![]() |
Paceline Selection - some observation
One observation re: my paceline selections early on in my journey compared to recently... earlier on, if Line 1 was an outlying 0 line - not beaten badly, but not good enough to be considered a (+) and typically a "Front Half of the field" performance, I was treating it as a non-comparable race for ratings purposes and moving backwards, usually settling with a + or (+) line from L2 or L3 providing it was recent and at or near today's distance. Typically, that race would end up coincidentally being the best of last 3 Adjusted Speed Rating. This "loose" approach was working for me.
I am aware that in the Paceline Manual, the guideline is to always consider the last line unless there is a valid excuse to go back further, and that "last line" can be expanded upon in various ways (e.g. last line before layoff, last line before trip trouble, last line on a dry track, etc). Rather than summarily dismissing a runner off a last out "0", I interpreted this particular "0" line - regardless of whether there was trouble - as I explained above, as a reason to backtrack. At some point, I began changing my tune towards this, even though it was putting me on some winners. I began to really become tight with FTL's guidelines. Granted, FTL's guidelines are founded on logic and on his own personal research/experience (I give him 2 thumbs up for his hard work!) and can keep someone new to racing or the Methodology in general from getting themselves into constant poor decision making. The skill of passing races with too many unknown variables is just as valuable as being able to select pacelines and contenders, IMO. Anyway, I began to tighten my standards, started mixing with other suggestions that members here have thrown in my direction, but with no success. I'm not pointing fingers, far from it - I make the decisions about pacelines, contention and wagers, not the members of Pace and Cap. The information disseminated by this group is invaluable, but as has been mentioned, if we focus on too many factors, the amount of noise increases. Same goes for taking too many voices at heart. The noise increases and it becomes difficult to maintain any consistency. Today, after Tampa, I looked back at many of my selections from earlier in the month when as one would put it, "life was good!" I could see that my line selections were more intuitive rather than rigid - decisions were made more clearly and rapid fire. Lately, tough decisions have been wrought with second guessing my first instinct. The first instinct, as I've learned from years of test taking in public school and college, is usually correct. I need to play to MY records and intuitively, and not necessarily towards every guideline or axiom known to man. I lost sight of that. Shame on me. Having gotten that out of my system, tomorrow starts a new month and I refuse to be an April Fool! :D |
Jeebs: That pace line manual was written around 1985 and is no longer valid . The "Doc" changed it to the best of the last 3 at a comparable distance.
This still comes down to two important factors ,contenders and pace line selection. Follow Doc's" guidelines and your results will improve dramatically. Pick a race at GP tomorrow and I'll go over picking the lines for that race. Mitch44 |
Hi Jeebs
I hope I have not confused you, We all are here to help each other,
Its important to learn what works, If you feel anxious about what your doing , then keep an open mind and PRACTICE Mitch will graciously help you We all want to see you succeed Bill |
Quote:
www.newyorkracingboard.com if you're interested in the entertainment. Our place is truly special. |
Hi Tim
When Mitch and I joined in 1990 we were taught the best of the last 3 comparable was the method of paceline selection. In Follow Up #81 in the publishers' section Doc clearly states the the last line is no more predictive then lines 2-3-or sometimes 4. That doesn't mean to totally disregard the last line[may indicate a horse going off form]. Later Doc began to favor compounded ratings over the visual matchup. As each of us becomes more versed in the Methodology we tend to have little quirks about why we won't use a certain paceline such as using sly lines on a fast track or lifetime best races by older etc. The bottom line is we must continually evaluate our approach to line selection and above all be consistent with it. Tim G |
I know it's been talked on here a lot before about follow the guidelines, follow the guidelines...
For us novices and not as experienced methodologists, I would like to see more of the teaching members here do a little more instruction, maybe even a live video with open discussion. Gotomeeting.com is an excellent video hosting site that is free for 30 days to anyone with an email address who hasn't registered previously for the free trial. I like what Jeebs is doing, sparking interest and discussion on a daily basis. I'm working offline with a member here who has offered to help me on a one on one basis as requested. Just my thoughts. We're all here to learn, let's see more teaching. |
Hi
Being new to RDSS but not Doc Sartin's Pirco group(I joined in the late 80's after listening to some Dick Mitchell tapes were he told of the Sartin Methodology) I took off over 12 years of handicapping because of family concerns,discovering Ebay to sell my 30,000 worth of 45's and the complete destruction by the idiot legislature that totally destroyed Michigan horse racing and caused the Ladbrook corporation to demolish Detroit Race Course,which I loved. Hazel Park which gave up racing to concentrate on Harness,which fell apart for them in the past few years and now run simulcasting and so called racing?? of 3 legged animals on Friday and Saturday nights I too would like more and more teaching posts and certainly more VIDEO posts! I learned so much from Ted,Bill and Ritchie's video's! One problem seemed to be on some Video's the teacher's said they would do some races later and as far as I know,never did them I respect all who respond here and Ted has been more that helpful! A true class act! I am having some problems lately with understanding some readouts but will post specific questions when I can Hope to hear some more from teaching members Papa John |
I feel a key takeaway that I got from my "tune up" with Mitch44 was in utilizing the entire past performance record. It is very easy to get "zoned" into the last 3-4 races, that one fails to evaluate how it got to its current form and condition. Pace is "the matchup" and it is vital to evaluate how horses have performed under previous pace conditions comparable to today's. Both Perceptor totals and Total Energy can open up many clues.
|
Hi KP and Papa. Unlike the old days when Doc named those he wanted as teaching members I don't believe outside of Ted and Bill V that there are any official teaching members. What we do have are veteran members who have been posting on various subjects. Perhaps if newer members would post more questions we could get a broad based session going where ideas could be freely exchanged. The problem is the newer folks would have to determine which info they want to accept. Jeebs has done a great job of getting a great back and forth session going. KP has a good idea of selecting and working with another member he has trust in. I'm pretty sure that there are older members here that would lend a hand if asked.
Tim G |
When we're picking pace lines its easy to pick a bad line with an extreme variant for that line. Besides a variant is useless unless its put in context with the others variants from the other horses in the race. I.e. a variant of 40 may be perfectly OK if all the other horses have a similar variant. A 10 variant may appear to be perfectly normal but not when all the others have -13 etc. that's a huge difference of 23.
I strongly suggest after picking all your pace lines go to the BLBL screen then click on the original tab. On this screen are all your horses and to the right it shows all the variants. Don't assume a variant is normal. I.e. a range from 17 to 27 is normal. View them in the context of what's normal for the horses in that race off the Original Tab of the BLBL screen. A -13 may be normal for fast tracks like SA etc. When you see a 10 for the SA as compared to the others -13 Take notice. When you find one that is abnormal go back to the horses chart and try to pick a better line. There will be many times you have the best line and the other lines are even worse. In that case I suggest you view the horses CR or CR+ to determine if its a true contender. Additionally with mixed distances such as having no choice and having to use a 8.5 F line in a 10F race. That horses will destroy your BLBL readouts because of the speed of that race and its an unknown if it can maintain that in a much longer race. The adjustment of a horse like that makes it too fast. Horses going longer have to prove it and deceleration normally takes place somewhere. A horse cutting back generally will run faster and has proven its ratings. View your pace lines in context of distance and total pace. I.E. Same Tot. Energy but one is from a 6F and the other is from 7 F and today race is 7F, advantage 7 F horse because it proven the distance. Reverse that and today is a 6 F race with the same Tot. En. I would still favor the 7 F horse still as it can run faster cutting back in distance. Class is the ability to carry speed over a longer dis. of ground. This will help you with races of mixed distances which is also on the original tab where you'll find the track variant for all your contender etc. Similar total energy or near similar total energy. Mitch44 |
pace line procedure
Thanks to all who have replied!
To Mitch: Can you give a brief explanation on pl and contender selection? You seem to be a great teacher along with Ted,Ritchie P.,For the lead and Bill V. Do you keep a track profile and limit yourself to 1 or 2 tracks? What factors or readouts do you keep track of? Ted has graciously granted me the test version of RDSS.2 and I seem to be getting hung up with trying to use RX. Any thoughts and/or replies would be so appreciated! Papa John:confused: |
Papa which rx factor are you using. I use rx3 and have posted some results in the private testing section comparing it to bl/bl. Remember that in the rx factor line score only vdc is depended on the paceline you select. I have found that on numerous occasions there is a big difference between the rx and bl/bl tiers. I tend to go with rx3 but still lean on my track model and of course final odds. I have also found that horses that rank in the top 4 of both win 67% of my races.
Tim G |
pace line procedure
Hi Tim
I knew there was another poster that I forgot! It was you! I have been using rx1 and the differences are many times not in the top 2 bl BUT now I understand what the rx3 is based on. Is it the same for RX! AND RX2? Thanks for the great and fat reply! Papa:): |
For my pace lines I pick the best of the last 3 at a similar distance and surface. Where ever that takes me is where I go and I don't care if its line 1 or line 10. Out of those last 3 I pick the line with the best Total Energy and Perceptor line. I will go back to 4 if the horse had a trouble line among those 3. When I used the Racing form I totaled the speed rating and variant. At $7 a pop I use it once a year for the Breeders Cup to get a handle on the foreign horses. Its PP's are terrible also,a poor product.When I used BRIS I used the best speed rating of last 3 at a similar dis. & surface. I still use Bris for their PP's for analysis of a horses record because everything is in one place and they contain better and additional information than Trackmaster. Why not go with the best which is RDSS and Bris PP's, plus I get Bris for free. Anyone not sticking to the "Doc's" criteria(best of last 3 at a similar dis. & surface) and using Total Energy in conjunction with Perceptor well good luck with that as you'll need it. The Perceptor is pretty much fool proof and idiot proof as far as earlier versions. I don't look at the class of the lines I choose which is old school circa 1985 Pace line Manual, the Total Energy and Perceptor supersede that. Additionally there are many different classes today that didn't exist years ago, that some are hard to figure out.
If your new I would suggest picking a line for all the horses and scratching by the lowest Total Energy or BLBL which most of the time are the same. You'll get a lot of practice on correct pace line selection also by picking a line for all the horses. I don't use the Fulcrum and flat don't believe in it. The lines you choose is the Match Up and the true fulcrum is within that. Additionally its time wasted that should be used to do a complete review of a horses charts. I don't keep track profiles or models because I play all over the country. The match up of horses supersedes a track profile and model. If I only played one track I would keep track of the number of beaten lengths where a horse has to be at the SC. and one or two other things. I no longer use the tandem process which I used back in the 90's. I find its not any kind of considerable edge, you'll win some and lose some. The concept of it is the change of form among horses however there are many other reasons for reversals such as a horse being at it proper distance,class etc. I don't keep track of any readouts because I don't need to. If your new I suggest you keep a record of factors till you learn what's best within RDSS. I believe data bases are a waste of time and takes away your time for handicapping. Horses race against each other not against a data base. They can be good for some trainer information etc. Large data bases become cumbersome and if not current end up as useless information. Few if any purge all that old data because they have an investment in time gathering it. I don't consider myself a teacher nor want to be. Ted, Bill V and Richie P are teachers within RDSS. I don't mind helping someone out nor does LT1 if asked. This answers how I do it and my thoughts on things and it works for me. Those who are contrarian to this have the right to believe in what ever they want to. I believe in keeping current and adapting as things change. In other words I like my power windows, air condition, power brakes and modern shocks etc. I' not riding around in a 1950 car or model A. One can't be closed minded and must be open to new ideas. If you can't adapt and rid oneself of old pace line selection methods etc. as an example, your doomed to a slow death. Mitch44 |
Hi PAPA. I posted the results of 2 surveys in the private section which you should be able to review now. It showed how bl/bl did vs all 3 rx factors[200races]. I found rx 3 to be the better of the3 but there are many races they are the same. I'm partial to rx3 because of profit line factor which I have used for years. If you don't have access to the private section yet let me know and I'll pm the results to you. The 67 % top 4 was based on rx3.
Tim |
thank you!
Thanks to all of you for the nice and informative relies! I left you out Mitch but it was a oversight on my end! I greatly appreciate you're how to reply! I do read all your posts also.
Thanks again guys Papa John |
Anytime Papa.
Tim |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:03 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.