![]() |
Saratoga Factor Information thru 8/7
1 Attachment(s)
Starts on day 1, does not cover races won by FTS or when more than two FTS or foreign starters in their first outing. There were a couple of days without data because I did not assemble all races. it started out as being a study of the four main factors, but ended up with most of the factors on the RX screen but not CR+, or New pace info. I forgot to show the final contender's TE ranking info and that could be a mistake. I like to look at the TE from POR top horses and compare it to my contenders, especially when making the final cuts to four or three. But just as interesting is a horse from say the #5 POR with only a 4 ranking in the contender mix – usually an easy elimination for win.
Finally, based on my handicapping and my SEGMENTS screen info I recorded the Lengths Back at 2nd call, so on the first worksheet that has all the races, 85% win within 4.5 L at 2nd call; also listed is wins from less than 2.6 L back. All of the worksheets have the same info, but sorted differently. the 2nd sheet is by distance and distances that have top 3 in all races are highlighted in yellow; those with 2 or 3 outside the top three are in light green. I am not finished playing with this info, however. |
Many years ago Tom Brohamer used 5 lengths behind for the Second Call, its a great down and dirty approximation. It can be improved on with a current track profile which would eliminate more horses and tighten up the parameters.
Generally looking at your data and based on my research you did an excellent job on this. I can gather by the data that your Pace Line selection is very good. Also whatever setting your using is getting great results. If you use this data I believe your getting the maximum from the program and only need to have discipline in betting and money management for success. For others you may not get the same results due to settings and the all important selection of Pace Lines and contenders, therefore they should do their own research and collect data to expose their weak areas. Excellent work Bill, your hard work has given you the tools for success. CONGRATS!!! Mitch44 |
Thanks Mitch,
One thing I was surprised at was the LB at 2nd Call data and how much of it was a lot closer than what TIM, LT1, had produced, but having looked at my paceline choices it was clear that several were from lines where the horse was more than 4 L back and it was the internal adjustments in the program that made it come together so that, overall, 63% of winners were no more than 2.5 L back at the 2c call once the program adjusted for variants, etc. For pacelines I try to find representative lines near zero track variant and no more than +/- 5, sometimes +/- 10. I think that above -15 fast tracks give too much advantage to horses with those lines (unless all the contenders have representative lines at that amount), so as a consequence my lines may go a lot deeper in the PPs than others to find those lines, BUT, the lines I choose are within the horse's normal/average running line based on its TPR style. Also, no off tracks on dirt, but firm and good on turf are okay, for me. |
Math Wizards invited!!!
One thing I was hoping by publishing this info was to get someone with a higher degree of math background to possibly distill this information further, through the use of algorithms or other math voodoo to create another factor that might be better than we already have.
ALL MATH WIZARDS DON'T NEED TO APPLY, JUST DIG IN!!! Regards, |
Quote:
Did you have all runners as win contenders when you put each race through the RDSS analysis? Thanks, Mike |
I gave each horse a line consistent with its history as close to the race distance as possible, then during analysis I eliminated down to those horses with the four main factors with top 5 ratings.
Be careful with horses that fail to hit the top 5 in BPP. If you hover your mouse over the BPP column for the #5 horse, check out how close that is only missing a top 5 rank in BPP. RDSS rarely, if ever shows ties in BPP, so a 6th ranked BPP could only be 0.1 of a point below #5 and might be a real contender if it ranks top 5 or better in the other main factor categories. By my count there were 23 races out of the 144 studied that were missing one or more of the four main factors ranked 5 or better, or 121/144 = 84% of all WINNERS had all four of the main factors in the top FIVE ranks, irrespective of distance. You can play with each distance to see where the anomalies exist. |
thank you Bill :)
Mike |
Just a further note on the four main factors:
Vdc depends on the line you choose. AND, the rankings often are tied, so even if a horse is ranked top 5 there may be more than 5 horses ranked in the top 5. So be careful of ties in Vdc. Csr can be changed if any of the races had an excuse - and then a really low total energy. But remember if originally a horse you like is not a top 5 Csr its an indication that there may be a problem, forgivable or not, with that horse. In one major instance if todays race is 9f or less, any horse coming from a marathon race (10f and up) will have a very low CSR. If it has several long races in a row, the CSR will not accurately reflect that horses rank. Look for verification in the other factors before discarding. PL and BPP cannot be changed and there are rarely ties, so usually you will only see 5 horses listed in the top 5 ranks. But when you look at the PPs for each horse you will see at the top the actual PL value and sometimes, the 5 horse will have a 15 PL and then one or two other horses not ranked in the top 5 will also have a PL of 15. Before you eliminate these types, make sure there are other reasons in the array of rankings to eliminate these types of horses. |
Win odds
Another fact from this study was that winning horses whose post odds were 4/1 (which includes everything just short of 9/2) won 76.4% of the time and horses that went off between 9/2 and 9/1 won at 16% of all races, leaving just a little over 7.63% of all wins at over 9/1 - a 1 in 13 chance with odds over 9/1. Think about that when you look at your contender odds! Granted its only 144 races thru 8/7!!??
|
Well done Bill and thanks for sharing. You point out a very important fact about Profit Line ranks. According to Twin Spires when there are ties in PL odds the tie is broken by post position. Let's say the #3 and #5 both have PL odds of 15-1. By default the 3 would rank ahead of the 5 although closer examination may show the 5 is the stronger of the 2. Another thing to check is BPP ranks. You will find that sometimes a horse that has NEVER been on todays' surface will rank higher then those that have. You may want to[and I do] downgrade this horse when you make your final selections. Bottom line DON'T blindly accept any rankings. Do your due diligence.
Tim |
Rdss
Here is the $60,000 question Bill, after you get your top 5 how do u narrow it down to your top 2? After all, in today's racing, the av field is around 7-8 horses in a race on the dirt, unless it is a turf race.
Bob |
Once you get below -15 or above +15 your out of what is a normal variant normal. Once I select all of my lines I then review the variants and create a new norm by seeing what the average is for my chosen lines. Then I see what is abnormal by that standard, if a horse is abnormal I try to seek another line.
Sometimes you can use another line and sometimes your just stuck with it, especially with young horses with limited data. Even if stuck with it, the line provides important information as to its preference to distance or surface. Like a FTS if its horrible I just disregard it and consider it an UNK. Factor. No matter what one uses there are flaws within in it. Even the best factors have flaws. Only being able to adjust one race for CSR is a flaw, false favorites effect CR+ and just using the last 3 lines are all examples of flaws. There are work arounds to most problems or flaws however most are on autopilot mode. Autopilot mode will have you crashing and burning on landings and takeoffs. Just not good for all situations or all races. If there is a whole card of being a math wizard it lies in working smartly and figuring out solutions to problems. We encounter the same problems daily in handicapping such as stretch outs. Greater success comes from solving problems other can't handle. Mitch44 |
Point well taken Mitch. I'm doing more of the same as I review the band of +'s and-'s in my contenders. I agree, there are times when you are stuck with a line, so I try to mentally adjust, giving nudges occasionally. I will be responding to LT1's latest with an idea that I have been kicking around, but have not formulated all that I want to say yet. As always, thanks.
Quote:
|
I think I read that, probably in one of your posts or someone elses, as it relates to PL ranks. The other factors total picture when compared to other possible contenders can really clarify the issue.
Quote:
|
Quote:
What follows is pretty much basic Sartin Methodology. Next you can look on the TPR graph to see who the top 3 EPR, LPR and TPR horses are and if they are within 5 points of the best. Exceptions to the within 5 points might be extreme early and late horses, but the early horses need to be their and 2C. Look at the total energy TE ranking and the actual TE value of the remaining contenders. If there are more than about 2.75 points (my estimate, could be different with others) difference between a horse under consideration and the best, consider dropping this horse as a win contender. In this regard you can always consult the POR TE on the RX3 screen (rt side of Rx3 info) and compare the POR from the paceline to the TE rank within today's contenders. If the horse is coming out of a race whose POR was #5 and today the horse is #4 or #5 in your mix of contenders, probably downgrade it. If you suspect any of this is "suspect" go back and have RDSS auto choose lines and go to the Analysis Rx screen and see who won. Based on the information in this study I went back over the weekend's races at Saratoga and kept for final consideration, the top 3 PL, the top 3 BPP and the top 3 TPR. Then I did what I suggest above and made some eliminations. You would be surprised at how many of the races had W/P/S horses in the top 4 or 5 picks. The more races you see, the better you will get at eliminations. Go back and record what you did, how it turned out, and you will find areas where downgrading a pick should be required. Buenos knot holes going forward, |
Quote:
Sometimes you can use another line and sometimes your just stuck with it, especially with young horses with limited data. Even if stuck with it, the line provides important information as to its preference to distance or surface. Like a FTS if its horrible I just disregard it and consider it an UNK. Factor." Have you ever noticed the variants of a horse's first start, especially if it won? Many times you will see a negative -15 and then it goes into its next race against winners and loses but the variant is close to zero or even a little positive, where the horse finishes up the track with no noted excuses. If all the horses in race 2 have positive variants, this horse's chances are probably over stated. How many times do you see a near zero or positive variant win with an adjusted speed rating (ASR) of say 75 jump and in its second race to an ASR of 88 with a -15 variant? Yes, expect that a second race SHOULD show improvement, but not all do. But in my mind no horse jumps more than a few ASR points from race to race, certainly NOT 13 or more. In this regard, pay attention to the distance being run. Early in their careers young horses often start out at 5 or 5.5 furlongs and post relatively high ASRs, but look what happens when the distances stretch out. An ASR of 75 at 5.5f often turns out to be an ASR of 73 at six furlongs, and perhaps 71 at 6.5 furlongs. In other words, the ability of the horse is declining as the distance gets longer. You will also find some horses get better as the distance progresses so you have to make that judgment in your line selection. Look at the TPR graph along with these other observations. To me its a dead give away if the TPR total is lower as the races get longer. Sometimes the EPR gets bigger with corresponding lowering of the LPR. When I first started in racing reading the form, you would often hear trainers say a horse was a certain distance horse, like "this horse is a perfect middle distance horse (8.0f - 8.5f) but cannot last to 9F". Another instance in many 7f races you will find horses that only run 6.5f or 7f, but never successfully go two turns. Many times by taking this view of the PPs you can prevent yourself from choosing a line not at today's distance that contradicts what distance the horse is good at. This is one really good reason to choose lines within .5 F of today's distance, after determining if a shorter distance line is appropriate. Most often I use a line at the race distance no matter how far back, as long as the energy expenditure is in the horses normal range and the TPR graph supports it. |
When it comes to Mdn winners going against winners for the first time pay close attention to turn time. Doc stated[and I've found it to be true] that if it doesn't rank in the top 2 tt they don't usually win. The reasoning according to Doc was that mdns tend to loaf on the turn.
Tim |
Quote:
|
Variants
Quote:
Bob |
Every horse has a best distance. Just because a horse finishes in the money does not mean that's its best distance. Even trainers are fooled by this and don't adjust. Part of this has to do with the deceleration factor and Match Up.
Speed Ratings are greatly effected by distance also. However no one has more effect on the game than the Racing Secretary. By not carding certain distances for a period of time he forces trainers with sharp horses to run at inappropriate distances. Ditto for surface and class of races. Inept trainers also darken their form by wrongful placing of their horses. Not an easy game to master but like any field of endeavor some do and most are regulated to the minors. Water seeks its own level and no black box approach will outperform detailed analysis and study. No matter how good someone is, you must always strive for improvement or get trampled. Mitch44 |
Bob,
Any variant below -15 and above + 15 is abnormal. When a variant falls outside this range the accuracy of it comes into question. Lets say a variant is +20, well is it that or a +21 or +25? Especially on dirt off tracks, or high class turf races that are left on the turf after real heavy rain. What is the difference between heavy or slow turf line? View abnormal variants with suspicion. There are degrees of heavy, degrees of slow and even degrees of fast. Not all fast tracks are the same fastness. Any Factor in racing must be put in context or perspective, this includes variants. One should ask; What is the norm for the field or better yet what is the norm for my contenders? If your using the recommended settings the program should take care of these inequities; Using 50% of the variant as suggested by Sartin your actually using 7.5 not -15 or +15. That's plenty. In the DRF a 10 variant would equal 5 lengths, therefore you can see how easily you can adjust yourself right out of a race, or in other words make a horse a contender for win or downgrade from win. In RDSS its hard to put it into beaten lengths because the adjustments vary by distance of Fraction etc. so its not clear and concise but its there. I know some one will ask; What if 4 contenders are all -under 0 and one is +15? Well putting it in context I would say its abnormal which is why I review variants after all lines are chosen. This really doesn't happen too often but can happen. I.E. an East Coast horse where tracks tend to be slower ships to say a California track. Or vise verses. I would look for another line, and if none than trust the program. You won't see this often but is a possibility particularity on Breeders Cup Day. Hope that answers your question Bob. Mitch44 |
Thanks
Mitch
|
Bill, Your findings in post 6, that 84% of all winners have all four ratings ( VDC-CSR-PL & BPP ) are identical to mine and mine cover over 8,000 races in the past 7 years.
My latest group of 800+ races I used the settings of 100DTV and The programs setting of + or- 15.( I used these settings after talking to Mitch) and I found no change in the % of contenders that won. The reason I use 100% is because the CSR is more accurate being a compounded rating taken from the last 4 races. (In my testing I found that there was a 7% increase in the winners in the top 5 CSR using this setting.) I applaud you for your research, I know how much time it takes. Rmath |
Now, I just need to find a way to be consistent and win.
Just wondering Richie, when you changed to 100 DTV did the stats on any of the other three factors change appreciably? Thanks, Bill |
Richie is correct about the variant effecting the CSR. The amount of variant or size from a zero base will determine any effect. Obviously the larger the variant the more effect. What tracks you play also has an effect. A track like SA won't have much of an effect because it tends to be very consistent with little variations in weather and variants.
I use 50% adjustment of the variant because I don't use CSR within the program and that is Sartin's recommendation. My view of the CSR is similar to pace line selection in that there are bad lines or bad SR's within the last 3 or 4 races. Even through you can throw out a line, there are situations where 2 or 3 must be discounted and that can't be done within the program. Something on my wish list would be the ability to discount lines, much like Brohamer did for inappropriate information. Either by lining a line out or a check box to do away with the line, naturally also the ability to bring it back. Like a pace line it could be automatic or user adjusted. A wish but I'm not holding my breath and will keep doing my present approach or regular. It works. The present CSR does an admirable job for instant gratification but precision is rewarded along with attention to detail. Note variant settings will also effect V/DC and other pace factors. Mitch44 |
1 Attachment(s)
Great example of what I was trying to say from below. Notice how the ASRs get lower when the horse runs farther. After a slow pace line 10 the ASR improves to 88, then retreats when two tries at 6.5 to 84 and 82, then back up to 85 at 6f, down to 82 for 7f, back up to 84 at 6f and further up to 89 (very close to line 9), back down to 82 at 6.5 and once again a little faster for 6f at 85. So for today's distance we have ASRs of 84-82-82 from the bottom up.
I am using line 2 for today's race. If this race was at 6f, I would use one of the higher 6f lines, if at 7f, I would use the lone 7f line and not give the horse the benefit of the doubt for running faster when not running as far. The TPR number is +10.2 which is right where it should be. Quote:
|
Bill, the only change was in the VDC rating.
PL & BPP are not affected by using the 100 setting. I got 7% more winners using the 100 setting in CSR. Like Doc said : If you can get 1 more winner in 20 races Go with the change. Richie |
Quote:
Thanks Mitch. |
Quote:
Thanks, |
Good thread, thanks to everyone sharing their insights
Jeff |
Busy day yesterday with 2 Dr. apt., haircut etc.
I've had a chance to look at your screen shot Bill. This horse likes the lead, and is best suited to 6 F distances, has lost 3 races at 6.5 and 7F. Total Energy indicates his best dis. is 6F, also his SR are lower at longer distances. Additionally she lost 3 races at BEL., besides the longer distances at BEL, that track tends to be slower than AQU. Smart trainers and owners will ship horses to tracks that favor their running style and favor their best distances. Owner & trainer here operate on the cheap and rather than SAR I would ship her to a faster track like MTH or even SA. But that would be if they card 100,000 purse sprint races. I'm sure they do or G3. Plus at SAR like BEL she'll go against better horses than say at MTH, a weaker field for same money. You can tell much more about this horse by its % M and computer generated Running Style. Probably an E with % Med of above 69% and perhaps a few at 70%. Also by her 3RD FR on FPS screen off her PP's. Looks to be a NTL. Running style(ESP) computer generated, 3rd FR., Tot. Energy or TPR and Perceptor even can give you valuable information about a horse's preferred distances, surfaces etc. Much of this also has to do with deceleration as to what a horses best distance is. The better the horse the longer it can carry its speed, this includes within distances such as 6F. Top 6F champions and BC winners have better 3rd FR or carry their speed after a very fast pace. Many years back they carded a lot of 1/ 40 yards, 1/ 70 yard races etc. now there are few of them and more 1/16, more 6.5 and 7.5 races The point is a horse can win at a mile but not at 1/40 or 1/70. They get gutted at some point and run into a brick wall, may finish in the money but do not win. EVERY HORSE HAS A BEST DISTANCE. Be careful with 3 year old's, their stamina improves as the year progresses and their 3rd FR's get better along with their Tot Energy. As long as they remain sound. This is why I prefer to stay with 1/2 F of todays distance if possible. Just like out of whack variants not always possible, but preferable. Like "The Hat" said; "You must use what's there. Sometimes you can even predict what a horse will do. Much of this comes from analysis and not a black box approach and everything on auto-pilot. While I can get winners on the fly and do , my best results come from detailed analysis. Old Arkie Girl (Pat) once said I tear a race apart and that's true given time. Bill you seem to have a long way, best of luck in the future. Success is in the details, Mitch44 |
Mitch,
I agree with all that you said, I am fully subscribed to your analytical approach. Many thanks, |
It's not unusual to find horses with mixed distances or surfaces. Many times their forced to run at inappropriate dis.'s and surfaces, even class for that matter because the way the Racing Secretary cards races. A sharp horse doesn't make any money sitting in the barn, while those lesser placings pay the bills.
With trainer fees today a horse needs to make about $24,000 a year just to break even. Many thousands do not and inept trainers and owners hinder their own ability to break even. Place yourself as the trainer and determine why its in todays race based on the conditions of the race. Get off auto-pilot and take over the controls, be a pilot not a co-pilot. Lastly, one is better off with quality handicapping rather than quantity. If I can be of help Bill, contact me. Mitch44 |
in gulfstream park,trainer fees a $90 a day + vet bill, a horse needs make $35000 a yesr to break even, is a very tough game
raymond |
Quote:
but the 50%DTV produces a better VDC output? If applying the entire DTV works for one (TS/CSR), why wouldn't it for the other (VDC)? The results Richie found in CSR would tell me applying the full variant change versus the 50% should put out more accurate readouts across the board; not just with TS or CSR. Mike |
WOW!!! Ray I new it was high but not that high. The costs have really gone up. Another reason why I guess we have all these short fields, most owners can't afford it as not many horses can win that each year.
Casino money has helped, but tracks keep folding. This is the last year for Arlington Park. CNL has problems with cash flow as Jocks aren't getting paid and are refusing to ride. I guess their hanging on by their nails. Mitch44 |
Just for clarity my recommendations have always been to use 50% of variant. This also is a Sartin guideline. I've never said use 100%. Its a user prerogative and like Sartin said; "Given a chance to make an adjustment, users will take it."
As I said my setting are the recommended settings that come with the program. I don't use CSR within the program. Its a decent Factor for sure, I'm more of a precision type bettor I guess and make some of my own adjustments based on research. Richie M was using 100% and -25 & +25 if I recall. He changed it to -15 & +15 but kept the use 100% of variant. The Variant setting will effect the CSR rating and there is some difference if you used 100% or 50 %. All Speed Rating's apply some sort of Variant adjustment. It'll make a difference in a SR if you use 100% verses 50%. How much of a difference? That can't be said because it greatly depends on the Variant. If its -1 or +1 its nothing but if its -25 or +25 it can be very meaningful. CSR is also effected by which tracks you play and the season or time of year you play. Winter tracks have higher Variants because the weather frequently changes more in winter. There even was a big difference in Poly tracks at one time because they were all made with difference materials. Many have gone by the wayside and those in use today generally are made of the same stuff. I forget which one, but its fibers were greatly effected by the summer heat. For those using the CSR, I would tell you to keep using it. Unless you can come up with something better. I also don't particularity like the way its weighted. I.e. Over weighted for last race, I view this like using the last line always for a pace line. There are many reasons not to use that line. Mike I hope your well. To answer your question, with a Pace rating everything is dependent on one line. The CSR uses 4 lines and will tend to smooth out or nullify one bad line. Make a mistake with a paceline and all your readouts are skewed, one bad line of 4 in CSR gets you that 84% winners in top four. Big note: with the last line so heavenly weighted in CSR it also distorts the rating. In other words if the last line was always correct you would get more than that 84%. I would never recommend users not use the CSR, for the overwhelming majority its a step up. But not for me. I don't use or do many things, and if I listed them all you would wonder how I get the results that I do. Some things like a model, track profile or last line are only important if you believe they are. Mitch44 |
Quote:
Mike |
Mitch44,
I hope you’re doing well too. (should have said that before) Mike |
I am Mike,thanks.
Mitch44 |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:41 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.