![]() |
MODELING - Does it matter?
Here is a handicapping statistic I keep and the results of that statistic for the current month of January.
It has a dollar net of $1.85 based on a single horse bet. Not too impressive, is it? At this point the only surface that is not included is turf. It seems many people (not all) only model on the basis of ‘distance and surface’. Well, as you can see the $1.85 dollar net is all inclusive except for turf, so let’s take a deeper look at this. I’ll break these races down by race type. ST (stake races).................= $1.50 dollar net AL(allowance race).............= $0.58 dollar net SA (starter hcp races).........= $1.27 dollar net MS (maiden special weight)..=$0.48 dollar net MC (maiden claiming)..........= $1.13 dollar net OC (optional claiming).........= $1.94 dollar net We started with a dollar net of $1.85 and except for the 'OC' which is $1.94 (just .09 higher) these are terrible, but if they are terrible then something had to be good. It was. CL (claiming races)...= $2.46 dollar net I have taken a dollar net that is much better than average and yet still a loser at $1.85 and found something that has a dollar net of $2.46 or an ROI of +23%, just by breaking down the races by race type. But let’s take an even closer look. What happens if we break this down by sex? CL/males.....= $2.18 CL/females..= $2.83 Both are winners, but I like $2.83 a lot better than $2.18. Like I said at the start, I only excluded turf, so let’s see how this does on dirt and artificial surfaces. Dirt........= $2.43 Artificial..= $2.51 Not much difference there Let’s take a look at some extremes with different tracks. Track A...= $1.41(lowest) Track B...= $3.39(highest) Enough said there. How about distances? Sprints...= $2.00 Routes...= $3.22 Enough said there as well. Oh, remember that 'OC' with a $1.94 dollar net? Let's take another look at that. I'll break it down by sex. OC/males......=$2.39 OC/females...=$1.23 You just never know if you don't look. So you see what you can do with something that initially appears to be a loser when you break races down into various categories. If you aren’t modeling, maybe you should be. If you are only modeling distance and surface, maybe you should reconsider you approach to modeling. Just some food for thought. |
Facts
Thank you FTL
Thank you for taking the time to share this with us I'm positive it will be a big help I appreciate your efforts to bring extra tools to our group rather than good guesses Good Skill Bill |
Alw
Hi FTL
I see the ALW races are low Do you know if this is from NW1 or are the NW2, 3 4, or restricted to state bred type that are better than others I seem to have more problems with non winner 1 other than maiden claiming or starter The more a horse wins I seem to do better I do better in better races than with young maiden winners and I do not do many maiden races at all Bill |
Quote:
I hope his hard work pays off for him. At any rate, it looks like it is the labor of love. Thank you for you efforts and sharing. As of late, I have been finding that the biggest prices and profit come from the very contentious types of races (The Cheaper The Better). There are some exacta players on this board that would agree with me. They have had success at MNR, PHA and DEL. I don't model, I have tried on a few occasions and felt it was a waste of time. I leave the modeling to those that play just one track. Tom Brohamer did this at Santa Anita. He was a one track specialist. There are specific type of races and specific type of horses at value odds that appeal to me. My method is simple. look for specific patterns and angles in contentious races. Dirt, Turf, AW, Fast, Sloppy, Muddy or Wet. Look for the things that will not be seen by others. I look for value. I can't add much more then that. I personally do not care for the exotics. That is why my recent efforts have been focused on pattern recognition, angle play and strictly win betting which does involve some good guesses. :D If I guess right in one out of 7-10 races odds permitting, I will be ahead of the game. Horse Racing is a numbers game. |
Quote:
|
FTL, may I ask is this all tracks and or just a few select tracks, like A/B/C/D or I am sure and have tried modeling, as Bill stated it was a labor of love that I found very hard to keep up with, not that the info would not be helpful, that much is obvious.
Wow we been getting great stuff here lately, thanks everyone for sharing all this, and RDSS or P&C forum has some of the very best players out there, look at the top of the leaderboards, but even more are the people who do not play the contest still contribute here, for which I am myself am very greatful for, as I have taken a little here and there and become a more expericend and patient player, with lots of work left to be done, but very much better than , say 2 years ago, most in part to this community, thanks . patrick |
[QUOTE=For The Lead;77481]
ST (stake races).................= $1.50 dollar net AL(allowance race).............= $0.58 dollar net SA (starter hcp races).........= $1.27 dollar net MS (maiden special weight)..=$0.48 dollar net MC (maiden claiming)..........= $1.13 dollar net OC (optional claiming).........= $1.94 dollar net We started with a dollar net of $1.85 and except for the 'OC' which is $1.94 (just .09 higher) these are terrible, but if they are terrible then something had to be good. It was." FTL: If I understand you correctly are you saying that Claiming races are excluded from the above sample? I assume that you do not consider optional claiming races as claiming races even at the lower end of the spectrum (like OC 25 NW whatever?) - is this the case? Eye opening post and thanks for sharing. Bill |
[QUOTE=Bill Lyster;77495]
Quote:
No, sorry if I wasn't clear. The beginning sample that returned a dollar net of $1.85 included all of the above as well as "CL" (claiming races). What I did was break down that $1.85 by race types, showing all the negative dollar nets first. Having completed that, the only race type left was "CL" (claiming races), which is where the profit from this particular stat came from. Without breaking it down this way, you would just look at the original $1.85 and say "oh well". Then I went further and further by breaking just the claiming races down by sex. Then by surface. Then I showed the return for the worst track and the best track. Finally, I went back to the "OC" that was $1.94 and simply broke that down by sex to show that there was, indeed, a profit there as well. No, I don't consider an optional claiming race (OC) to be the same as a claiming race (CL). The reason being, if you look at the entire condition, it is an Allowance Optional Claiming race and they are run under allowance type conditions, such as NW1X, NW2X and etc. My point to this thread was to simply point out, that if you only model by distance and surface, you may not find profitable areas that can be exploited. |
Quote:
As you have been saying, horse racing is a numbers game and you are correct. Horse racing is a “maze” of numbers without meaning unless you keep records. The dollar net for all winners at all tracks every year is $1.54, give or take a penny based on the given year. Whether one thinks so or not, that is a tough maze to find your way out of in order to reach the break even point, let alone reach a respectable profit. Without record keeping (modeling) you have two chances, slim and none. I took a random year and did some dollar nets for a variety of tracks. Here are the results. TAM=$1.55 GP..=$1.57 PIM=$1.50 HOU=$1.50 FG..=$1.50 AQU=$1.59 SA..=$1.57 HOL=$1.50 PRX=$1.56 PEN=$1.50 OP..=$1.46 TP..=$1.50 As you can see, it doesn’t matter which track you are playing, your work is cut out for you. In order to win, you have to keep records (modeling) so you can find where the profits are. Just a note here; I didn’t accumulate 600,000 races by being a “one track” player. Also, this is the first time I have ever heard someone categorize Tom Brohamer as a “one trick pony”. The man has probably “forgotten” more about handicapping than most handicappers “know”! Was he a one track specialist or did he “make his bones” before the advent of the internet and simulcasting came along, forcing him to play just one track…like everybody else?! At any rate, here are the results of another statistic I keep. For the entire year of 2011, this statistic returned a dollar net of $2.82. That dollar net was based on a single horse bet with a win rate of 27% and an “average” win price of $10.38. This statistic produced these optimum profits from 3 race classes, maiden claiming, maiden special weight and claiming. Naturally, there were some tracks that did better than others. These results come from the tracks that did best. Without modeling, be it one track or multiple tracks, these profitable areas would not be known. |
Quote:
For Single Horse Win bets: *Dirt Claiming and Allowance sprints generate my highest win percentage. *Turf routes have the greatest ROI. *I've lost money on artifical surfaces with the exception of Woodbine. Based on fixed odds of 7/2, and pari-mutuel odds of 4-1 at post time my overall ROI for year was 1.13 (or a $Net of $2.26). However this is somewhat overinflated as rebates are included. So, based on my record keeping the only artfical surface I'll be win betting for 2012 is Woodbine. Record keeping -- it's a pain in the keister...but without it...well, you get the picture. |
Tom
Hi FTL
I agree, Tom was special This is from the Pace line manual " Tom Brohamer Is Pircos only handicapping purest. he is thoroughly grounded in every aspect of what he calls "the game". He has read and digested every valid work on the subject and writes and speaks with an authority born of knowledge and experience. A professional athlete from a family of professional athletes, he approaches the races as a golfer does a new course sizing up each fairway,approach and green; then making a game plan appropriate to his analysis and knowledge of his own skills. he would make a top flight baseball manager,shrewdly playing the percentages. Having been once burned in a private business venture, he is the most conservative of this tutorial staff. He concentrates his handicapping efforts on the type of races that he knows are most predictive using his approach. He often sacrifices high mutuals for pin point accuracy; although still enjoying some long priced ventures. If the variant making procedure of Andy Beyer, the form cycle evaluation of William Scott and the classification guidelines of James Quinn can be called conventional ; then Tom is the most conventional member of our group. he also enjoys the highest win percentage " Tom was a master and produced a daily variant and horse to watch list for both north and south California circuts Thanks Bill |
FTL:
Quote:
I do not model but I came up with the same conclusions as you did with small exceptions. Do you have figures for all type of turf races? I am a follower of Brohamer. He set the precedent for pace handicapping as we know it. I am not faulting or criticizing him. From what I've been led to believe and what I've been told, the man specialized in just one track, Santa Anita. |
Correction
Quote:
Correction: I meant Maiden Special Weights on the turf. |
Tom specialized in both the SoCal and NorCal circuits and did his variants for both. At the time, Golden Gate & Bay Meadows in NorCal and the same tracks as today in SoCal. I believe he used to take Fairplex off. Of course, all the tracks had dirt surfaces back then.
When Tom went to Vegas he played multiple tracks and as he went around the country to seminars, he played the nearby tracks. He used his same concepts and was successful everywhere. Par charts and the "Brohamer Model" were keys to his success. While an ex boss who took me to the Turf Club on closing day 1988 is responsible for me getting interested in handicapping, the hour that Tom spend with me privately at a McDonald's near Santa Anita in 1989 at my request was probably what spurred me on. I had the privilege to spend time as part of many small groups with Tom and at Santa Anita with his friends Quinn and Romano. I also participated in Dick Mitchell's handicapping classes at Cynthia Pub in the early 90's in the evenings. I would drive from Pasadena where I worked to Studio City once a week - think they lasted about 7 weeks. Gordon Pine, Ron Ambrose, and Kitts Anderson manning the front desk were around Cynthia then. I also paid for a day at Hollywood Park of private handicapping with the trio of Dick Mitchell, Ron Ambrose, and Barry Meadow. Watching Barry watch the monitors with his overlay charts was fascinating - don't know how he did it. I consider my style mainly Brohamer with a touch of Quinn and Mitchell, and a pinch of Meadow. I currently use a mix of AOdds and EXDC Thoromation to fine tune my contenders into potential bets. BTW, I fully agree with FTL's opinion on the value of modeling in whatever way works for the individual. Since we can't win all the races we invest in, it's about putting as much of the percentages in our favor as we can. That's also why Dorianmode's approach sounds logical. If the last 30 races at 6F have been won by E types running close to the lead and my analysis comes up with a couple of S horses as my win candidates, why buck the percentages? The only reason would be ego centered and any time I've gone that way, it's cost me money. Either re-analyze or pass. If one of the S types does end up winning, just smile and move on. I also agree with FTL's thoughts on class that he has posted before and class is critical to my handicapping but that's a discussion for another day. With few exceptions, horses do move up and down a track's class levels in an orderly and logically determined manner and there are no bargains at the track. |
Quote:
With regard to Brohamer, I have read and heard all the same things, moreover, not only did he play Santa Anita, but more specifically, the OAK TREE meet. My point, however, is in those days EVERYBODY "specialized" or "played" just one track, so he can't be faulted for that. There was no simulcasting, no internet, no off shore betting and etc. You either went to the track or you didn't play. (bookmakers aside) Yes, I have figures for turf, but they are meaningless. Aside from Florida and the West coast, turf racing is basically a summer event. There are too few races when it comes to turf racing to allow for "breaking them down" and garnering any meaningful statistics. In a given year there are roughly 1,000 turf races for maidens...at ALL the tracks combined. This leaves very few per track, per race type. The results, therefore, are not conclusive. Consider that even during the summer months, turf races (of any race type) do not dominate the racing card, there are just a couple of them mixed in. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Record keeping, while not the modeling of rankings and such, does give you useful information as you have shown. In the information I have posted here, there is an underlying set of statistical information that was accumulated first. Once having that information, you can go on and learn things about different tracks, surfaces, distances, race types, age, sex and etc. I'm sure you didn't arrive at your conclusions without a set of underlying statistics of your own. It seems modeling would be a "natural" for you. |
There must be something in the air, all these great players sharing so much lately, with us, let me say a Big Thank You, for all of us.
These post's of late have been classic, almost like follow ups themselves, with a touch of today in them, really great stuff, guys. patrick |
FTL, I *do*indeed model. As a matter of fact virutually all of my monster hits have come from modeling.
I was keeping modeling, record keeping, win bets, exotic bets, etcetera as separate topics. That's all. One of the nice things about Dick Mitchell's old All-In-One programs was the automatic modeling it would do. For example it would start with 6F dirt races. Then when it had enough statistically significant data it would break it down by sex, age, race conditions, track conditions, etc. I no longer use those All-In-One programs (I think I had three or four versions starting with 3-in-1) and manually create track models. When I was younger and more industrious I'd have several models. Now I only model GP then CRC when it opens. It will be interesting to see what Ted comes up with for RDSS models. |
Addendum: I have Bettor Keep Track and used to update it daily.
It's a fine program, but the manual entry just got to me after a while. |
Quote:
We had one $2 double on the 1st 2 races, a $2 pick 6 and 3 races with $5 exactas (something like the 3rd,5th, and 7th race)- that's it. Simulcasting started in 1988 but not as you might think. You had 8 facilities from Bakersfield to San Diego, either racetracks or fair grounds that could accept bets on the track that was running. However, if the track that was running was within 35 miles of one of these facilities, the facility had to stay closed. Same limited wagering menu, btw. I remember going to Ventura or Santa Barbara for a change of pace to play HOL - long ride but the trip to Inglewood was not real enticing. |
[QUOTE=lsosa54;77597]And the wagering menu was limited, sometimes I think maybe for the better, although I guess more choice is always good.
We had one $2 double on the 1st 2 races, a $2 pick 6 and 3 races with $5 exactas (something like the 3rd,5th, and 7th race)- that's it. /QUOTE] When I first started there was a daily double on the first two races and after that it was WIN, PLACE and SHOW. THAT WAS IT!!! And since the daily double required picking 'the WINNER" in each of the first two races, learning how to "PICK WINNERS" was the PRIMARY concern. Nobody cared which horse was running second, third, 4th 10th or whatever today's gimmicks require. There was no such thing as a "contender" for 4th!! The old days certainly made you learn how to handicap...to WIN! |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:28 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.