. Sartin is also correct about Pars and their flaws etc. Sartin's concept of Pars were the horses within the race or Matchup determine Pars. He is correct that Pars people purchase are old and outdated by the time people get them (no immediacy here).That also begs the question if its the same horse. He also is correct that horses don't run to pars but run by the matchup of the race. Sartin was correct also that one of the biggest problems with Pars is that their taken from the POR (pace of the race) rather than by the winners of the race.(POH) The match up is within the RDSS program based on his belief of Pars. Its much more recent, more accurate than matchers can do by eyeball scans etc. and most matchers don't take it into the 3rd FR,so their essentially speed handicappers. Taking it into the 3rd FR is best done by the computer program. The 2 for 1 formula just isn't accurate. I.e. for every unit of pace used early will cost the horse 2 unit in the 3rd. FR., the big reason for this is that horses don't all decelerate at the same rate. Therefore its a hap hazard approach at best. I use odds also for FTS. I would not use Cramer's adjustments as they seem way out of line and especially with TPR. TPR is based on 1 point per length. Speed Rating are much more and more like 1.5 per length for sprints and 1 per lg. for routes. So for 15 sprint 22.5 & 20 sprint 30 lg.'s A route 15 is 15 lg.s and a 20 SR is 20 lg.'s For a horse to make up those kind beaten lengths in TPR are just unreasonable from race to race. Seldom will you see a horse make up more than 10 lengths, in fact the majority of TPR winners come from the top 3 and horses with a deficit of 10 will seldom be in the top 3. And if ranked 4th or worse you better be getting some odds to make the risk rewarding. Keep records of TPR and you'll see this. Mitch44 |
Top 5
Hello Mitch
10 points is a very wide spread. In PMTR the cutoff is within 5 points. If the top horse has a 180 TPR, horses horses with less than a 175 are highly suspect. I only keep horses that are in the top 3 EPR or LPR or both, and within 5 of the top TPR horses |
I agree Bill but have seen where horses between 5 & 10 of the top figure wins. These are mostly from the matchup and improving horses. Specifically when at least 3 E horses with very high % Med that get into a speed duel. With two E horses many times they don't get into a speed duel because one may not be in form.
These horses tend to show high deceleration and it allows even pace horses and S types to catch the dying speed. Beaten lengths say they should not win but they do. And if the top TPR etc. are out of form their closer and more competitive than appears. I see more of these types of races at the minor tracks. Horses with sharp deceleration get regulated to the minors because at major tracks they tend to hold their speed longer. My point to barryt was to keep records and he'll see the top 3 generally win most of the races , it really drops after the top 5 as far as winning ability. Rather than ranks RDSS users or pace cappers should look more at gaps than rankings. A point of SR and a length in TPR are not the same also. Over 10 lg. especially 15 & 20 are way out of line. I agree that beyond the top 2 LPR seldom win, those are excellent guidelines from PMTR. IMO those guidelines don't allow for even pace horses who generally never meet that criteria and Total Energy horses, although most times they are similar. How you doing Bill? Well I hope and best of health. Mitch44 |
Tex Mitch
I didn’t understand every thing but I certainly got the drift. My point is yes the top 3 TPRs win most of the races but by adding grow up points or 2TS points an otherwise also ran could jump up into the top 3 As it happens I have a perfect example o illustrate this in Friday’s card at OP R7 the 1 & 4 both raced at SAR in JulyAug with 84. &83 ratings and both tried graded stakes. The 4 continued racing and earned a 95 SR in Feb. The 1 stopped racing in SEp. Now are we going to use it’s July pace line of July SR 84 TPR of 177 that makes it an also ran or bring it up to equal that of of the 4 SR 95 TPR 190which makes it a prime contender? This is what I wrestle with and most of the time I do the upgrade and get say 8-1 on a 3-1 horse. With the upgrade I have #1 E 121 that’s 1 EPR,2 FFR, & 1 TPR I’m using Bris figures throughout. #4 P 132 #6 P x12 It’s very close as 1 and 4 tied EPR and 1 was 2 better in TPR that both 4&6 Well see what happens, yesterday FFR was king. |
TPRs as in PMTR are approx double speed figure as thy are based on 100 for EPR and 100 for FFR. I realize that the methodology has come along way since 1991 and the computer programs can easily compute compound pace figures that are more representative of the matchup. I’m just trying to get back to where I was and needed to know if I should adjust for grow up. The answer says I shouldn’t ,but I’m not convinced. Where I have to adjust ,I’ll just tread lightly at the windows TIL I get some data.
Tx for your efforts |
I believe you got it barryt, Glad you understand the difference with the SR verses TPR in RDSS which was what I thought you were doing.
In using Bris pace ratings for TPR, the Speed Rating and beaten lengths also differ. Regardless of distance Bris uses 2 points for each beaten length. Their SR are 1.5 for sprints and 1 for routes regardless of distance. Therefore there is less projecting and its more accurate with Bris pace than with Sartin TPR within RDSS. Sartin and RDSS uses different adjustments for BL according to the distance being measures Or in other words the adjustment used for 4 F and 2F in TPR for a 6 F race is different than a 7F race where the increments are 4F and 3 F. Point is very much less accurate to project growth in RDSS than within BRIS. As I said I do it and employ it. I always do it with Bris ratings. What I think you should do is forget about projecting SR to TPR as it compounds the problem. Just project the growth in Speed Ratings, than use that as a guide to whether or not their competitive by SR to the rest of the field. If so there is no need to convert to a Bris TPR. IMO converting to a TPR just compounds the possible error. I never convert to TPR just to a SR. I looked at your race of todays 7th @ OP and IMO no. Here's why: #1 your using a 5.5 line to project to 6F. How is that done? Also in that line he was decelerating and once that starts no ones knows how accurate a 6F race will be. I.e, it may increase rapidly that last 1/2 F or may be able to hold it. Its a crapshoot. Once deceleration starts it generally doesn't improve. The line your using for the 4 is taken from a 6.5 line. This stuff works best when using similar lines and surfaces. With that said, this is a tough race as 3 other horses have ran SR's in the 90's and a couple others in high 80's when breaking their maiden recently which means they could be anything and jump and win if they were not all out in those Md. wins. Something only the connections are aware of. Getting very good odds on the #1 is critical considering the field and also the 1 is coming off a very long layoff of 181 days. That could be from injury or planned to allow it to mature. Here my other analysis. you don't have to project the #1 horse. He has proven the distance and didn't decelerate that much in the race of 10 Aug. at 6.5F. The last part he decelerated rapidly. But look at the internal times of that race. At the stretch call he was 5 lg. off so I would day he ran this in 110 or 110.2 Same as that of the 4 at the same calendar period but also in a race with much faster internal, FR.'s than what the 4 did. So I would say he's a better horse. The trainer for the 1 horse is very capable off a layoff, a plus. His workouts say ready. Prior to layoff he was given longer and slower workouts in prep for his route try. The only ? today is what odds you'll get. If you get the M/L odds of 8-1 I would bet it otherwise pass. No need to project the 1 horse. When projecting consider like dis.'s and surfaces. Project using SR as a comparative and forget about converting to TPR. Mitch44 |
barryt
The 7 scratched. Mitch44 |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:57 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.