![]() |
Trainer Intent
For those of you who think that everytime a trainer sends out a horse he is trying to win with it I suggest you read The Gasman Lights Up the Toteboard by Gasper Moschera.For those of you not familiar with him he only won the NY trainer title six times.
Just because you use follow the Sartin Methodology doesnt mean you cant open your eyes to new things. |
I use trainer info a lot, but I use it as a reason to forgive bad lines and go back to better ones. Works well for me, but the horse still has to match up on pace in the end. I find this very useful ad cheaper tracks with a lot of conditioned claiming races.
I'm ordering that book today, Jeff....I got a good review of it from a friend. |
Tom.Im sure you will enjoy it Gasman was really a master at the claiming game.Jeff
|
Shoeless correctly said:
"Just because you use follow the Sartin Methodology doesnt mean you cant open your eyes to new things." If you can successfully incorporate non-Sartin corollaries into your analysis, especially when handicapping cheap and very cheap horses, you only $tand to benefit. I'm sure Doc would agree. But if you can't, you should strictly adhere to the methodology as prescribed. Regards, Jon |
Jeff,
I thought about buying this book in the past but declined based upon a review from someone on that 'other' forum. Basically, from what this person said, you'd have to be at the track to gain those insights that Gaspar mentions in his book. Is this correct? Or can something be gained from its reading to better (read: more correctly) intrepret the past performances? Regards, Jon |
Trainer Intent
While Doc Sartin excluded trainer intent aand jockeys from the methodology,
he advised anyone who wished to use these factors to investigate, and keep records. If they were able to profit, more power to them. He never stated jockey and trainer factors had little, or no value. The intention was to avoid being distracted by isolated factors and angles. If a person kept records, and found the jockey and trainer material to be supplemental to their handicapping, then by all means , use it. Anytime someone would introduce non-sartin methodology material or ideas at a seminar, the advice was: "do a study on anything you feel would aid your bottom line, and from your records, proceed accordingly" Some would ask : what about first time or second time lasix? What about bandages on the front legs?? What about certian type shoes?? what about trainer percentages?? The answer was clear and simple. We kept no data on any of that material. It isn't part of the methodology. If you wish to research it, be my guest. Make your wagering decisions based on your personal records. The oweness is on you. BobC:) |
Jonathan,In my opinion most of the info in the book you did not have to be at the track just the good ole DRF.Jeff
|
Bob,Thanks for clearing that up and you should know.Jeff
|
Quote:
Regards, Jon |
Bob said:
"While Doc Sartin excluded trainer intent aand jockeys from the methodology, he advised anyone who wished to use these factors to investigate, and keep records. If they were able to profit, more power to them." You see, just as I thought! :) Thanks Bob. Jon |
Quote:
|
If you are into the trainer side of things, two older books I would recommend reading are:
Inside the Claiming Game by Steve Collison Handicapping Trainers by John Whittaker Jim |
Unless you are THERE you don't know
Horses, like athletes in any sport, are, and always will be INDIVIDUALS. These books about databases somehow allowing the author to let you "read the trainers mind" are pure and unadulterated MALARKEY. All three year old filles have nothing more in common than their sex and their age, as do three year old turf runners.
I spent two years as a volunteer groom and hot walker and learned first hand the myriad number of ways distinctly different horses require distinctly different training regimens. This one is a finicky eater, this one tends to throw shoes, this one has a hard time running inside of other horses (just like the Big Brown out one), this one gets bored in the stall and needs a goat friend and when that friend in not there he will not train, this one has gone barn sour and needs a freshening, aother one gets a sore back if he works longer than 5 furlongs, this one needs a special unregulated bit for his workouts and we hope we can control him with lesser bits on race day, this one requires special handling away from other unaltered males, etc etc. The way each of these problems are dealt with is enormously different. A friend just bought a five year old maiden standard bred a few weeks ago. "The other trainer missed that fact that this one needs a strong head pole and a few other goodies to keep her mind on racing." Sam made a few changes and the horse, since that change of trainer and change of simple equipment, has made three starts won twice and ran 4th the other time. You could never "read into that" from any database. IT IS THE INDIVIDUAL horse that requires INDIVIDUAL treatment. there are several miles of MIS-UNDERSTANDING between what might APPEAR to be cause and effect and what really is. My favorite parallel is from a movie about a great baseball pitcher. In the stands a father answers his son's question: "Dad, why are the pitcher and catcher talking out there?" Dad: "well they are talking about how to pitch to this hitter." A close up on the pitcher and catcher; Pitcher: "so you still have that shot gun for sale?" Catcher:"yes but why ask me about it now?" Pitcher:"just wanted to make sure I talked to you ahead of the other guys." Unless you are there, GUESSING from a distance is just guessing. |
Got 'em both, Jim.....thanks.
Tim, most players are not there, and even if they are, it still a guess to some degree. The payoff balances it all out. You know what reward you will get for your risk. You have no assurance that any horse you bet off his pace numbers is not hurting today or is still in shape enough to run back to those number. Many times there will be no recent lines that get the winner, but having reason to go back to better races in another form cycle can do it. That is how I use trainer patterns. Quite successfully for over 30 years. I this not malarkey when you know what you are talking about, and you don't really seem to grasp how other use the data. You yourself post database results as to E/L requirements frequently, in fact, your database told you that Aqueduct inner had changed and you stopped laying for a while, then it told you things were back to normal and you played it again. Proper use of a database in handicapping. |
handicapping trainers didnt care for
inside claiming game was good |
Tim,A lot of things you post are MALARKEY as well.
|
Quote:
At arm length books don't cut it. Suggested dogmatically entrenched Information has a habit of "filling in the blanks with guesswork" when no rational information is available. i have read, AD NAUSEUM, these simplistic efforts in explaining what is a very complicated and horse specific regimen. No two horses learn the same way: some are good students and others take many months to 'get it' and not all via the same path. The trainer I spent the most time with actually told an owner to find another trainer since HIS methodology would not work on a particular three year old. There are animals that have poor vision in one eye, those that cross fire or over-reach, in toed and out toed, conformational problems that hurt (back at the knee) and others (swayback sprinters) that actually helps horses run better. There is no one answer to teaching a horse to suppress it's instincts to throw a rider as a perceived predator as much as any one way to train fillies or colts over turf or dirt runners. EACH horse has a different individualized training regimen that reflects on it's specific needs.To try and bundle them all up in any one category is downright ridiculous. Often it is the TRAINER working the horse him/herself that gives them the specific information they need to progress with the training. |
Quote:
The only thing that matters is the predictive value of it all. What you say above is all well and good, but not the right argument.You do not know how we use trainer data, so please do not presume you do. |
My insight comes from knowing several small time trainers,just because you have worked on the backstretch for a certain trainer and he does it one way doesnt mean a thing.Actually Im glad that their are people like you as it enables me to get better prices on these trainer patterns that according to you dont exist.
|
I spent two years as a volunteer groom and hot walker
Tim,Im very impressed with your racetrack resume lets see besides this worked with starting gate crew take pictures for photo finishes boiled hot dogs at the concession stand The only thing it seems you havent done is been a track announcer and ridden in an actual race.Whoops I better not open my mouth so soon you probably will tell me you have done that as well |
Quote:
Jim |
Preston Burch, hall of fame trainer,from Training Thoroughbred Horses 1953 The Blood-Horse, from the preface p. VII
"No one can tell a man how to train his horse, he must study each one of his horses individually, and train them according to how they take their work." "There are few generalizations on training. There are exceptions to all rules as in everything else." You will find the same sentiment by Lauren in Nack's books on Secretariat, Frederico Tessio's Breeding the Race Horse, and in Woody Stephens biography Guess, I'm Lucky. Great trainers who worked with champions and not so champions expressing the need for individual training methods, not an "at arms length" statistician. Want real information go to the practitioners of it not pretenders. |
Do I have to give back the money? :D
|
Interesting post over at P.A. from a long time "trainer intent" believer and bettor. Seems like history has repeated itself for 12 years running.
Looks like he is cashing in quite nicely. http://www.paceadvantage.com/forum/s...ad.php?t=55611 =================================================== Some of the best bets are finding the sweet spots of those 10% trainers. A 10% trainer might be 30% in some catagory in some specific race meet. I have a trainer that wins with first time starters 40% of the time over the last 12 years at a specific track only in a certain month yet if you go by DRF or BRIS stats it will show him around 15 percent. He rarely wins outside of this month with those babies. And that's every year. |
thxs Rich...it was interesting but he didnt divulge who it was :cool: ...stuff like this is still part of my handicapping and helps me to be a all around handicapper
mike |
If you are going to play the multi-race bets, you almost have to have more tools in your box than just pace. Too many races in the middle of the P4 or P6 just aren't going to have what we need, so other tools must be used.
When you finish mowing 98& of your lawn, you still need to finish off the last 2% with a trimmer (groan). :D |
From Jerry Stokes' Secrets of Handicapping ebook, Chapter 4 - The Trainer Maneuvers:
"Now that we've covered the very basic stuff I want to acquaint you with what we'll call Trainer Maneuvers. These "moves" are things trainers use to check the condition of their "charges" or one they own. The reason they do this is to try and hide the horses' form or condition from the public. They do this as they want to get the odds as high as possible before they try for the "gold" so to speak. Most trainers we will be running across have to supplement their income with winning wagers." Trainer maneuvers are especially useful when you're dealing with cheap and very cheap horses. Again, I want to emphasize, I do not (nor should anyone else) use these angles as the sole indicator to base my decisions on in the parimutuel fund investment arena. It is used as a supporting corollary and/or those times when horses don't have the 'numbers' to correctly assess their potential. Jon |
Vacuum logic: seeing a process that SEEMS like it is one way, but having no idea of what actually happens, one fills in the vacuum with supposed cause and effect. Sad state of affairs to analyze based upon no first hand knowledge.
To ovrelalay generalizations upon factors that NO one but the trainer and owner knows is a byproduct of too many episodes of watching Boots Malone (William Holden) or Salty O'Rourke (Alan Ladd) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0038047/ Real trainers, not the ones not the fantasized ones that are incorporated in these books of fiction that are hot sellers, are more akin to cowboys or teachers. These nefarious episodes make good reading IF they are in the pages of Dick Francis, but in reality these 'betting coups" are ridiculous given the tools that the parimutuel and film patrol have over the running of the programs. They make for good stories so I guess that is why these urban legends persist. |
Quote:
When the purse was large enough, a LGA shiipper under his tutelage would make the trip to Vancouver. They won at a much higher rate that all of his other stock, BUT it was that the horses were better, not the trainer although with a statistical eye his 14% wins regularly and his 28% wins with shippers (every one was from Mrs. Whitham's barn) could be inferred (incorrectly) in all kinds of ways with "vacuum logic." |
And could be inferred correctly as well.
This is not a mean justifies the ends game, it is a results only game. The only thing that matters is the result, no payoff on method. If we keep good records, we know what results our method yields. No one cares why. The 28% wins rate with one owners is a factoid a good DB will reveal. Not that you would bet blindly ( you don't think that is what we do, do you?). But it would certainly give me a reason to open the window for pace lines. Here is the key....somewhere in the past, the horse has shown the ability to beat today's field, and we are looking for reasons to go go past bad lines and find the good ones. You yourself talk about using Pizzolla's window on turf races, but do you do the same on dirt? If not, why? Why turf and not dirt? |
Quote:
FRAME of reference lines are always used to see the trend to a cycle, but there is simply no correlation to turf and dirt form. NADA |
So you blindly use the best?
What I'm getting at is, you do not know where the horse is at today, high or low in it's cycle, but you know using the best results in winners. |
Tim, I understand your not liking trainer intent but why do you have to ruin it for others who may.I wish I had the skill to interperate readouts the way you,Richie and Bill do but I dont.I have to rely on my ability to pick the right paceline and use things such as trainer intent to give me an edge.On a side note every since I stopped trying to emulate you guys I have gotten back on the right track.The reason being that I have started to depend on TPR numbers using Synergism,I know they seem simple but they are really a powerful tool thanks to Houndog's excellent job of updating the pars[he should be a programmer].
|
Tom and Jon,How did both of you get started with trainer intent?For me it was Davidowitz from his daily radio show he used to do in Maryland and his book.
|
Quote:
If a validated difference of opinion with data to back it up is ruining something than you do not have much breadth of thought on the subject. THINGS ARE NOT BLACK AND WHITE, NOTHING is. |
Im bowing out here life's too short to argue over this trivial BS
|
Quote:
|
I would like to apologize to those of you out there who were interested in this topic unfortunately someone here main mission is to try and wreck other people's post when it doesnt agree with his philosophy.If interested I will continue to post this over at PA.
|
Shoeless asked:
"Tom and Jon,How did both of you get started with trainer intent?" Hi Jeff, First, from Jerry Stokes' Secrets of Handicapping ebook; second, Jim Lehane's Calibration Handicapping book; third, Boxcar's (Ray Taulbot-based) Handicapping Methodology. Jon |
Jon,Those three are good especially Taulbot.Jeff
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:45 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.