Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   Sartin Methodology Handicapping 101 (102 ...) (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=116)
-   -   Extreme Pace Handicapping (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=14221)

1retired 09-26-2021 12:54 AM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
1 Attachment(s)
Barb Craven

I'm 1retired. My first name is Dave.

I saw through reading posts on Races of Interest on Ted's website that you have read Randy Giles book, Extreme Pace Handicapping. I read portions of it at one time in the past when I saw it in a library somewhere, but I didn't really read. that much of it.

My understanding is that he describes a number of Pace Handicapping angles which he describes in colorful terms. Could you tell me if you found the book worthwhile in a way that you can, were able to, and have pracdtically adapted it's angles to your handicapping methodology that you use wwith RDSS?

Is it a worthwhile book? would you recommend it? Could you describe the most impactful 2 or three angles that he talks about in his book that you were able to adapt to your real life handicapping today?

I assume that one of th e obvious angles that he discussed was the situation where there is too mu ch Early Speed in terms of Quirin Speed Points among the entrants in a race and that there would be at least 3 entrants with high early speed points and that you would eliminate the Early Speed horses from win contention in the race, and that an OTE horse or horses would become the win candidates, presumably at high oddsi? Would that be correct?

By way of a trade so that I am offering something in return, I offer my flehsed out version of Lueylumps Early/Late Difference angle. I have spoken about it in my posts. See my posts on Old TPR threads. Below I have attached a Excel database with the 10 horses so far that I have put with their records in my database establishing a spot play angle for horses with significantly higher EPR ratings compared to their TPR ratings and whose Total Energy and other traditional rankings in RDSS are not that great who are winning races because of this high E/L difference.

I'm hoping that you will post me back with some information. ]]

1retired
Dave


.

1retired 09-26-2021 08:11 AM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
Hi Barb. a

I'm retired1. I, as the name suggests, recently retired and have a lot of time on my hands to do what I want. I've always been interested in horse race handicapping and while surfing the web, came upon your son, Ted's, website. I used the Sartin methdology at the time of Phase III and thought it had start of the art thinking at that time. I' think RDSS now has state of the art thinking re handicapping. That's why I'm contacting you now.

I just read my original message and it seems pretty abrupt. That's why I'm sending you this f/u message.

1retired

Tim Y 09-26-2021 03:29 PM

WORD to the WISE...No handicapping program works universally the same. also it takes TIME to transfer selections to good wagers.

PLAY ON PAPER until you find consistency in your reading the evaluations.
TRY many tracks and see which ones are your best
RECORD all your evaluations and betting decisions for post race evaluation. You will, as all of us from time to time, will find positives and negatives which you can exploit or work on to alter

MJS6916 09-27-2021 10:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138567)
Barb Craven

I'm 1retired. My first name is Dave.

I saw through reading posts on Races of Interest on Ted's website that you have read Randy Giles book, Extreme Pace Handicapping. I read portions of it at one time in the past when I saw it in a library somewhere, but I didn't really read. that much of it.

My understanding is that he describes a number of Pace Handicapping angles which he describes in colorful terms. Could you tell me if you found the book worthwhile in a way that you can, were able to, and have pracdtically adapted it's angles to your handicapping methodology that you use wwith RDSS?

Is it a worthwhile book? would you recommend it? Could you describe the most impactful 2 or three angles that he talks about in his book that you were able to adapt to your real life handicapping today?

I assume that one of th e obvious angles that he discussed was the situation where there is too mu ch Early Speed in terms of Quirin Speed Points among the entrants in a race and that there would be at least 3 entrants with high early speed points and that you would eliminate the Early Speed horses from win contention in the race, and that an OTE horse or horses would become the win candidates, presumably at high oddsi? Would that be correct?

By way of a trade so that I am offering something in return, I offer my flehsed out version of Lueylumps Early/Late Difference angle. I have spoken about it in my posts. See my posts on Old TPR threads. Below I have attached a Excel database with the 10 horses so far that I have put with their records in my database establishing a spot play angle for horses with significantly higher EPR ratings compared to their TPR ratings and whose Total Energy and other traditional rankings in RDSS are not that great who are winning races because of this high E/L difference.

I'm hoping that you will post me back with some information. ]]

1retired
Dave


.


It's not the best written book I've gone through but definitely worth reading.

I liked going through the "recognizing the running style exercises"
( I call "running style" ---> P1cP which stands for Preferred 1st Call Position" ).

I'll come back with more later. I left the book at my cottage, so I don't want to butcher the details for now.

1retired 09-28-2021 07:07 AM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
Thanks

Dave
1retired

MJS6916 10-01-2021 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138671)
Thanks

Dave
1retired

Just picked up the book at my cottage before dinner tonight.

Won't have a chance to get into it now.

I didn't forget about you. Bear with me.

Good luck and skill to you this weekend.

Mike

1retired 10-01-2021 10:37 PM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
Mike

Thanks. Hope to hear from you soon.

Dave

Tim Y 10-02-2021 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MJS6916 (Post 138669)
It's not the best written book I've gone through but definitely worth reading.

I liked going through the "recognizing the running style exercises"
( I call "running style" ---> P1cP which stands for Preferred 1st Call Position" ).

I'll come back with more later. I left the book at my cottage, so I don't want to butcher the details for now.

Took me a long time to accept it, but POSTION and segmental velocity makes assigning a running style somewhere in between these two.

MJS6916 10-03-2021 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 138843)
Took me a long time to accept it, but POSTION and segmental velocity makes assigning a running style somewhere in between these two.

100+% agree.

I forget who put this out but, it was someone from this forum.

I copied and saved the following to my notes about a year ago.

"I don't believe that you can separate running style from Projecting today's pace.
First there are two aspects that you want to determine for running style:

1) Will the horse pass other horses?, will he run past a bunch of horses in a single pace segment?

2) When the horse wins or runs very close where was he at the 1st Call? OK, maybe 3.

3) Will he fight when he is challenged? or does he quit and let the other horse go by?"

ranchwest 10-03-2021 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MJS6916 (Post 138849)
100+% agree.

I forget who put this out but, it was someone from this forum.

I copied and saved the following to my notes about a year ago.

"I don't believe that you can separate running style from Projecting today's pace.
First there are two aspects that you want to determine for running style:

1) Will the horse pass other horses?, will he run past a bunch of horses in a single pace segment?

2) When the horse wins or runs very close where was he at the 1st Call? OK, maybe 3.

3) Will he fight when he is challenged? or does he quit and let the other horse go by?"

Are you defining running style as positional?

MJS6916 10-03-2021 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranchwest (Post 138852)
Are you defining running style as positional?

Yes but not entirely. I'm in agreement with Tim Y's post in # 8 of this thread.

ranchwest 10-03-2021 07:22 PM

How would you evaluate the mesh of those two?

MJS6916 10-03-2021 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranchwest (Post 138866)
How would you evaluate the mesh of those two?


I try to use lines where the runners
had their best finish results.

Generally I expect runners who are usually
in the front 1/3rd of the field +/or
within 4 lengths of the lead at the first call to keep
the pacesetters honest.

Runners who are regularly ahead of
80% of their opponents at the 1c
or within 2 lengths of the lead
should be expected to push or set the pace.

everyone else is to me “other than early “

Then I look at the POH and PORs
in RDSS to determine if any of the runners
seem to put out of their usual 1c range
compared to when they’ve ran their better races

That’s where my assessment of who in
the front-tier of the field at the 1c
is overmatched and who else is still a contender.

ranchwest 10-04-2021 01:14 AM

Interesting. Seems everyone has a bit different way of selecting pace lines.

MJS6916 10-04-2021 07:18 AM

I should have ended post 13 with: begins.

1retired 10-04-2021 02:50 PM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
Mike

Thanks for your continued responses. I understand handicapping concepts and theories much better when I see them applied to an actual race. Could you provide the workup of just one race in which you incorporated whatever concepts and theories that you use from Randy Giles' "Extreme Pace Handicapping along with the Sartin Methodology and RDSS to get the winner of a race.

I am coming around to the idea that the Runninbg Style of horses is just as important as the pace numbers and factors that we use to arrive at our picks for the winner of a race. Tom Brohamer talked about this in terms of looking at and evaluating the running style of the horses in the race as the first handicapping step. Further, the Hat talked about looking at the past performances from the left side of the past performances to the right, not vice versa. It is just as important to know how a horse got to his finish of the race as the finish itself, in fact, more important.

To that end, I have an example race workup or partial workup, to use as an example. It is from For the Lead's thread "Why Not Maidens" dtd. 1/23/13, POst #46. It discusses the handicapping of a 6F dirt sprint race for 16,000 Mainden Claimers at Aqueduct on Feb 16, 2013, 10th race.

The eventual winner of the race in quesstion, Bwana Booyah, led at the break and led at the first two calls by 2 lengths at each call and finished 7th in his prior tandem race by 6.4 lengths. He was designated by Running Style as an E5. There was no other early speed in the race. The fractional calls of the race were 23.4 and 46.7 with a final time, I beliebve of 1:12.8.

The eventual 3rd place finisher in Bwana's race was King Keene who was had a running style of EP2 in the prior tandem race in which Bwana finished 7th. He was 2nd at both the 1st and the 2nd call.

The eventual 2nd place finisher of the race on Feb 16, was dropping from a 35,000MC (not the tandem race) and finished 3rd in that race. His runnning style designation was an S1 runner.

Just looking at the running styles and nothing else, it was clear what Bwana Booyah had to do in order to win the race on Feb 16. He simply had to slow down a little bit in his 1st and 2nd fractions and he would.have a lot more energy left to finish the race and win it. There is no indication of the E/L Difference Graph in the workup of this race. However, if it had been available, I'm certain that it would have shown that Bwanah had a ton of extra early energy, much more than any other horse in the race. He just had to throttle back on the first 2 calls a little bit,and he could go wire to wire, which he did. .
He paid over 21-1 to win. To me, this is an excellent example of using the E/L Difference graph and the significant extra early energy that this horse had to win the race. The fractions for the winning race on Feb 16 were 23.9. 47.8 and 1:13.4.

Does this example race that I have provided show up in any context in Randy Giles' book?.

Dave v

1retired 10-04-2021 03:13 PM

Extreme Pace Handicapping
 
I apologize for not putting the workup of the Feb 16, 2013 10th race at Aqueduct in the post as an attachment. I find that it is or has much more impact than a verbal description. I just have not learned how to do that yet. If someone would help me learn to do that, I would appreciate it.

Dave

MJS6916 10-04-2021 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138884)
I apologize for not putting the workup of the Feb 16, 2013 10th race at Aqueduct in the post as an attachment. I find that it is or has much more impact than a verbal description. I just have not learned how to do that yet. If someone would help me learn to do that, I would appreciate it.

Dave

Let's do this first.

Some brief comments on
Chapters 1 & 5 of " Extreme Pace Handicapping" - Randy Giles
Chapter 1 - Extreme Pace Tools
The main lessons I took away from this chapter is:

1 - the much needed reminder that just like runners who can, or try to,
be pacesetters before or by the 1c ---> middle of the pack runners can often be one-dimensional.
Many others here at P&C, have spoken to this as well. I think the easiest way to identify this type
of one-dimensional presser is to see if when the pace in front of that horse gets hotter, does that
runner still produce close enough to it's usual final fraction (F3) or final 2 fractions-combined (HE)
at or near today's comparable distance and class level.
If you see a clear downturn in that runner's F3 and HE output
without any reasonable excuses, that runner just like the easier to spot need-to-lead type
is likely a one-dimensional presser. BTW, most around here use different labels for
running styles than Giles does especially for what he calls pressers.
Still it's an important lesson to hold on to.

2 - The Pace Pressure Gauge discussed on page 7 is not a bad way to estimate the shape of the race
as far as whether the front-tier or early trailers are at more of an advantage than the others.
I personally think it's more important to note the one-dimensional early types and compare them
to each other first.
Regardless of how many Quirin points get added up from the group of
5+ early speed point runners, if one of those front-runners is clearly better than the others who "look like"
they can pressure him/her, the rest of the pack may as well be chasing a Lone Early horse.


3 - The Pace Comfort Zone number (again discussed starting on page 7) is interesting.
I think it's very useful but with a BIG caveat: Be skeptical about using a PCZ number that's
well larger than what could be pulled from other paceline(s) in that horses PPs if you can see
that 2 lengths faster than that runners actual final time or speed figure is about 3 lenghts or worse
than what it should take to win today's event. Use one of the lower PCZ #s as to ensure you're not giving
that horse too much credit for being capable of allowing the pace in front of him/her to
"go on with it" without that runner getting sucked in to chasing it early.


This entire chapter is worth reading just like Chapter 5 for many handicappers.(which I'll discuss next)

Plenty of "Sartinologists" and RDSS subscribers won't need it.

MJS6916 10-04-2021 06:13 PM

Some brief comments on
Chapter 5 of " Extreme Pace Handicapping" - Randy Giles
Chapter 5 - Running Style Workout

Again, I'll repeat: Giles labeling of running styles differs from many around here at P&C.

I differ some from many of the RDSS users here. Whatever, works for you is whatever works for you.

If you never learned the Match-Up from Jim Bradshaw, Howard Sartin, or some other really good
teachers from around here, this chapter is a great alternative.

Giles saw to it this chapter took up more than 25% of the book and rightly so.

I haven't read more than 7 books on handicapping in my life and doubt I'll read 2 more
before I go to the "pearly gates" ( no I'm not dying ).

I can't imagine there's a much better practice session in any other handicapping book
than this one. If I wanted to point someone to the best combination of learning how to
identify "running styles", AND in the shortest amount of time ----> Chapter 5 would be it.

I, myself, break down the "labels" more so (and of course I think better), but I have to admit
Chapter 5 helped me get there.

If you need a refresher, or you're not confident in your assessments of "running style lables"
Chapter 5 is worth intense study and more than once.

Giles repeats something he said in Chapter 1: "Chasing is NOT pressing".
This is crucial to correctly distinguishing between an E or EP type. Can't be reinforced enough.

He also says he labels "running styles" by lengths not position. I disagree.
To me it takes both plus considering the POR of the lines we are inspecting.

Because of my own skepticism of the Quirin points system ( not saying they're useless ),
I didn't read the other chapters (2-4, & 6-8) after my first run through them.
There's some really good advice anyone can hang on to at the very end of the book,
and keep in mind that in Chapter 8 Giles' research only dealt with sprints.

Finally, on page 53: the horse who Giles says gets a PCZ # of just a 1/2 length (based on his 4th line back)
I say is wrong. It's 2 lengths.

I had to get that one in there. :)

1retired 10-04-2021 06:17 PM

Extremem Pace Handicapping
 
Mike

Many thanks. You've given a lot of stuff so far. Give me some time to digest this. I'm considering buying the internet PDF version of the book which costs something like $9.50 or $10.

,

MJS6916 10-04-2021 06:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138880)
Mike

Thanks for your continued responses. I understand handicapping concepts and theories much better when I see them applied to an actual race. Could you provide the workup of just one race in which you incorporated whatever concepts and theories that you use from Randy Giles' "Extreme Pace Handicapping along with the Sartin Methodology and RDSS to get the winner of a race.

I am coming around to the idea that the Runninbg Style of horses is just as important as the pace numbers and factors that we use to arrive at our picks for the winner of a race. Tom Brohamer talked about this in terms of looking at and evaluating the running style of the horses in the race as the first handicapping step. Further, the Hat talked about looking at the past performances from the left side of the past performances to the right, not vice versa. It is just as important to know how a horse got to his finish of the race as the finish itself, in fact, more important.

To that end, I have an example race workup or partial workup, to use as an example. It is from For the Lead's thread "Why Not Maidens" dtd. 1/23/13, POst #46. It discusses the handicapping of a 6F dirt sprint race for 16,000 Mainden Claimers at Aqueduct on Feb 16, 2013, 10th race.

The eventual winner of the race in quesstion, Bwana Booyah, led at the break and led at the first two calls by 2 lengths at each call and finished 7th in his prior tandem race by 6.4 lengths. He was designated by Running Style as an E5. There was no other early speed in the race. The fractional calls of the race were 23.4 and 46.7 with a final time, I beliebve of 1:12.8.

The eventual 3rd place finisher in Bwana's race was King Keene who was had a running style of EP2 in the prior tandem race in which Bwana finished 7th. He was 2nd at both the 1st and the 2nd call.

The eventual 2nd place finisher of the race on Feb 16, was dropping from a 35,000MC (not the tandem race) and finished 3rd in that race. His runnning style designation was an S1 runner.

Just looking at the running styles and nothing else, it was clear what Bwana Booyah had to do in order to win the race on Feb 16. He simply had to slow down a little bit in his 1st and 2nd fractions and he would.have a lot more energy left to finish the race and win it. There is no indication of the E/L Difference Graph in the workup of this race. However, if it had been available, I'm certain that it would have shown that Bwanah had a ton of extra early energy, much more than any other horse in the race. He just had to throttle back on the first 2 calls a little bit,and he could go wire to wire, which he did. .
He paid over 21-1 to win. To me, this is an excellent example of using the E/L Difference graph and the significant extra early energy that this horse had to win the race. The fractions for the winning race on Feb 16 were 23.9. 47.8 and 1:13.4.

Does this example race that I have provided show up in any context in Randy Giles' book?.

Dave v

In the book, it focused more on taking advantage of running style mismatches and locating lone running styles no matter where they were in the pack.

Without getting too particular in the book, he seemed to recognize the velocity of the pace as important in Chapter 1
but in the rest of the book it was all about the Quirin points, pace pictures, and running style labels.
He basically used his PPG numbers solely to determine how hot the pace should be.

If that works for Giles and others I won't argue with'em. Not for me.

MJS6916 10-04-2021 06:25 PM

Also Dave, you won't see an energy distribution nor E/L graph type number analysis anywhere in Giles' book.

MJS6916 10-04-2021 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138904)
Mike

Many thanks. You've given a lot of stuff so far. Give me some time to digest this. I'm considering buying the internet PDF version of the book which costs something like $9.50 or $10.

,

I've done more writing and studying lately than handicapping.

The very second I'm done with some other work I gotta do,
I'll be able to discuss some races to handicap or review in detail.

I promise you, I can't wait for it much longer. Doing my level best to pull that day to sooner.

Remember, just Chapter 1 & 5 is more than worth what you'll pay for that book.

Ted Craven 10-04-2021 07:19 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1retired (Post 138880)
Mike

Thanks for your continued responses. I understand handicapping concepts and theories much better when I see them applied to an actual race. Could you provide the workup of just one race in which you incorporated whatever concepts and theories that you use from Randy Giles' "Extreme Pace Handicapping along with the Sartin Methodology and RDSS to get the winner of a race.

I am coming around to the idea that the Runninbg Style of horses is just as important as the pace numbers and factors that we use to arrive at our picks for the winner of a race. Tom Brohamer talked about this in terms of looking at and evaluating the running style of the horses in the race as the first handicapping step. Further, the Hat talked about looking at the past performances from the left side of the past performances to the right, not vice versa. It is just as important to know how a horse got to his finish of the race as the finish itself, in fact, more important.

To that end, I have an example race workup or partial workup, to use as an example. It is from For the Lead's thread "Why Not Maidens" dtd. 1/23/13, POst #46. It discusses the handicapping of a 6F dirt sprint race for 16,000 Mainden Claimers at Aqueduct on Feb 16, 2013, 10th race.

The eventual winner of the race in quesstion, Bwana Booyah, led at the break and led at the first two calls by 2 lengths at each call and finished 7th in his prior tandem race by 6.4 lengths. He was designated by Running Style as an E5. There was no other early speed in the race. The fractional calls of the race were 23.4 and 46.7 with a final time, I beliebve of 1:12.8.

The eventual 3rd place finisher in Bwana's race was King Keene who was had a running style of EP2 in the prior tandem race in which Bwana finished 7th. He was 2nd at both the 1st and the 2nd call.

The eventual 2nd place finisher of the race on Feb 16, was dropping from a 35,000MC (not the tandem race) and finished 3rd in that race. His runnning style designation was an S1 runner.

Just looking at the running styles and nothing else, it was clear what Bwana Booyah had to do in order to win the race on Feb 16. He simply had to slow down a little bit in his 1st and 2nd fractions and he would.have a lot more energy left to finish the race and win it. There is no indication of the E/L Difference Graph in the workup of this race. However, if it had been available, I'm certain that it would have shown that Bwanah had a ton of extra early energy, much more than any other horse in the race. He just had to throttle back on the first 2 calls a little bit,and he could go wire to wire, which he did. .
He paid over 21-1 to win. To me, this is an excellent example of using the E/L Difference graph and the significant extra early energy that this horse had to win the race. The fractions for the winning race on Feb 16 were 23.9. 47.8 and 1:13.4.

Does this example race that I have provided show up in any context in Randy Giles' book?.

Dave v

I fished out that race from the Example Races RDSS Teaching Forum database. If only there were a way to get a link to that specific Thread or set of posts ;) (oh wait, there IS a way: http://paceandcap.com/forums/showpos...7&postcount=15) -- THEN we could know of any scratches, pacelines selected, Results, etc, etc. I spent 5 minutes looking for it and could not find.

Over to you 1retired (i.e. since you know where that thread is, please post the link, per the instructions I gave). Then, perhaps more useful discussion ensues ...

Attachment 49945

Ted

Ted Craven 10-05-2021 02:11 AM

Thanks Buffaloxp! Here is the link: http://paceandcap.com/forums/showpos...9&postcount=46

http://paceandcap.com/forums/attachm...1&d=1361222149


http://paceandcap.com/forums/attachm...1&d=1361222149

http://paceandcap.com/forums/attachm...1&d=1361222149


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.