![]() |
Fulcrum vs. Match Up
I recently read Pace Makes the Race and have been applying the fulcrum method to try and determine today's pace of the race.
I'm also reading the red match up manual now and ordered the Hat's original Match Up book. I have more reading of the red manual to do to really understand exactly what the Hat is trying to teach. My contenders in the example races don't match his. But early on, it's hard for me to tell the difference between what Pizziola is saying and what the Hat is saying. I know the fulcrum is ideally using the last paceline, but is the match up across all pacelines? Is it also in a competitive race or is it just the fastest times? Clarification anyone? |
'"The Hat" never believed in the fulcrum and told me that at a seminar. He also stated that to the whole audience and is on record on old tapes as saying specifically that. He more or less used a horses whole chart to obtain what the horse normally could do at the different calls and then used that against the match-up that it would face today.
What Pizziola used (fulcrum) was never endorsed by him or the Sartin group. There are many reasons why the last line could be incorrect, all of which Pizziola never takes into consideration. Perhaps the horses last line was on a very fast turf course such as GP or SA and todays race is on the dirt. Etc. etc. I personally believe if your interested in the match-up stick to Bradshaw's teaching and forget about any Pizziola teachings or you'll continue to be from the state of confusion. Mitch44 |
I'm trying to get out of the land of confusion. I don't agree that last race is always most indicative of today fo the reasons you stated.
|
quote
Hi Mitch
Quote:
kpmats10 says he is using the fulcrum method from Pace Makes The Race The official title of the book is Pace Makes The Race an Introduction to the Sartin Methodology Pizzola was one of 4 authors of the book Mr.Bradshaw was not involved. So The Hat has a right to not agree with all of books content, But I disagree with you when you say the fulcrum method is not nor never was endorsed by the Sartin Methodology. The book PMTR is official literature in the history of the Methodology. Howard Sartin himself is a co author. I believe there are methods in the follow ups and in the book that Howard did not fully agree with but he published them, If the contributor could prove to him these methods worked, Later after PMTR was published, Howard asked and his name and his contributions were removed, But when asked he simply said that he felt the book was too simplistic and that he had better tools for getting higher mutuals. I feel the fulcrum method in PMTR has some faults but I still use it confidently, Using only the last line and finding the fastest POR 2nd call were the horse was beaten less than 5 lengths at todays distance, track, and surface. and the line is not unusual for the horse , Aberrant. If none of these factors apply, there is no fulcrum, There is no reason you have to use a non representative line. You do not necessarily have to make a fulcrum in every race, Even in the book, Pizzola shows a example of a non fulcrum race/ winner. Thanks Bill |
Well from a technical point I'll agree Bill that PMTR was part of the Sartin Methodlogy. It also began my understanding of Sartin material and I still believe it has many merits when one understands it. In fact I always consult TPR for a beginning to readout interpretation.
However I won't concede that either the "Doc" or "The Hat endorsed it nor believed in it. The "Doc" gave them free reign to produce the book and perhaps his reasons for removal were to use some tact at the time. All I know is that neither believed in it. If one wants to use it that's their prerogative however it has nothing to do with "The Hats" match-up techniques if that's what some one is attempting to learn. It actually confuses the hell out of them and to a large extent those also choosing correct pace lines. A traveler has to choose their own route to success but it remains doubtful at best they can travel in both directions. For clarification they are two different approaches, but one can take any path they want. Bottom line is the fulcrum has nothing at all to do with Jimmies match-up. Mitch44 |
If what you say is true about the fulcrum then why is it in a article Pizzolla wrote for FU #8
|
Yes and that's precisely my point. That is Pizziols take or his method etc. It is not Bradshaw's match-up and he never did endorse it nor believed in it. If you really want to learn the match up then stick to the originator and master of it and that is Bradshaw's match up. Basically it is in that article because that is Pizziola's take on it not Bradshaw's.
The fact of the matter is the match up was conceived by Bradshaw and he is the expert and master of it. He graciously has shared it with us. If one chooses to not learn from an expert and the best then that's their choice. I wish them the best. That is the main point of my original post, to clear up those confused by the opposite and contradicting methods of the two. Mitch44 |
what works for you
Hi Mitch
I am happy we are on the same page, that the fulcrum is and was part of the Methodology toolkit. I wish all who want to learn the match up nothing but the success they seek. Thank you Shoeless, for the link to the fulcrum in follow up #8 I found the articles about PBS numbers in follow up #11 interesting as well. Good Skill Bill |
My question is that you say Doc never endorsed the fulcrum if that is the case then why was it in the fu's in the first place.
I thought that the purpose of the fu's was to teach others about the Sartin Methodology |
Michael Pizzolla
I was in a Sartin seminar in Las Vegas, I don't know what year it was. I think it was at the Dunes, which is no longer there. As the seminar was starting these young attractive gals appeared in the kind of costume that you might think would be worn to deliver a singing telegram. They started handing out pamphlets at the end of each table, asking that they be distributed down to all the attendees. Everyone was kind of in shock, they didn't know whether it was a Sartin handout or what. Fairly quickly some of the Sartin people started collecting them but I took my time and looked at the material. It was photocopied articles and written information about Doc Sartin, all of it very un complementary. It claimed that his Psychology was mail order and that his background had contained some brushes with the law. Literally, it had Doc in tears and both Brohammer and Bradshaw went up to the podium and spoke in the Doc's defense. My understanding was that this was the work of Michael Pizzolla. He had started marketing his own material and past performance download and my understanding was that he was trying to convert the large following of Doc Sartin to his own programs and such. I learned later from another individual that is now dead but was a major contributor to "Pace Makes the Race" that a disagreement arose concerning the distribution of the profits from that book. Doc published it through O'Henry House and therefore controlled the distributions. Pizzolla thought he got screwed and that caused the fracture of the relationship.
Regardless, Pizzolla's methods in his attempt to disgrace Doc Sartin and injure him personally and professional have made it impossible for me to ever consider anything the Pizzolla has been involved with. Beyond that, Match Up analysis begins at the gate and is specifically focused on 1st call horse position. Additionally, Bradshaw was responsible for the advent of visual Running Styles and a horse's preference for a specific position at the 1st Call which allowed him to put forth his top effort. As far as I know he was the first individual to recognize the psychological aspects of the horse. These are flesh and blood beings that have instinctive behavior based on herd mentality that fight or quit when in competition. There are many handicapping concepts and factors that can indicate potential horses. Certainly horses in contention at the 2nd Call have a better opportunity to win the race, But to ignore everything that has occurred prior to that point in the race to me is not using all the information available to you. It works given certain pace scenarios but misses a great many sustained winners that benefit from intense early pace contention. I began the serious study of the Match Up nearly 3 1/2 years ago when I found the Hat Check blog on this website. I had read the old Red Match Up manual and Jim's first book but I just didn't understand it. Due in large part to Richie P, I was slowly able to digest the information and organize it. I would venture the guess that due to its simplicity, without long experience and careful record keeping by track and distance, it is hard to make a profit using Fulcrum based analytical tools like TPR. |
I was told about that incident while in the bar with Doc Jimmy and others. Sounded like it was ugly. If one listens to the 1992 Vegas tapes you will hear Jimmy stating that Howard was the one who helped him become a winner by explaining to him that horses were like human runners. Since Jimmy was a track coach at the time he grasped the theory and never looked back. Jimmy also told me he didn't believe in the fulcrum stuff since the race starts at the 1st call not the 2nd. He also stated that the race didn't end at the 2nd call. Jimmy also always told us to use the computer programs since the matchup was included in the later programs. In his 1998 tapes Doc leaned heavily on compounded ratings versus the visual matchup. As for Pizzolla and his product I used his Black Magic program for a year and found it lacking when compared to RDSS. In fairness some people do win with it but the downside is you must be willing to withstand long runouts between winners since their definition of value and our wagercapping differs a lot. As stated many times no program will get the winner if the proper contenders and pacelines are not entered. Garbage in garbage out.
Tim G |
Nicely
Tim
Nicely said, I am not a fan of MP. I have seen his programs and read some stuff of his written after he left Pirco, Heck Doc told me some stories too, but since he did not publish them, and since Doc took the high road , so shall I. Pirco was a group of methodologist, these were men and women, flesh and blood , as much as we idolize them either as a group or individuals they were human, not gods, Non of us has ever gone through a nasty divorce ? I know I did I said and things were said and done to me, that neither of us is proud of. I am not a MP supporter. However The fulcrum method from the book PMTR works for me , Its from a official part of the methodology. and I use it based concept, not based on the personalities or behavior practices of the author Peace and love and good skill Bill V. |
Bill I will defer to you since you have been in longer but when I joined 90 the match up was the in thing. I know that you use the fulcrum very successfully.Like they use to say find what works for you in the Methodology and win with it. I guess it can also be traced to what teaching member that we felt had the approach we felt most comfortable with. I connected Glen Connolly because he was from the East Coast and played the tracks I did so it was easy to talk with him and get good info. Bert Mayne was also helpful.
Tim G |
The "Doc" allowed things into print however that does not mean he condoned it or believed in it.
My original post was to clarify a question for one wanting to know the difference. Essentially the fulcrum is a Pizzola technique and has absolutely nothing to do with the match up. Period!! The main contributor of PMTR ( Tom Hamilton) nor any others in the book mention it. My advice to all is to actually test and see if it works for you and if it does then have at it, also test just picking pace lines and compare the difference. TPR is an excellent way to break into the RDSS and the Sartin material. I highly recommend it for those starting out and even old heads can learn from it. Bradshaw stated; "The race starts when the gates open and not at the second call." If you use a fulcrum for the match up your percentage or success will suffer as the 1st Fr has a tremendous effect on races. "The Hat" never taught fulcrum. The bottom line is that PMTR and the Match-up are two totally different concepts. Success with whatever fork you take in the road or trail followed. Mith44 |
You really should read FU 8 on page 5 where Pizzolla is crediting Doc for showing him the fulcrum approach 7 years ago on a phone call.
Funny why would Doc teach the approach if he didn't endorse it Period!! |
Who cares?
I have my own aspirations and goals for handicapping Thoroughbred horse races. My preference for the Match Up began when I saw this gentleman in a cowboy hat at a Sartin seminar and was just overwhelmed by his abilities. I once saw him handicap a race in the gift shop outside and down the hall from the conference room with a racing form and a roller ball pen. And this with the meeting just about ready to begin. Amazed is putting it lightly. At that moment I knew I wanted to handicap like Jim Bradshaw. Well, hell, that was probably 25 years ago and I am still working at it today.
Does it really matter whose teachings or handicapping philosophy one follows? Most of the originators are dead now, unfortunately. So they can't answer any of these questions. No Pizzolla's Fulcrum has nothing to do with the Match Up. They are completely different and stand alone. I am convinced that Jim Bradshaw's association with Doc Sartin lead to the Match Up. Or should I say that the pace methodology that Doc promoted gave Jim a framework of analysis to define his Match Up. In the red manual there is a chart that he suggests that you photocopy and use. This plots the curve created by the internal fractions of a race based on the pace calls. It was said that Jim charted by hand 1000s of races. Later in Aodds98SuperGold the program would do this for you. What it showed was Acceleration > Deceleration and I believe was the source material for visual Running Styles. Early horses expended their energy in the initial segment of the race reaching their top speeds most quickly and therefore beginning their deceleration first etc. This work led to Kgen and Thoromation when they found someone who could map the curves through the use of Calculus. Today we use these same 20 -30 year old advances all wrapped up in a very user friendly program, RDSS2. I don't know where Pizzolla got the idea for his fulcrum concept but I know when I first read about it and explored it, it seemed too much like one of those handicapping systems you would get in the mail 30 -40 years ago. Enough said, whatever floats your boat! Maybe TPR whose creator Tom Hambleton was a good friend is a good starting point to enter the world of handicapping. It is not overly sophisticated and gives new people to the handicapping world some structure to approaching a wager that is certainly better than nothing. However, it should not be touted as a means to instant riches. Those attracted to gambling as a means of making easy money can be mislead. All you have to do is count the number of new guys just in the last couple years that have come on this website and then just disappear when their money is gone. Eventually they start asking for horses just before they drop out of sight. Why do you think the best handicappers are middle aged or older? The learning curve is very steep and it takes years usually before you can even overcome the track takeout. TPR, just as with Matchers or those that use Pizzolla's programs have to invest the time to gain proficiency. In the hands of an experienced handicapper who not only knows his program but also has acquired money management skills and is blessed with patience and personal discipline can make some money betting the horses. Maybe not as much as the old days but enough to make it an enjoyable and rewarding pastime. |
all
Mitch and Mark
There seems to be conflicting themes to this thread I agree, the fulcrum method used by MP in the book Pace Makes The Race has nothing to do with the match up , It really is more of a contender identifier Simply put , who can run competitively against today's expected 2nd call POR Its simply a tool, or step . A beginning step from a book that is clearly an all inclusive rather simplistic introduction to of Sartin Methodology . As Shoeless pointed out, It is written about in Follow Up #8 I also refer to the article in Follow Up 11 about PBS numbers. Imagine that, Bradshaw having something to do with the second call and final time!. This is a clue that leads me to my conclusion that stuff happens. Friends or co workers break up and move on, But I feel Mitch misspoke to say the fulcrum was never was part of the methodology, That was clarified Mitch has replied in post #3 that technically the fulcrum is part of the methodology Which is all I wanted to clarify right from the beginning. I use parts of the Match up and the steps of PMTR including TPR but I use RDSS software and depend on many factors. Thanks Bill |
Hey Shoeless I'll read FU # 8 and reply today. I'm tied up till later this afternoon.
Mitch44 |
Quote:
Horses that can run competitively against that pace are contenders. Others are tossed. |
Having read FU #8 I can clearly see where someone can be confused with the match up by Bradshaw and the fulcrum, also not get the same contenders.
Pizzola on pg. 5 par. 3 line 3 specifically states “It’s is my approach. . . “ On pg.5 par 6 appears to me to be very vague as to the meaning or exactly what the paragraph is saying. Does he mean the preceding paragraph (#5) for selecting contenders, pace lines, adjustments, etc. I have absolutely no idea what this vague paragraph means as its not specific and contradicts his statement in par #5 “ It’s my approach…” I know it’s not Bradshaw’s approach because he has said; “The race starts when the gates open and not at the SC.” Also he told me he doesn’t believe in the fulcrum. Pizzola on page #7 par. 4 states he’ll look at races within 1/5 of his projected pace, or fulcrum. I for the life of me do not think this is a valid concept because it would eliminate as contenders EP, SP & S types horses. This is a false narrative because we all know these types running styles win at tracks every day. If this SC and 1/5 rule is followed you become nothing more than a speed handicapper. Now Bill V. from what I have observed has taken Pizzola fulcrum to new heights because Bill doesn’t use it for contender selection as he puts all the horses in, uses the Doc’s guidelines for pace line selection. He doesn’t use the last line for every horse as the selected line, only an initial step. Additionally he eliminates by Sartin class (TPR) for eliminations and employs the advance concepts that are in PMTR, particularly deceleration. At least that’s my observations and he can correct me or elaborate more if he like to. Pizzola also falls short in that he doesn’t carry it through the 3rd Fr. And this is because of the HUEY factor as explained on pg. 9 par. 8. His explanation on pg. #9 par.6 is really the match up but done by the computer within the Energy program or Thoromation. Bradshaw match up carries through the 3rd FR which is where the 2 for 1 BL comes in etc. In fact the matchup is in the later programs and readouts. Mark brought up a good point about old heads that have been around a long time. They have an understanding when reading old Follow Ups as to what’s current and what has been improved on or superseded. Lt1 and I have talked also about this. It very for a new comer to sift through old FU and do that. I believe this is why Ted recommends reading the later Follow ups as they reflect the current RDSS etc. The fulcrum and the match up of Bradshaw’s are two different approaches. Bradshaw said the match up will stand the test of time and it has. I can’t say that for the fulcrum. Sartin said if it didn’t have 3 fractions its not pace, Bradshaw’s match up includes all 3 Fr.’s. “The race starts when the gates open.” Success can come from testing and keeping records. Conclusions from your own work are lessons never forgotten and more valuable than someone else’s opinion. Best of luck. Mitch44 |
Come On, men...
In the beginning all the pace handicappers used the last line. It wasn't until the mutuels went to hell because the Public picked up on it did the Doc start talking about Sports Stats ROI on the 2nd or 3rd line.
Times change and in a wagering sport like horse racing the syndicates and Public in general get wise. When you quote a reference to Pizzolla and his Fulcrum in FU #8 or #10, what about #15 or #50 or #73? If you want to go back in time use the old Yellow manual and make all those track adjustments. Things change and evolve. Pizzolla quit or got thrown out of Pirco. His ideas and methods ceased to exist in all later publications. Let's not get wrapped around the axle about something that doesn't mean crap. Bill likes the Fulcrum and has used it for years. Harrah for Bill!!! I personally think it is an oversimplification and omits a large portion of the race from analysis. So I don't necessarily recommend that new users start with it. I recommend they start with Bradshaw's 5 step approach and move forward over time as the skills and understanding progress. There are no Cliff notes in handicapping! Tell me this: Why is the last race so important? Is it most important? Why do I care how fast the horse ran in that race. Don't I really want to know who has run the fastest of all the horses in the race? And how did they run fast: on the lead, Pressing or from further back? POWER LINE handicapping will show you in what line the horse ran his best against the fastest early fractions. Isn't that what I want to know? If he did it 7 races ago in a route and today is a sprint, I have to interpret that and make a handicapping decision. If he did it 8 races ago and 3 or 4 months ago returned from a year's layoff, why can't he run back to those figures given the proper conditioning? This obsession with recency is complete garbage but it allows all Matchers to earn double digit mutuels. You either find a way to make money at this sport or you help other people make money. |
Bill,
Thanks for clearing it up Jeff |
Mitch,
You stated in a post What Pizziola used (fulcrum) was never endorsed by him or the Sartin group. FU 8 Par 6 Pizzolla writes This is not new and by no means original with me. Doc Sartin presented just this approach during my first phone call with him 7 years ago As I said before if Doc did not endorse this seems to me he would have mentioned it in writing not some I heard this point of view Doesn't matter if you like Pizzolla or not but at one time was a important piece to the methodology |
I think that before we go too far astray we should remember that there have been many advances in the methodology in how to select contenders. . The fulcrum, TPR, sr+tv, total energy, even the Beyer numbers. Each of us is free to choose whichever we feel comfortable with and gets the winner in our top 4 or 5 on a consistent basis. We are also free to use the matchup or best of the last 3 comparable etc to choose our pacelines. If one takes the time to listen to some of the seminar audio tapes[Vegas 1992 is a good one] you will hear how teaching members arrived at contenders and pacelines. A lot of divergent methods to be sure but all part of the methodology. Keep records and you will know what works for you.
Tim G |
Quote:
It's all a buffet. Take what suits your preference. A lot of Sartin users don't use the Match Up. It's still all Sartin. |
Some may be surprised to hear this but I don't use the match up. I know it, have used it and can also employ it. However I'm smart enough to know I can't outperform the computer and the match up is included in RDSS and Sartin later programs. At seminars "The Hat" never told anyone to give up computers. While I have a great understanding of entropy, the match up etc. I'm smart enough to know I can't compete with the computer. Most members don't realize the amount of math and calculations involved which if applied by hand is error prone and very slow.Your not going to get too many races done.
My reason for defending the Bradshaw match up are:1. While Pizzola mentions the match up at least 6 different times in FU #8 it is not the match up and as he states, it is his approach, it doesn't use the 1st FR, when the "Doc & or Bradshaw incorporated all 3 Fr's the results greatly improved and the "Doc"said that any pace method that did not include all 3 Fr's is not pace handicapping. 2. From the match up all the later programs evolved to what we now have in RDSS with the match up included in its readouts. The match up was one of a few big breakthroughs, another entropy and or deceleration that really propelled everything to what we have today. Today with RDSS its all very simple as compared to doing hand calculations years ago. Nothing Pizzola ever did within Sartin was any great break through or propelled the group forward such as Brohammer , Bradshaw etc. Yes it is a buffet as MikeB stated so choose wisely, eat healthy and I'm sure everything will get sampled there. Let record keeping be your taste buds and you'll do well. Mitch44 |
Just to clear things up as Bill stated I never said the fulcrum and the match up were the same.
I was just commenting about your statement that the Sartin group never endorsed the fulcrum yet there it was in black and white that Doc had gone over this approach years before with Pizzolla If I am not mistaken you tried Black Magic with not much success, seems strange why if you have this dislike for Pizzolla's teachings why would you try it in the first place. |
Hi shoeless,
Just for clarity I don't recall you said the fulcrum and the match up were the same. Not sure where that comes from, my original post was to answer a question from a member who was confused about the two. Confusion about the two can happen to anyone about the two. All I did was clarity the two. That individual can choose any path he wants however he should get an answer to his original question. I have absolutely nothing at stake in what he chooses to do, I'm not selling anything etc. As far as Sartin going over the fulcrum years before Pizzola I totally disagree as I said in a previous post that paragraph is vague and says absolutely nothing except the "Doc" got him started several years prior but he does not specifically say in which way but alludes to something in the pervious paragraph. Now you can read into that anything you want or so can anyone else but the facts aren't there. You are absolutely correct that I have tried Black Magic in the past and found it to be a very poor product after giving a fair 90 day trial. That trial included record keeping, testing. I will say this about the product and that is he does honor his money back guarantee. Now that's not an endorsement just a fact. Now one of the reasons that I tried it is that I'm a progressive horse player who is open to new ideas, theories etc. I can read the worse book on racing and if I can garner one little nugget out of it I'm a happy camper. Those that are not opened minded are stuck in the pass and never will progress. Myself I'm happy to ride in a car with AC, power windows, disk brakes etc. And Sartin introduced me to computer and I've progressed as the programs have progressed. I have also used Aodds and when "The Hat" passed I went to Bris. You can knock me on that also. At that time Sartin was going through some growing pains and nothing like what RDSS is at present. Actually I use a combination of both. Oh yea before knocking me about it I think Ted is including some of their stuff in the new RDSS. While I'm good with stretch out and cutbacks etc. and can figure this stuff myself I fine that RDSS can do it more efficiently w/ out mistakes, plus some other nuggets which for me makes sense to use a combination of both. IMO Pizzola's stuff; fulcrum, PBS#, BM and his method of picking contenders along with what he alludes to be the match up which it isn't, is crap and that is derived by my record keeping, testing and personnel experience. Everyone has the freedom to choose their own path. I wish all horse players the best with whatever they use however if its not working I would suggest change, if contented and it isn't broke leave it alone. Mitch 44 |
I took a lot of good from reading Pizzola's Handicapping Magic.
I can see how the Fulcrum and his PPF can be used to help the handicapping process in many events. The PBS number (whatever chapter that was in) I had to read 3 times only for the sake of not laughing at it too soon. Mike |
Mitch
How do you like living in the Villages? A buddy of mine was telling me I should retire there |
Absolutely love it shoeless. A real terrific place. If you ever visit your friend or get around here look me up or contact me, I'll show you around. Its is like Disneyland for adults.
Mitch44 |
Thanks
|
and beat goes on.......
|
Photo
Hi
Pino I can't find the photo of "Binder" day from Laurel I know I have the actual photo some place, I think my mom has it In her stuff, in NJ. but in her condition, I don't want to make her worry and try to find it. I will be going to NJ in about 2 weeks , hope I can get routed there sooner. I tried to do a site search but I did not see it, I want to see it again, It was a great day , Mom actually has her world famous VDC Messenger hat in her hands LOL Bill |
Bill,
I never got a copy of that photo I remember it was you, your parents, Pino and RX Lawyer (Gary) and some of his family Wonder what happened to Gary he was a really nice guy and very good with the Energy program, Pino and I met him once in Atlantic City Also wonder about Phase III lives (Jeff) and his son they were very nice as well. After his Mom passed who he was very close to lost touch with him Still remember that day we were at Pimlico where in the 9th at Delaware Pino picked that 50-1 shot using Synergism, unfortunately none of us had him. |
Photo
Quote:
That day at Pimlico when Pino hit that 50/1 shot, !! wow that was so fun. I think what made it so cool , it was the last race of the day so we all got to leave on a real nice high note. |
I did a search here and I couldn't locate them, like to post em on my FB page, let me dig deeper,
Bill, my best to Brooks and Mrs. Varone. Jeff, don't be a stranger. |
Pino will be in touch
Bill really hoping for all the best for your Mom and that your Dad is holding up well, I really enjoyed when they came to our Maryland gatherings |
Come to remember that it was RX Lawyer who got the Hat to first post up here, he was good friends with him.
|
Quote:
I must be in the minority, but there was not much in Pizzolla book for me that I thougt could not be better evaluated by another method. For example I thought sustained pace was a better way to evaluate Turf horses than his final fraction method. But that's just me |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:39 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.