Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   Sartin Methodology Handicapping 101 (102 ...) (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=116)
-   -   History of the Methodology (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=10716)

kpmats10 11-07-2016 02:22 PM

History of the Methodology
 
I'm feeling a bit reflective. Maybe I'm just licking my wounds from a brutal weekend at the BC. But can I get a history lesson?

I was first introduced to incremental breakdowns of a race and pace handicapping when I picked up the revised edition of Modern Pace Handicapping 10 years ago. I read it, studied it, and have been applying the concepts laid out within it since. Some successes have been reached that would've not been possible without the knowledge in the book. I actually paid a hefty sum to have a custom program written to apply the mathematical formulas and make various adjustments in the book.

Come to find this website and I signed up some time ago and never really took advantage of all the material laid out here. I'm here because I want to be a winning player. But where does one start? Come to find out reading all the material here there is much more to the Methodology and practice of pace handicapping than just Brohamer's book. When trying to read through the manuals and Follow Up's, there's a lot of info in there on systems, programs, etc that aren't clearly explained in previous issues; how to use the programs, what the readouts mean, etc and most of which are obsolete. Even paceline selection seems to have many different rules and applications that has changed over and over.

I'm trying to be a winning player. I want to improve my ROI. This year, I'm showing a flat bet profit on win and double wagers. I'm trying to learn self discipline to focus on only those wagers and focus on non maiden races.

My main question here is, if you are about to jump into this concept brand new, where would you recommend someone start? What is obsolete in terms of manual readings? What is relevant today and how do you find updated information?

I'm not afraid to do the work to get to where I want to be. But I feel lost in a big world, if that makes any sense.

Mitch44 11-07-2016 05:48 PM

I understand your dilemma completely. The present RDSS program and the new one that Ted is working on contain everything in one place. E.g. Pace Makes the Race, Brohamer's book , the Match Up, FPS calculations, % Median, calculations to consistently convert difference distances to today race distance etc. etc. etc.

Ted recommends reading only the later issues of the Follow Up to lessen the confusion. Only those that been around many years have the ability to sort through the old FU's and can determine what's relevant and what's isn't. It can help one to determine how something evolved to today concepts but probably confuses the hell out of most, because some of that stuff was incorporated into other programs and also improved on while some was just eliminated. The "Doc" always said that you don't really need to know a formula to make it work I.e. you don't need to be a mechanic to drive a car or a computer geek to operate a computer and there in lies the rub that people just can't get away from.

In a forum setting such as this there are a variety of opinions and a newcomer doesn't know what to believe or whom. Many have latched onto things and refuse to accept later concepts and teaching. All this has a negative effect on someone trying to learn and I'm sure contributes to a high number of failures. What to do?

Personally I'd like to see the teachers and most experience members comb through every Follow Up and blacken out any thing that has been superseded, outdated or has been replaced. I e. get rid of % Early and only leave the later improvement of % Median which used all 3 fractions and improved it greatly. I do however think TPR while only using SC and 3rd FR. is still a valid concept and a springboard for beginners to other later programs. As far as the site it needs to be cleaned up and erroneous comments and outdated ones need to be removed. Perhaps separate opinion stuff or Breeders Cup stuff from actual facts, formulas and current stuff. One hell of a monumental task.

To get you off on the right foot I would suggest you read any comment, post and stuff written by Ted. Ted is overwhelmed now with the new program but perhaps in the future can put all his posts etc. in one place and eliminate the old stuff from years ago that may not be current.

Conceptually it comes down to:1. picking contenders, 2.picking pace lines, 3.readout interpretation and 4.record keeping. Good luck kpmats10.
Mitch44

kpmats10 11-07-2016 08:00 PM

Thank you Mitch for your detailed thoughts

Mark 11-08-2016 12:58 AM

Jim Bradshaw's Match Up
 
I have been at this game for over 50 years. I have tried just about everything. Going on 4 years ago I found the Hat Check blog. I read and reread, studied and practiced what was taught there by Jim through Richie P. Started with Jim's 5 step approach and moved on to the more sophisticated stuff gradually. The most important thing I learned was how horses win races. What is happening in the race that determines the outcome. This is not about number crunching or databases. It is a matter of finding the fastest horses or due to the pace contention in the race, who becomes the fastest horse at the wire. People will tell you all sorts of things but until you can watch a race and recognize what is happening and why the winner won, the best software in the world won't help. Pace makes the race, we know that. But how can I see what that will entail before the race? Will an Early horse get to the lead quickly and be unchallenged? There's your winner. Will the Early horse have to fight his way to the lead and repulse challenges, that is not your winner. If you can project the 1st and 2nd call times that will be run today you will know who will be in front and where the rest of the horses will be. Many times in the posts Richie put up there is the saying from Jim, "Bet the horse closest to the leader positionally, factoring in the pace of today's race"! So if you determine that the winner will not go gate to wire, because of the pace scenario, then look at the Pressers, if they are crappy and can't get to the lead and sustain their effort, then look at the S/Ps. Rarely will an S horse win unless everyone else in front of him is exhausted by the early pace. Forget about all this other stuff and determine where each horse will be at the 1st call. Understand that horses are creatures of habit just as we are and they want to be in certain positions at the 1st call to give their best efforts. That is there Running Style, they are comfortable there. Look at the form and find out what position the horse normally occupies at the 1st call when he wins or runs very close. Read Bradshaw's definitions of Running Styles and memorize them. Work the 5 step approach until you see it in your dreams. Only the few extremely dedicated handicappers will stick with it, so you have a huge challenge. It has taken me nearly 4 years to figure it out and then to use RDSS2 to implement it. But I'm a stubborn SOB and I like money! Good Luck!!

Lt1 11-08-2016 01:29 PM

I've been with the Methodology since 1990 and have seen the evolution take place. I would say to read the follow ups that Ted recommends then work on contender and paceline selection until you can get the winner in your top 5 around 90%of the time. Next decide which approach you feel the most comfortable with the matchup approach of Jimmy B or the compounded ratings that DOC recommended in the later years. If you decide to use RDSS you will able to see both. Both approaches work fine if you enter the true contenders and predictive pacelines. I suggest you keep records and/or track models and profiles. In short establish your comfort zone, and don't be afraid to ask question on this site. Good luck.
Tim G

Bill V. 11-08-2016 01:53 PM

100 %
 
Quote:

I've been with the Methodology since 1990 and have seen the evolution take place. I would say to read the follow ups that Ted recommends then work on contender and paceline selection until you can get the winner in your top 5 around 90%of the time. Next decide which approach you feel the most comfortable with the matchup approach of Jimmy B or the compounded ratings that DOC recommended in the later years. If you decide to use RDSS you will able to see both. Both approaches work fine if you enter the true contenders and predictive pacelines. I suggest you keep records and/or track models and profiles. In short establish your comfort zone, and don't be afraid to ask question on this site. Good luck.
Tim G
Tim

I could not agree more,
Simple and to the point,

Good Skill
Bill

Tim Y 11-08-2016 07:45 PM

No amount of insight, practice or even LUCK can overcome the HISTORICAL difficulty of the closely matched and UNKNOWN qualities of the many potential champions on Breeder's Cup day.

To bet that card is to deny reality of how close EACH contest is.

atkinsrr 11-08-2016 10:28 PM

Tim Y you are so right....I treat the BC as I do any other day of the year...making money to me is more important than betting races...2 days of BC races and I only bet 2 races the whole BC and hit them both....Race 7 Downhill turf I had to bet 3 horses to win #2 Obviously #9 Alot #12 OM #2 Obviously was 5/1 when I made the bet and he got bet heavily near post time but still paid $9.60 Race 11 I had to bet 3 horses to win again #5 Tourist #8 Tepin #9 Ironicus.....Tourist is a horse that I have followed for a long time and has been in 9 G1 races out of his last 10 starts ...he;s the won that made my day couldn't find any other races that I wanted to bet so I just watched

Ted Craven 11-09-2016 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kpmats10 (Post 106245)
I'm feeling a bit reflective. Maybe I'm just licking my wounds from a brutal weekend at the BC. But can I get a history lesson?

...

The Sartin Methodology is a study of horse race analysis and betting practice which Doc Sartin conducted over 25+ years and which has been going on now for over 40 years. It is still going on today: RDSS is a part of the history of the Sartin Methodology. In 2001, at the end of Doc's work, RDSS was known as Validator - in other words, RDSS (a modern Windows-based program) completely and accurately includes Validator, the culmination of Doc's work (along with much else which is still highly congruent with Doc's approach).

Doc's work started with the 'legendary' group of truck drivers convicted of gambling offenses in the late 70s. By whatever poetic stroke of insight and phraseology, he came up with the thesis 'the cure to losing is winning'. It became the motto of the Methodology and lead to all subsequent fact-based enquiries, including the collaboration of many brilliant minds, to prove and elaborate on that idea. Line scores, track class levels, velocity ratings, The Matchup, track profiles and decision (Brohamer) models, point-based Early/Late ratings (TPR), incremental energy disbursement, deceleration, weighted line scores ...

Each subsequent line of enquiry created a foundation for the next enquiry. With each phase, Doc sought to make the process simpler and more straightforward for those interested in making money and checking their egos in the process - without ever succumbing to the simple easy system-seller rules approach of get-rich-quick artists and childish gamblers' fantasies. Anyone who knew Howard, knew ONE thing at least: he CARED about people; he cared about their experience and success in this particular domain, and he cared even more deeply about those who were serious about understanding and applying the ideas he and the group had uncovered. I think he cared more deeply about that than about making money selling software, subscriptions and seminars. Even if he sometimes doubted it in his final years, on that very basis of caring and love alone - he died a very rich man.

So -- it is inconceivable to me that his later works in the Methodology including his final efforts on Validator (and thus --> RDSS) would willfully EXCLUDE useful and valuable tools from earlier phases. He thought Validator was all you needed. Here is what he thought in 2007 about RDSS.

Thus -- if anyone wants to simply dig in and start using the culmination of 40 years of Doc Sartin's thinking on horse racing analysis and betting -- they should simply pay a modest annual fee and start using RDSS. As mentioned, it includes the various flavours and phases of Doc's work. If anyone wants to try out RDSS 2.1 (under development, warts and all) just ask.

All the foregoing built in numbers and adjustments, plus good software tools, has permitted us to use a large measure of automation to select representative pacelines and make Contender choices (although: individual freedom of choice is ALWAYS permitted, for better or for worse). RDSS 2.1 has a new factor Rx, itself a weighted line score of other line scores and other factors like Class (a new and better Class rating), Consistency, public opinion, Early/Late bias. These alone help you get the winner in the Top 4 75-80% of the time (depending on race type and field size) and 80-90% Top 5 -- at better final odds by rank, than Morning Line odds, post time odds or any previous composite factor rank in Methodology history. Out of the box, you start with high level rankings of true contenders: then your work begins, finding good pools to wager in, assessing whether a given race or multi-race wager is priced to your advantage, given the unknowns.

I appreciate those who have favourite aspects of the various phases of the Methodology, and The Matchup. We all have history and affection for that history, and/or we all have particular and individual styles of learning or ways of seeing and understanding. We all have inherent biases towards what works, or at least what works best for us. I would not tell ANYONE that the way they apply the Methodology, using RDSS to do it or not, is inferior to another way. Thankfully, not much advice is necessary: our wager records tell the incontrovertible tale, if sometimes an uncomfortable one.

I got a new car last year, a sporty red Nissan Juke, goes fast (sometimes too fast ...) very fun to drive, very safe and functional in Canadian winters. It's not a Tesla or Humvee, but it is pretty much near the culmination of 120 years of automotive engineering. If the 'apocolypse' comes - I could not reproduce that car myself, I don't really understand combustion engines let alone petroleum exploration and refinement, nor do I understand modern medicine, nor jet airplanes, nor computer transistors and hard drives or how the internet and web servers are truly put together in a functional manner. I mean -- while I USE all these modern tools to live my life, and while I even have a passing interest in the HISTORY of these conveniences, really - what I want is to employ them to get a job done or to live a lifestyle.

I say -- forget about the past history of the Methodology and focus on the 'current history'. I agree, all the Follow Ups and manuals and audios and videos can be too much, except for long term study, understanding how we got here from there, and delving for nuggets of improvement (which ARE there to be found). There needs to be an Archive somewhere on the internet about what Doc did. But I suspect Doc would say that it could lead to too much confusion: start with and stick to current tools (and DID say precisely that in almost every later Follow Up).

We have GREAT analysis tools - better now than in Doc's day, and likely they will get even better. We really don't need many better factors and ratings. My focus in RDSS 2.1, and what will ultimately determine its release schedule sometime next year, is the following broad areas: 1) record keeping, 2) wager construction and submission, 3) deeper tote board and money flow analysis. Those, together with the existing superior and largely automated analysis tools, are how to profit at horse race betting.

You are warmly welcomed to make as much use of these as you wish!

Take care, good luck, good skill!

Ted

Lt1 11-09-2016 01:05 PM

Whether we are successful or not when playing BC races isn't really what this thread is about. KPM is asking for input about how to become a successful investor. We should stay on point since there are other members who maybe struggling like most of us did when we first joined the Methodology. Let those of us who have gained a level of success share how we were able to do so. In the past years a lot of us were fortune enough to attend seminars or to call teaching members and other members who were doing well and pick their brains to up our game. This forum and thread provides the opportunity to give something back. We have seen it in the past with folks like Ted, Bill V, Richie P, FTL and others sharing their knowledge. Let's do it again.
Tim G

Tim Y 11-09-2016 03:45 PM

one of the greatest things OUTSIDE of the methodology is how to wager, WHEN to wager......Something woefully left out over time.

As a handicapper the ideas of the methodology are without PEER, but that is just 50% of the challenge. There are few avenues of improvement offered on that side of the equation, always has been. Handicapping is not wagering and vice versa.

The entire concept of probability, the tricks of wagering options, betting points, take, tracking biases, etc etc, are homeless in the methodology, sadly enough. It takes evaluations OUTSIDE the boundaries of the taught basics to find out just WHEN and HOW to use the contenders outlined by segmental velocity evaluation.

Tim Y 11-09-2016 04:01 PM

Another, more subtle aspect of DECISIONS, are the inborn biases that dictate and bias truly OBJECTIVE evaluations of the same data by any two individuals. These are subtle, below consciousness and one must guard against them all the time.

One only has to read BLINK ( M. Gladwell) Thinking Fast Thinking Slow (Khaneman, Nobel prize winning economist), The Drunkard's Walk: How Randomness Rules Our Lives, by Leonard Mlodinow) or Strangers to Ourselves (Wilson) or The Black Swan by Nassim Nicholas Taleb to witness the subtle, yet domineering internal psychological blocks to our open decision making process.

One of the MOST egregious mistakes we all make to some degree is the Narrative Fallacy: weaving stories of cause and effect over FACTLESS observations and then accepting them a true when we just make up a story to fit what we THOUGHT happened.

A good one in this last category just happened last week. I was told that ARROGATE "exploded" by Chrome to which it noted that a gain of 3 lengths is merely a gain of 3 lenghts and showed several similar closing moves, just in claiming races. Interesting how the same move in a claiming race garners far less value than the same amount of ground made up in a grade one race. Same effect, but psychologically bolstered out of reality by the emotion of the situation at hand.

Mitch44 11-10-2016 09:58 AM

Money management and wagering is an important part of being a successful handicapper. However I don't know how one can put a specific % to it because if you don't have the correct horses its all for naught, game over and on to the next race.

The methodology has addressed this with the two horse bet and created an odds line. The Doc was addressing this as things evolved. Had he remained with us, who can say what else may have came about. He also discussed betting overlays, hiding horses etc.

The Bottom Line betting odds next to the BL Score is a tremendous tool for the handicapper to use. Of course if you put in a bad horse or non- contender than it will provide false readings. Another reason why contender selection is so important to master.

Theory verses experience are entirely two different things. Take a welder with 10 years experience verses someone that read a book on welding, well the book reader is going to lose to the experienced welder. Experience trumps theory. This is also similar to a college grad such as a West Pointer who upon entering the Army thinks he know more that some NCO's that have years of experience or a new cop verses one that's been one for years.

Betting and money management are critical to success however if you don't have the correct horses forget about it. Record keeping will help give a player the experience to evolve in both disciplines.

Mitch44

Lt1 11-10-2016 12:07 PM

I agree with both Tim and Mitch on the money management part of the game. Tim is imo also correct that each of us tends to reach different conclusions as to the information we review in the pps. We all also have our quirks as to paceline selection such as using off track lines on a fast track or dirt or turf lines on the opposite surface today. Once one masters the basics of the Methodology they are free to use whatever approach they like. Additionally record keeping and experience figure in the equation. And like any other profession one must continue to be flexible and keep up with the changes in the game.
Tim G

Tim Y 11-15-2016 12:25 PM

Horses Horses Horses: ONCE you pass over to the wagering side, FORGET about horses...look for mismatched probabilities. THAT is the heart of the wager. The TWO sides of the EQUATION require different disciplines:Handicapping requires innovation, insight, original approaches while the wagering side can, or should be, almost as rigidly RULE based as an accountant.

DON'T LOOK for THE WINNER, only probabilities that several could be the winner or hit the board. Wait, watch the wagering, get an idea where to go ONLY if the crowd allows your selection(s) to be underbet.

Look for races that will soak up and distribute "rookie money" over a wider base so that your odds increase. That would mean staying away from fields of 7 or less. Remember YOUR payout only comes from backed money that did not hit the board. The more horses, the wider is the distribution of monies wagered.

Find races that YOUR data supports that the crowd does not, i.e. finding a track where sustained horses win sprints for example: (Assiniboia for one).

IF the logical favorite is the best, it is a good idea to just watch, OR, if you must wager, let that choice be the KEY to exotics and ride the coat-tails of that favorite. It is often amazing the exotic payoffs when an "odds on" horse runs third.

You have to change thinking when you move over to the wagering side of the equation.

turtleman 11-17-2016 03:06 AM

Here's what I have stared to do in the last few days.
Print out and start to read the yellow manual.
Start listening to Tom Brohamer audio series.
Pick a track and build a track profile.
Start to apply what I have read and listened to.
Assess results, repeat steps 1 and 2, make adjustments!!

Lt1 11-17-2016 03:05 PM

May I suggest you also start a track model in conjunction with your track profile. They are 2 distinct tools to use. The model is based on your hanicapping from pps while the profile is based on result charts. I would also recommend reading the later issues of the followups that Ted has outlined. Take your time.
Tim G

turtleman 11-17-2016 10:53 PM

Thanks Tim
Yep, I am also going to start a model and i would appreciate your ideas as to what to include.
When I first started with rdss Ted advised me what to read, and I did read the follow ups and parts of the yellow manual. When I first started to use the software I think I was overwhelmed with all the data and did not have any structure to my capping. this is my attempt to simplify things and get back to basics.
The other thing I haven't done is ask enough questions, because I know there are a lot of great people on this site that are willing to help.

Thanks again for your help!!

Tom

Lt1 11-18-2016 11:40 AM

Tom models usually consist of the factors that the person keeping them feels is important for them to monitor. I myself limit my models to the rankings of the winner in EP,LP,CPR,VDC.and %MED. Others will track TPR ranking, some will add TE and still others will add TT and BL/BL rankings. I would suggest listening to the tape on the Brohamer model. In other words you determine what to model but I believe making it complicated with too many factors is counterproductive. Hope this helps. Feel free to send me a PM anytime you want.

Tim

turtleman 11-18-2016 06:44 PM

Hi Tim
What if the winner is not one of my top contenders, do I still put it in the model?

Tom

Tim Y 11-18-2016 07:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turtleman (Post 106348)
Hi Tim
What if the winner is not one of my top contenders, do I still put it in the model?

use the line you chose no matter if the one was a contender or not

Lt1 11-18-2016 11:27 PM

Good question. I don't but others will go back and pick a line and then enter it. I'll go back and look at the horse and see if I missed something. In your case you might want to consider marking an x in each factor to indicate you didn't have it as a contender and if you begin to see too many of these you should review you contender and paceline selection. Nothing gets the winner 100% of the time.
Tim

Lt1 11-19-2016 11:12 AM

Tom I also recommend that you keep 20 race cycle forms to let you see from what tier your winners are coming from. The goal is to have most of your winners in the top 3. Too many in tier 4 & 5 will also indicate a contender and paceline selection review.
Tim

Bill V. 11-19-2016 01:26 PM

Na
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by turtleman (Post 106348)
Hi Tim
What if the winner is not one of my top contenders, do I still put it in the model?

Tom

Hey Tom

Tim G (LT1) is really giving you A1 help ..

I follow Tim's advice about record keeping
I also keep track of the race class , the actual RDSS notations and the TM RC
When I get a race were the winner is not one of my contenders I enter
NA or X
This is a tool I use when structuring my horizontal bets , doubles P3 P4 P5
Its good info to know which races tend to favor the ML favorites and the races that tend to come up with longer price winners.

Good Skill
Bill

Tim Y 11-20-2016 10:23 AM

Sample error. Two years ago I listened to a lecture on line about statistical analysis and it hit home. The lecturer pointed out that looking first at the BEST most outstanding effort (like Frosted, an known in and outer might get you to select), you are getting a skewed idea of what the animal is capable of since we all know the basic statistical principle of returning to the MEAN. One stand out performance is the OUTLIER, not the norm.

The best actuarials (the principle evaluations that insurance companies use to access liabilities) are based upon HUGE samples. The Theory of Large Numbers requires that a large database be evaluated before the results are representative of real life.

We do not have this luxury so we have to find a way around it.

In the Speculator program, there is an area called the Long Shot detector which evaluated the pace of race of each horse. I found it best for Match Up reasons to find similar paces of race (make the horse's be under similar pace pressures before evaluating them). Find several appropriate lines and use them, by themselves, to see how each horse handled that pace of race, particularly asking the question: DID any of these efforts push the horse out of it NORMAL ESP status? Then go back and you compare the other contenders to these lines.

I would try never to wager on horses that did not show at least two similar efforts coming into today's contest.

Tim Y 11-20-2016 10:32 AM

Further on that point, I discovered, INDEPENDENTLY of several other pace handicappers (i.e. Dave Schwartz calls this 2BE or two best ever), the idea I call Two Lines Better than the Field and wrote about it many years ago.

If you can find TWO pace lines and these point to it being the best this race, the chances of that horse doing very well are high. NO ONE GETS RICH on these horses as they are not secrets, but they are solid contenders that I usually use as KEYS in exotics.

Boiling it down, the only differences in one horse or another (and it has NOTHING to do with Man Made class levels) is the ability to handle a narrower (cheap stock) or wider (best stock) range of pace pressures. Horses don't know they are 12.5K or 30K level horses, but the pace of those races will differentiate the two animals.

turtleman 11-21-2016 12:10 AM

Thanks Lt1, TimY and Bill V
I really appreciate all of your input. I will have to reread your posts several times to digest everything. One thing I have realized in the last week is that it takes a lot of discipline to become a good capper.

Thanks again
Tom

DontSayDont 11-21-2016 08:42 AM

Theory of large numbers
 
Quote:

"The Theory of Large Numbers requires that a large database be evaluated before the results are representative of real life."
This theory is something I wonder about when it comes to handicapping. In order to have a large db it would have to go back to times when training was done different from today. There is a poster on here with a db with over 1 million entries that show horses that are off over 120 days to win only about 2% iirc. In fact I believe he won't use a horse off over 90 days as a win contender.

Today's training methods with regards to days off is very different from 15 - 25 years ago. Used to be a horse should be coming back in 14-21 days and even have a workout. This is the information that would be stored in the db. Fast forward to today and there are a lot more horses coming from much longer periods between races. It would require many thousands of races before the win % could be reflected in the db to change that 2% to a percentage usable in today's handicapping practice.

Therefore it is MY belief that it is not necessary to have a large amount of numbers to evaluate some profitable handicapping profiles. I don't have any mathematical proof to back my theory.

Ray

Tim Y 11-21-2016 12:18 PM

What do many statistics actually tell us?

I constantly hear conclusions reached on SKEWED inadequate data. Just recently I was discussing how trainer stats (because of their VERY limited and dynamic changes) are so full of holes when viewed objectively.

Trainer Smith is a 45% trainer of 3 year old fillies. He may have 8 3 y/o fillies but ONE of them accounted for just about all the wins. Is HE that great a trainer, or RATHER, does he not have a great FILLY in his barn? Also IF you look at these same data over a long period of time, with the changing nature of many a barn in the make up of their stock running, one season to the other this same trainer may hardly have ANY 3 y/o fillies in the barn.

Troy Taylor, a respected journeyman trainer in Vancouver had never been in the top ten trainers at Hastings since 1965. He was contacted by a generous, horse loving benefactor (Glenn Todd who was the force behind Mario Gutierrez's transition to greatness) who cares a lot for the game and was not afraid to spend money to get many low level stakes horses off the tracks at Pimlico, the Fair Grounds and Saratoga and bring them west. This influx of great stock gave this journeyman trainer a great edge on HIS competition and LO and BEHOLD, ever since the marriage of these two forces, TAYLOR has been leading trainer at Hastings. Did HE, all of a sudden, get to be a prodigy or, did the horses get better? Just like the pass receiving percentage for quarterbacks is too dependent upon their receivers rather than the thrower, statistics on the trainer are overly influenced by the level of stock one has in the barn. As such they should not be trusted.

BASIC statistical analysis has to be viewed in this light or we are lost at making the realistic conclusions.

Read THE DRUNKARD'S WALK: How Randomness Rules Our Lives, and it will make you have a completely new interpretation on the LIMITED conclusions we can take from poorly set up, but somehow trusted statistical evaluations.

Mitch44 11-21-2016 06:03 PM

DontSayDont; IMO you absolutely nailed this. An overly large data base isn't necessary to get good data and the larger it is the harder it is to change it by recent and better data.

Yes todays trainer methods have changed due to better equ.,feed and a host of other reasons that render a large and old database useless. In fact if one were to include class levels(@ least 20 or so levels) the whole study of days between races would change because better class horses can be trained up to a race and cheaper horses generally need to be raced into condition. If your not breaking this stuff down by the basics of horseracing such as conditions of races I.e.( sex, dis., class, surface etc.) your going to end up with a flawed study.

Those with overly large data bases spend little time playing and almost all their time managing their database. HUGE samples??? I don't think so as life actuaries are broken down by many different things, I.e., stress in a large city is a factor as compared to suburban dwellers and different races are subject to different diseases.

Now to each their own however this is how I do it and handle this problem. In the very early 90's I learned from the "Doc" at a seminar at Saratoga that the same thing will happen in a sample of 20 that will happen in a sample of 100 etc. If you want to round off or break ties the "Doc" suggested using 21. This is what I have always used and it has served me very well over the years. Survey a sample of 21 then make a decision to abandon it or confirm with a larger sample by adding to it. I add to it for a sample of 50 and absolutely no more than a sample of 100 for those promising ideas only. Ideas that aren't promising are abandon after 20 or 21 sample size. I can test many more ideas with this technique then obtaining a HUGE data base hoping it may turn into something after it has long proven not to be a worthwhile endeavor. As I said this is how I handle studies, samples, data, factors etc. As "The Hat" would say "Use what you have" whether a trainer stat that all came from one horse or not if that's all you have than use it; It shows that the trainer is capable, if the horse has the ability he'll get it out of the horse. Of course you can refine any trainer stat with your own take on it, if your aware the stat all came from one horse well that's a big edge over the public. Your own studies will always outperform someone else's data. Hope this nugget helps as it has served me well for many years.
Mitch44

Bill V. 11-21-2016 07:32 PM

Mitch and Ray
 
A great big THANK YOU

I would suggest to Tom to build his record keeping SLOWLY
Try not to track too many factors at first but Slowly add additional factors, only after you are confident in what is happing with your beginning factors.


For me I only keep records for either Del Mar or Santa Anita*
I make my serious money betting into group tickets with sharp partners. at Socal .
When I got into making bets with big timers I realized I better know what I was bringing to the table, saying I like a horse because its tier 3 on blbl ...well :o, I would just get blank stares, I also notice the winners I was with all kept RECORDS

Now Ray and Mitch you are so right. I track many things now but I constantly try to hone down my database into smaller bits.
Mitch I agree about the most recent 20 races being what Doc recommends.

I save everything so my model and profile always includes the date race
and race number as well as the winner, what it paid and any scratches
This way I can go back and start to add more factors to races in my database
by going back into the race , Lets say I want to add a factor like trainers who
win off long layoffs, since my model shows me the race info I just reopen RDSS and grab the trainers info , Since I already have the DSLR infor factor
Its a snap to add the trainer name ,
I record every race each day onto the main worksheet I then copy and paste
races onto other work sheets for example
My main Del Mar work sheet has 412 races
but after each race I copy the race and paste it to a specific type worksheet,
For Del Mar Turf races I have 4 separate worksheets
Turf Sprints, Turf 1 Mile, Turf Long ( 8.5 or longer ) and Maiden Turf
After awhile, I will break these specialized work sheets down again into
male of female, then by age maybe someday into purse value or claiming , non claiming ect.

This system helps me keep my sample sizes not to over whelming
I can also feel confident to single horses In Tims example above he mentioned a 45% trainer with 3 year old fillies,
I have this type info and if I can spot this pattern in a race were yes the 45 percent guy is sharp but I also can see what the other trainers in the race are capable of doing with 3 year old fillies Trainer info is a tool but any database is only as good as the quality of the paceline selection method
used to generate the numbers.

In summary.
Keep records but focus on pacelines and contenders and build your work slowly,

Good Sill
Bill

ps

*I have year's worth of Parx but being mostly on the west cost I am now spoiled. Now I love fast tracks with little DTV crap so I only "play" Parx and Monmouth and NYRA for entertainment and to help my dad

Tim Y 11-22-2016 12:58 PM

I have found that modeling by RANKING does not work since they do not represent objective numbers that the horse created by challenging the pace of the race they were in.

Let's say total energies of a group are 160.5, 160.45, 160.42, 160.33. 160.21 as compare to rankings at the same relative level, are 160.9. 160.45. 160.01, 159.55, 159.21. The first group's rankings are skewed as directly compared to the second. Rankings are too dependent upon the range of the GROUP and cannot be compared directly.

% median, early/late balance, ESP range for the distance, etc, are OBJECTIVE

Lt1 11-22-2016 03:21 PM

Tim I have found rankings do work very well for me in factors such as EPR,LPR,CPR,AND VDC. When it comes to %med rather then ranking by number I establish an acceptable range for the distance and class concerned.
Tim G

Tim Y 11-22-2016 03:31 PM

Some factors are UNIVERSAL with only slight variances, i.e. early/late balance from the line USED to evaluate the animal COMING INTO the race.

No matter if you follow the earliest of the earlies (inner Aqu, Fort Erie, Parx) where the 6 furlong e/l is high +4 to +12, or a more presser track (Oaklawn) there are all within a close range of one another. The OUTLIER here would be the Fair Grounds with the inordinately LONG home stretch. As a reminder, the RANGE of e/l's on the grass is huge and the better thing to monitor is deceleration: Most grass races are won by horses in the 98.5 to 105 range. THERE ARE EXCEPTIONS, like Woodbine with its very long stretch.

Also, it is a good idea, at least twice a month, to search out a NEW venue that you have never tried before to see how your brand of selections work there. Laurel would be a good place to start (big fields classier than average horses). Canterbury has nice fields, works with the methodology except the prices are not great due to smaller than average field size. STAY away from fields of 6 or 7 horses.

Mark 11-22-2016 05:43 PM

Dream Race
 
I assume that the Segment Screen is based on the Dream race of Thoromation fame.
With adequate consistent contender selection the best fractions from the group of horses will be used to establish the rankings of each contender by racing segment and compounded factors on the Energy Screen.

Applied consistently this should overcome your objections. The program applies the same rules to all pacelines and beaten lengths whether you agree with this or not, that is the Sartin methodology. I, personally, am skeptical of the 3rd fraction calculations and the adjustment process used. It makes absolutely no sense to me to apply final time adjustments to the 1st fraction but that is the way it is. It just puts the responsibility upon the user to pick accurate pacelines and avoid aberrant ones.

Tim Y 11-22-2016 06:05 PM

I rarely ever use the third fraction evaluations except on TURF or marathons. The hidden energy is a better one. Deceleration standards are even better for turf lines.

My bone of contention with that 3rd fraction is that many a race is OVER midstretch and a winner does not persist with an all out effort. The "race" is early, always has been as those are the movers and shakers in the field.

The "passive" horses, (FAR OFF THE PACE OF THE RACE), content to just try and catch those actually "racing" are UNRELIABLE to put it mildly.

kpmats10 12-06-2016 04:40 PM

Thank you for all your pointers, some great reads here as well. I welcome the opportunity to speak to anyone willing to work with me collaboratively or individually. Like I said, I'm here to learn.

Here's where I'm at in my handicapping -

I started tracking myself in 20 race cycles. Mentally, that's been a big help and when I look at my cycle, it's not overwhelming if there's a bad day or two in there because I feel like I can pick myself up. Losing feels less, shall I say, demoralizing? That said, my contender selection is 90%. In my most recent cycle, it was 90% with one of the two horses I missed was a 30-1 longshot. Don't feel too bad about missing out on that. I'm not chasing bomb winners, I'm chasing winners, period, and profit.

My winning percentage though is around 40% betting two horses to win. And not showing a profit. Problem.

My homemade software automatically makes adjustments for distance, surface, track speed based off the DRF variant. It then calculates velocity for the incremental fractions, AP, EP, SP, FX for sprints and rankings for each. Also, creates %E. At the end of the day, the data is stored into a Brohamer model for all the rankings. I'm not currently tracking by class, but am tracking by distance and surface. It also makes TPR ratings and these also go into a model.

I also won a bunch of old Sartin programs as part of an ebay package several years ago and just recently discovered what I have and how to get them to open, but have no idea how to use them - Phase III with the Match Up, Pace Launcher 3 and Synergism 1A (I think)
I also make a track profile everyday.

I'm not presently an RDSS subscriber and am hesitant to become one solely because the money I spent on my own software was large (and it is customizable to add/subtract/change anything I've already created) and the data files I use work with two other programs I use. I can't justify the expense of more data files, especially to make a daily model means being a daily downloader. I wish RDSS was compatible with Brisnet or other data files.

Where I THINK I'm struggling -

PROPER paceline selection. What I mean by that is, I generally will use the last race unless there are reasons to go back (wrong surface, distance, trouble trip, etc). Generally my pacelines are in the last three races. But I have questions -

One thing I'd like to do much better on is projecting today's pace. I've read PMTR and started using the fulcrum method a bit. It's pretty good in getting you at least close to what the projected pace of today's race could be. So let's say you have your fulcrum horse. When looking for horses to rate against the probable pace, do you select + or (+) races against that pace? If you have a horse who's last race was a + and no excuse to go back other than a + race 2 back is at today's fulcrum EP fraction, what line would you use? Or is it better to use the most recent + line for each contender, regardless of what probable pace be and bet off your model rankings?

I've been reading the Match Up forum, and I can't seem to get the 5 steps down. Look at a horse's overall record and pacelines to guess it's projected pace? Does that mean looking at all 10 lines? Even if recently it's not running back to those numbers?

Self reflection says I may be leaning to heavy on my models to make my wagering decisions, but maybe the models are wrong because of my improper paceline selection.

Or I'm playing races where I think there's a vulnerable favorite and losing to a low priced chalk horse instead of taking the easy money.

Does anyone go over losing races anymore like they used to in the Follow Up?

I feel like I might be all over the place in this post and may not be expressing myself coherently. I want to learn to be better, that's the bottom line for me.

Tim Y 12-06-2016 05:54 PM

Here is some help: NEVER go on a single pace line or you WILL get the scourge of SAMPLE ERROR.

Find the fastest pace of race that each ran against: HOW did they do? Could that pace of race be the same today? If an entrant could not keep up to a 45.3 and the rest of the horses can, ELIMINATE that one.

ONLY wager on opportunities that are OVERLAID, or if none are available, PASS the contest. THE WAGERING SIDE IS THE MOST DIFFICULT THING TO LEARN, not the handicapping.

Dick Mitchell did a great article years ago that simple stated: "Even in the best of evaluation systems, the odds are that you have a good chance of going 7 races in a row without collecting. THAT is possible. Do not let that change your approach."

Try to ONLY bet in fields of 7 or more so as to spread out the monies enough so that HUGE favorites can be defused throughout the odds board. ANYTHING at 6 or under, is USUALLY, a waste of time even to bother with.

Tim Y 12-06-2016 06:40 PM

Another thing: we get paid from the monies that the crowd does NOT BET on the horses that hit the board. LEARN to know booking points and how much remains in the field after you have made selections. Don't think of odds as much as HOW much of the field does that entrant represent. Remember the field is represented as around 125% to account for the take out.

A very good article on that was printed for the American Quarter Horse Association in an article explaining how the morning line is written.

Here is that reference. It shows how to understand booking points.

https://aqha.com/racing/pages/racing...-morning-line/

Mitch44 12-06-2016 11:00 PM

kpmats10:

To solve any problem the first thing one must do is recognize that there is a problem.

Your own record keeping has shown your pace line selection is a huge problem and greatly contributes to that low 40% win rate. I follow the "Doc's" teachings of using the best of the last 3 at a similar distance and surface. There are several reasons why the last race may not be correct such as coming from off a layoff and needing that race and not performing to its true potential. Perhaps that race was just a conditioning race up in class to sit out the jail time off a claim etc. I try to stay within 1/2 F of todays distance and no more than 1 F max in selecting a pace line. The least you have to project the better off you are and races are just run different as distance increases.

In your own program using the DRF variant is basically ok in that your using a consistent procedure to do so. Anyone could argue for a better one but as long as you are consistent is a key. Where you may have a problem is how you proportion that variant among your fractions and figures. And that varies among different distances because at 6F the SC is 66.6666 % and at 8F its 75% so it depends weather your using SC & 3rd FR or all 3 FR's etc. I would investigate this with correct selected pace lines for a 20 race cycle to determine if that's the problem and whether your variant distribution can be improved upon. Getting from 40% to 60% + is more than just pace line selection. You can't just treat all race distances as 66.6666 % at the second call.

I still do post mortems, even knowing "The Hat" didn't believe in looking back. They can correct errors and really build your confidence knowing you made no mistake.

Not selecting correct pace lines and distributing a variant incorrectly will make your model useless because a model reflects your handicapping.

I understand when you say you invested much time and money into your own program. But I would recommend cutting your loses if your not winning and only getting 40% winners or making what you have better. The stuff in your program isn't the best of the Sartin stuff and was improved upon in later programs. RDSS contains all the latest programs up until the "Doc" passed and it can help you to pick better pace lines as just one example. Ted gives a free trial period so the cost is minimal or nothing if you just use the examples that come with it. With a free trial it won't cost you any further investment and you can determine if it ups your game or not.

I'm not a believer in the Fulcrum and stated some reasons as to why in another post, just 2 were mentioned above in using the last line. The Match Up is a valid concept and was the springboard for later programs and concepts.

Mitch44


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:26 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.