Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Sartin (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4495)

gl45 09-07-2008 08:23 AM

Sartin
 
From a Google search

The greatest strength of the Sartin Methodology (an extremely popular and profitable race analysis approach from the 1980s) was the requirement that users study the race results in conjunction with the ratings generated by the various software applications. Sartin realized, as a psychologist, that the act of "searching for patterns and answers" was a great training method to develop decision making skills.

What the most sophisticated Sartin users quickly discovered was that the software was almost irrelevant; there was no "killer app" that would mechanically select enough winners, consistently enough, to be profitable over time. However, the more those users struggled in the assigned tasks of "isolating the true contenders in the race" and "finding the most predictive pace line" for each of those contenders, the better race analysts they became.

The more intelligent of the Sartin advocates caught on early; they realized that selecting the "proper pace lines" and "true contenders" essentially forced them to analyze the past performances in a completely new way. The most difficult part of the process for many "experienced handicappers" was the implication that in most cases, the winner was uncovered before the first pace line was entered into the computer. Specifically, the training process developed the skill of pre-race analysis to a sufficient degree that the "computer readouts" became almost irrelevant.

Because Sartin's income was derived from the sale of the steady stream of the "latest, greatest" software to "analyze races," the notion that those software applications were training devices, rather than "real" analysis aids was kept under wraps. Unfortunately, the fall from grace of the Sartin Methodology was based on all the wrong reasons; later users argued that the "software didn't really do anything" beyond generating simplistic pace ratings. That was true, as far as it went, but failed completely to explain how Sartin managed to train an entire generation of race analysts, a number of whom have been wagering successfully since the 1980s.

lsosa54 09-07-2008 09:23 AM

Definitely some truth to it but a rather simplistic summary. I use EXDC with Thoromation and if I do my job of selecting contenders and pace lines that are predictive, this program does an outstanding job of selecting winners and many of them are not apparent through pre race analysis, especially in contentious races.

I think the model back then was to charge for the software as the data had to be hand entered. All software programs were expensive. Once downloadable data became available, the vendors saw the profit was in the data and went in that direction. HDW is a perfect example today.

I agree that there is no killer app or magic bullet in handicapping, and even if Doc designed the software to make you really think a race through, unfortunately the majority of folks were looking for killer apps or magic bullets so as not to have to do the work.

Doc was definitely a showman but his heart was in the right place. It was a shame to see the infighting that started the downfall and then I guess Shane didn't want to continue running the business once Doc's health wouldn't permit him to, although I have no knowledge that was the real reason.

We could use a solid biography but it probably wouldn't sell much unfortunately.

Turbulator 09-07-2008 09:38 AM

When I read this article I thought of The Hat. This, in essence, is how he evolved. After feeding thousands of races into the computer he started "seeing" who the winner would be before he entered the data.

I'm sure this is true of other software practitioners as well.

gl45 09-07-2008 10:20 AM

This is the paragraph that got my attention.

The more intelligent of the Sartin advocates caught on early; they realized that selecting the "proper pace lines" and "true contenders" essentially forced them to analyze the past performances in a completely new way. The most difficult part of the process for many "experienced handicappers" was the implication that in most cases, the winner was uncovered before the first pace line was entered into the computer. Specifically, the training process developed the skill of pre-race analysis to a sufficient degree that the "computer readouts" became almost irrelevant.

If I understand correctly, we must learn the subtle intricacies hiden in a horse's pp, and once this task is accomplished with certain amount of accuracy the software become almost irrelevant.

Turbulator 09-07-2008 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lbj (Post 39609)
If I understand correctly, we must learn the subtle intricacies hiden in a horse's pp, and once this task is accomplished with certain amount of accuracy the software become almost irrelevant.

That's a good way of putting it. I think Jimmy, with his volume of experience was able to develop shortcuts to the process. Tandems, power lines, power moves, projecting pace, finding the lead horse, fast horses, matching up--all of those things are born of experience brought about by an intuitive application of the data at hand.

He realized that in certain situations he could borrow bits and pieces of different races for the same horse and meld them into new lines because somehow that's what the software did on occasion, so to speak, and after doing that over and over he just knew when to apply it and when to discard it.

He once told me a good way to learn to pick winners was to look at old races and see who won, and then try and figure out why they won, in a sense reverse engineering.

It's still a marvel to have studied with a man who went from not being able to pick a winner to picking nothing but winners.

That light bulb "ah-ha" moment must have been momentus.

gl45 09-07-2008 10:53 AM

54,
It is a simplistic summary. You quoted "if I do my job of selecting contenders and pace lines that are predictive, this program does an outstanding job of selecting winners and many of them are not apparent through pre race analysis, especially in contentious races.".

You don't give yourself enough credit. The fact that you select a not so apparent winner through a pre race analisys, do indicate a knowledge in reading a horse past performance. EXDC and Thoro didn't select the winner.

Bill V. 09-07-2008 11:05 AM

Dr Howard Sartin
 
Thank you Pino

I guess you know what i'm going to add


If you read the follow ups -mostly # 70 and beyond till the last issue
# 88 I really think that Doc's teachings about not only readouts
and race examples. But about learning to live and make decisions
about racing and life in everything you do. The overall spirit of
the methodology is so much more than programs
Steve -Turbulator - hits it well when he mentions the Hat
"Getting it" Once you can learn about it and then its there
I can do this there it is ..

what the author is saying about the total past performance ,
To me, I hear Doc saying about correct pace line /contender selections
looming up off the page

GS
Bill

p.s.
Doc made a big part of his income from seminars and the Follow Up
and what he wrote in the follow up is there for all to see in black and white
I respect the follow up service His words then and now can make you a winner

Turf Speculator 09-07-2008 11:10 AM

Not so fast
 
I was fortunate enough to have seen Dick Schmidt work in the late 80's and early 90's. He used a methodical step by step approach to paceline contender selection and relying 100% on computer readouts and his models to bet.

He will be the first man to tell you he disdained intuitive working of races in favor of a repetitive application type approach that he repeated day after day. Email him and ask him. He will tell you the same thing I just posted.

So while all the intuitive members of Pirco were betting there 3 to 20 dollars a race he was betting 200 to 300 dollars a race and was the biggest money earner in Pirco at the time.

He switched from betting thoroughbreds to the markets and makes a killing today in that genre.100% mechanical and 0% intuition.

Bill V. 09-07-2008 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lbj (Post 39611)
54,
It is a simplistic summary. You quoted "if I do my job of selecting contenders and pace lines that are predictive, this program does an outstanding job of selecting winners and many of them are not apparent through pre race analysis, especially in contentious races.".

You don't give yourself enough credit. The fact that you select a not so apparent winner through a pre race analisys, do indicate a knowledge in reading a horse past performance. EXDC and Thoro didn't select the winner.


Pino actually I give winners like Lou, Users of the older Sartin program
So much credit. Because these programs were part of the methodology
when win percentage was the key to success. Entering lines
and proper contender selection, Then betting the programs top 2
picks was the methodology

But today the name of the game is profit and now we see the
value of all Sartin programs to get those higher paying not so
gettable horses that most visual handicappers don't see

To get those horses with the older programs is very admirable

Bill

Tim Y 09-07-2008 12:40 PM

Let the program tell you. I have done very well using each horse's MOST RECENT TOP E/EP LINES as their pace lines for the program: works very well.

Charlie D 09-07-2008 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lbj (Post 39611)
54,
The fact that you select a not so apparent winner through a pre race analisys, do indicate a knowledge in reading a horse past performance. EXDC and Thoro didn't select the winner.


Correct, the software helped soldify (right word??) the initial race analysis made by Lou

MIKE1121 09-07-2008 02:41 PM

Result Charts
 
I agree with the many benefits of using result charts with the Sartin methodology. Tom Hambilton in the book Pace Makes The Race often said that he would continuously check the result charts to verify his track to track adjustments. I do it all the time, it works.

Want to learn the crowds weaknesses, examine your PPs with the result charts , you will learn what they under value and over value quickly.

Mike.

lsosa54 09-07-2008 09:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lbj (Post 39611)
54,
It is a simplistic summary. You quoted "if I do my job of selecting contenders and pace lines that are predictive, this program does an outstanding job of selecting winners and many of them are not apparent through pre race analysis, especially in contentious races.".

You don't give yourself enough credit. The fact that you select a not so apparent winner through a pre race analisys, do indicate a knowledge in reading a horse past performance. EXDC and Thoro didn't select the winner.

No, they didn't select the winner, but they did help me to separate contenders and make a betting choice that may not have been apparent on the surface or at least to me and that I may not have been able to separate without the use of the software.

Charley: Sorry - I hadn't seen your post - but what you said is what i meant. Solidify is the correct term. Let's not forget that by using EXDC/Thoromation I'm using an aid that the Hat had a large part in developing for people like myself who may not be able to separate contenders consistently by the manual match up process that folks like Richie are mastering. I spend my time on contenders and pace lines and let the software do its thing. My contender and pace line selection is neither crazy nor mechanical. It is very much modeled after Tom Brohamer's approach and is logical to my thought process.

lsosa54 09-07-2008 10:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turf Speculator (Post 39613)
So while all the intuitive members of Pirco were betting there 3 to 20 dollars a race he was betting 200 to 300 dollars a race and was the biggest money earner in Pirco at the time.

I have no doubt that what you say about Dick is true. I don't think Brohamer was betting $20 a race as I did get to spend some time with him. The Hat's approach was different from both of them so I do think there is room for different approaches that can lead to profit.

Jonathan Steele 09-08-2008 05:24 AM

"Because Sartin's income was derived from the sale of the steady stream of the "latest, greatest" software to "analyze races,"

I don't like the ring of that. The writer makes it sound like there's something wrong with someone deriving an income from the sale of handicapping software, all of which costs time and money to develop, etc., not to mention the brain power and imagination needed in the first place to come up with the formulae! Like Doc's time and creative genius was not to be compensated monetarily in some way (though that was not his motive in doing what he did)!

If whoever wrote this did better research on the subject, they'd realize that there was a whole hell of a lot more to the Sartin Methodology than the mere sale of handicapping software!

"later users argued that the "software didn't really do anything" beyond generating simplistic pace ratings."

I'd be willing to bet those "later users" were not "users" of programs like Synthesis and Validator whose ratings were anything but "simplistic pace ratings." It amazes and amuses me when I read articles like this, whose writers base their critique on what they believe the Sartin Methodology to be--decades old Phase I and Phase III teachings! :D

Sounds to me like sour grapes from disgruntled former members and/or those "horseplayers" who refused (or were intellectually incapable) to grasp and apply the Sartin Methodology as instructed.

Regards,

Jon

Tim Y 09-08-2008 01:10 PM

I have heard from multiple sources that many inside the original Pirco group were dissatisfied with the way descriptions of the use of the methodology were not explained so as the newest software program would be needed.

I cannot blame anyone for doing the marketing necessary to keep the sales of software up, but others did.

The Sartin methodology is a starting point for those individuals who can see adaptations outside the mainstream.THINGS CHANGE as new discoveries are made and it is the enlightened individual who continues to realize that NOTHING stays the same. As I often quote Hereclitus; "You can never step in the same river twice."

RichieP 09-08-2008 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jonathan Steele (Post 39664)
I'd be willing to bet those "later users" were not "users" of programs like Synthesis and Validator whose ratings were anything but "simplistic pace ratings."
Regards,
Jon

Hi Jon
Quick anecdotal story about Validator and it's V/DC readout when it first came out in the late 90's.

This was when I was at the Meadowlands 6 days a week night and day wagering and Bill and I would hook up often at "the table" up in the clubhouse especially Saturday. That was our day to be together and enjoy racing and good friends.

Mark would join us and may times these other 2 fellows Neil and Freddie. Freddie was one of the first users of a deceleration program back in the late 80's/early 90's and headed a wager syndicate that made well over a million dollars in a few years.

Story isn't about any of them or myself. It is about a man named Joe who Bill and myself affectionately called "The Beard". He knew nothing about computers,software or anything like that. Bill and myself took the time to show him Howard's simple best of last 3 comparable guidelines for paceline selection. Then we taught him how to hide to top 5 total energy/line score.

All we told him after that was to write down the top 3 on the V/DC screen and always pay attention to longshots ranked THIRD. He loved exactas and would go and box them in exactas. Sometimes it was 3 most times 4 horses in the box.He didn't look at trainers/jockeys,layoffs etc. He got his numbers and went straight to the window and bet. We would sit him in front of the computer and he did all the work himself.

Travers day at Saratoga comes and it was an unreal card with super competitive races and giant fields. A lot of the big name cappers in the business had given picks/opines on the card either in print,on the Saratoga show or online. The Beard sat down at 11 A.M. after we entered the scratches for him and worked the entire card writing down each race the top 3 V/DC and ties. Took him somewhere around 30-45 minutes to do. He left us his numbers on a sheet,headed straight to the window to box his exactas and disappeared downstairs.

During the card Bill,myself and Mark would look over at his numbers he left us. I can't remember how many times we said "Beard's got this one!". With simple $1.00 ex boxes at card's end he hammered the races for significant profit. he out performed all the "experts" considerably and stuffed his pockets so much he was "leaning" toward one side.;) Later on he comes back and leaves me and Bill a voucher for ourselves as a thank you. Not sure if it was $50.00 or $100.00

I can't tell you how many times I was in the Franchises alone during the week betting and he would work a card or 2,leave and hours later walk by and drop a 50 buck voucher on my table. I'm dead serious.

Bill would say he never saw anyone who acted so quickly going to BET immediately after getting his "mix".

The "table" broke up,folks went their own ways but the Beard never forgot. Bill told me a while back he stopped at the Meadowlands and who does he run into but yes The Beard! After exchanging pleasantries Bill said first thing Joe asked for was Bill's V/DC numbers! This is after at least a few years had come and gone.

This really is quite a remarkable game we play isn't it! Room for ALL ideas under the big umbrella we know as racing :).

From using computers to raw stuff to angles to Bayesian models (:confused: ) to picking numbers and colors (my Mom:) )

Remarkable!

mufasa 09-08-2008 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 39615)
Let the program tell you. I have done very well using each horse's MOST RECENT TOP E/EP LINES as their pace lines for the program: works very well.

Tim:

You have some very interesting ideas and I usually look forward to reading your post. Your recent comment and expressed at times in other post is that the pace line selection and its program results can benefit if one uses the best 1-2 E/EL ratings within the last 3-4 races? Assuming that I have that statement somewhat correct the E/EL rating is just one part of the overall Energy rating which I have tried to use in the past as a basis in my pace line selection.

Why not just use the entire Energy rating in pace line selection rather then as you suggest just the one part of the overall rating. I know that in most dirt races early speed is king so perhaps that is what you are concentrating on by using this one part of the rating vs. the entire rating. I am just guessing at your reasoning so if you could please elaborate on this point, if you do not mind. Is this just for dirt races or do you also use it for grass or poly races? Is there yet another consideration for winners vs. maidens?

Thanks,

Robert

Tim Y 09-08-2008 04:53 PM

Things change. We are NOT looking for what HAPPENED, we are looking for what WILL HAPPEN and the best way to find that is projection based upon a logical premise. It is for all dirt races, no matter the level since horses don't know if they are running at the man-made level of 10 or 15K, they just run.
It is an old time honored idea: IMPROVING EARLY SPEED

Tim Y 09-08-2008 05:39 PM

an example
 
1 Attachment(s)
here is how the program caught the 10/1 winner of the nightcap at Philadelphia today. See the improving early cycles recently in the far left E/Ep column? Since EP is such a large part of a pace rating, the TPP is often the top rated one along with the top E/Ep

mufasa 09-08-2008 06:02 PM

Tim:

Thanks for both of your responses. I have heard and more importantly read that improving early speed is sometimes a hint of good things to come. Cary Fotias had many good things to say about improving early speed in his book “Blinkers Off.” I have always seriously considered such improving speed as a form or conditioning factor, but not necessarily as a pace line selection consideration.

Your use of the improving recent E/EL rating to select pace lines is different, interesting, and as you say effective. I have to keep this in mind when looking at pace line selection. The only problem that I have is that I have picked some nice bombs from rare time to rare time using pace lines for contenders that go way back, certainly way past the last 3-4 lines. Since it is rare then really what am I giving up if I hold myself to the most recent racing by all contenders?

Thanks again,

Robert

Turbulator 09-08-2008 06:05 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Would it be possible for someone to put up the PPs for all of the horses in this race using the same software program? Or even RDSS if it has the same readouts needed to make the OPs comparisons.

I have seen this analysis made dozens of times now and I still don't get it. Yes, I know, I'm slow--but I'm stubborn. Maybe by looking an entire race and pointing out exactly what I'm supposed to be looking at the light bulb will go on.

Thanks

Steve

Tim Y 09-08-2008 06:12 PM

in context
 
1 Attachment(s)
In comparison to the field it becomes more obvious. Chosen by improving E/EP not e/l here. the FAR left column listed in the first capture. You outlined TPP and e/l neither of which show the improving early speed.

KISS, don't complicate something that needs no complication.
10th race - Philadelphia Park - September 08, 2008
Pgm Horse Win Place Show
4 Lit Bema 22.00 8.60 3.00
9 Blushin' Fax 4.40 3.00
3 Emmerton Lane 2.60

$2 Exacta 4-9 105.60
$2 Superfecta 4-9-3-1 626.20

Turbulator 09-08-2008 06:35 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I need some help with this graphic.

mufasa 09-08-2008 06:52 PM

Tim:

I see that after having picked the best pace lines on the basis of improving E/EL for each contender you then reduce the competition down to the best 5 horses and match them up with the Spec 160 Matchup screen. What did you use to get down to the best 5 contenders? Did you use to assist you other aspects of Energy like TPP or the Energy rating, or how about BLBL?

Thanks,
Robert

Tim Y 09-08-2008 07:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mufasa (Post 39708)
Tim:

I see that after having picked the best pace lines on the basis of improving E/EL for each contender you then reduce the competition down to the best 5 horses and match them up with the Spec 160 Matchup screen. What did you use to get down to the best 5 contenders? Did you use to assist you other aspects of Energy like TPP or the Energy rating, or how about BLBL?

Never thought about it. I NEVER use bl/bl NEVER......Most fields have far more than 5 contenders. TOtal energy can be often be used in routes, but never in sprints......TPP is good for routes....Never do it the exactly the same way twice

There is a great book you should read, TWO actually. BLINK by Malcolm Gladwell who states that once you understand the "essence" of something you can have far LESS information when understanding something

and SECOND a book that Howard Sartin touted COMPLEXITY by Walrop which is the basis for how I use all the programs. It is about self organizing systems in chaos. When I evaluate a race, I throw in several lines for each horse and then let the program TELL ME who might be leading at the second call (much like the fulcrum)

I then go back to see if that line, which I then compare to all the rest, was an aberration or a repeatable line. If I have let's say 6 contenders ABCDEF

I them go back and compare lines A1,A4,A7 to BCDEF and then go through EACH one, the same way (i.e ACDEF, to B2, B3, B6) to get an idea how multiple lines compare to one another which cancels out sample error.

mufasa 09-08-2008 07:41 PM

Tim thanks for your responses on this subject.

Robert

Bill V. 09-08-2008 08:07 PM

The BLBL VDC and The Beard screen
 
Thanks Richie

I can't believe you posted about Joe beard
You beat me to it .

Joe "Beard" Is a man who makes most of his income from
wagering He is very good at harness racing. So he always was near by the table... To get some good info about what he calls "the flats" The cool thing about Joe is that he just wants to know the top 3 on BLBL VDC and the "beard screen" as we came to call the Incremental match up graph
He would take our numbers and make the bet. He is a very generous man
when he hits

"The Val gets horses nobody else gets "
I guess you all can see why I like Joe


One of my favorite days at Monmouth Park
was a day Rich Joe and I drove down from the Meadowlands
on a beautiful summer Saturday to meet up with my Dad
for a afternoon of live races

Turbulator 09-08-2008 09:22 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Is this right?

socantra 09-08-2008 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill V. (Post 39713)
The cool thing about Joe is that he just wants to know the top 3 on BLBL VDC and the "beard screen" as we came to call the Incremental match up graph
He would take our numbers and make the bet. He is a very generous man
when he hits

"The Val gets horses nobody else gets "
I guess you all can see why I like Joe

He's certainly right about the Val getting horses that nobody else gets. It may not be for everyone, but for me its the closest to Magic that I've ever used.

Dick

Bill V. 09-09-2008 06:33 AM

Screen multible lines
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbulator (Post 39715)
Is this right?

Steve something more to add in regards to your questions


I'm sure whatever Tim is doing to get his contenders
works for him but to Tim

This statement

Never thought about it. I NEVER use bl/bl NEVER......Most fields have far more than 5 contenders. TOtal energy can be often be used in routes, but never in sprints......TPP is good for routes....Never do it the exactly the same way twice

I have no idea of the distance of race for the screen shot your showing
But I see

Lines from Pha, Del, Crc and Penn,
I see sprints of 5.5 6.0 and 7.0
I see Routes of 8.3 and 8.0 and
I see a Turf route of 8.3

I just want to add that using the BLBL and Total Energy
Which are two vital readouts of the Sartin Methodology
These readouts do work equally well at both sprints and routes
and on turf and dirt
If you follow Sartin Methodology guidelines and
use the best of the last 3 pace lines at a comparable
distance, surface and competition level
Using many lines for horses is encouraged
when more than one line is considered
Its the guideline of the Methodology
to let the program decide what line is best

Thanks
Bill

Jonathan Steele 09-09-2008 01:25 PM

"Quick anecdotal story about Validator and it's V/DC readout when it first came out in the late 90's."

Hey Richie! Thanks for sharing the really cool story!

"Freddie was one of the first users of a deceleration program back in the late 80's/early 90's and headed a wager syndicate that made well over a million dollars in a few years."

Wow...

Best regards,

Jon

Tim Y 09-09-2008 09:10 PM

every race is different
 
Folks should never try to "cool book" races (follow some set guidelines for EVERY CONTEST) as NO two races are the same, no tracks are the same, no surfaces are the same, no match ups are the same.

After reviewing the methodology at over 40 race courses one has to understand that different parts of the program gain greater emphasis at say the Fair Grounds versus Aqueduct or Keeneland.

Each is a unique event that should be considered as such.

Charlie D 09-09-2008 09:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 39729)
NO two races are the same, no tracks are the same, no surfaces are the same, no match ups are the same.



Each is a unique event that should be considered as such.



Yep and this is why you need to create a "picture" of the horse(s) from the PP in your mind


These pictures should then give you a good idea as to whether Horse A, B, C etc can transfer from FG to Aqu etc


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.