Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   NewPace Discussion Forum (old) (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=90)
-   -   My latest study of VDC & CSR (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9188)

rmath 06-05-2013 04:03 PM

My latest study of VDC & CSR
 
My latest study of 650 races.
Same guidelines as before.
618/ 650 winners 95% were ranked in top 5 VDC OR CSR
529 were dual qualifers, ( Top 5 on both VDC & CSR) 81.4%
89 were single qualifers on VDC or CSR, .137
From the 529 dual qualifers:
225 34.6% were #1 vdc
148 22.8% were #2 vdc
93 14.3% were #3 vdc
49 7.5& were # 4 vdc
14 2.2% were #5 vdc

Because I Can Jim 06-06-2013 01:55 PM

Thank you for that information. :)

As someone new here on the forum, I do use the CSR to help me determine if I would want to handicap a race and the VDC to help somewhat in determining who might be contenders.

Appreciate the effort you put into it. It helps by providing some confidence in what I am doing.

Thanks again,
Jim

rmath 06-06-2013 06:07 PM

thanks
 
Thanks, Jim.
Appreciate your comments.
If I can help you in any way feel free to ask.
I enjoy sharing and if I am able to help anyone improve I am always willing to help.

Richard

pilot 06-07-2013 04:48 AM

Thanks for posting, Richard


Wayne

rmath 06-07-2013 11:02 AM

thanks
 
You are welcome, Pilot
Richard

mowens33 02-05-2014 11:17 AM

Data
 
rmath, I'm new to both rdss2 and new pace, this is great data! I want to make sure i'm understanding the data correctly? For instance if horses are both in the top 5 VDC and CSR the top 3 will win 72% of the time?
I am also curious as to what tracks you pulled your data from?
thanks, Mike

Bill Lyster 02-05-2014 01:16 PM

Richard:

I just wanted to see if my understanding about the CSR numbers are correct. So if you look at the entrants in each race after scratches the CSR values for each horse are a constant, because they relate solely to each horse's past performance. The remaining horses rank in CSR will not change, isn't that correct?

I also was wondering which tracks you play or which tracks were the subject of your study.

The reason I ask is that I redid all of last year's Delmar races for races at 5.5furlongs to 9f on poly and the incidence of winners in the top 4 CSR was only about 62% and for top 5 was 74%. I only did races for horses 3 YO and up, no turf, no maidens and field of 8 or more occasionally 7. Admittedly the sample size only encompassed 80 races because I had not downloaded all the cards, but it was what I had. Also, I understand that Delmar being a short meet might generate its own problems.



I purposefully did not handicap the races because I wanted to know how well CSR, all by itself, would put me in the neighborhood of winning. By rank the #1 CSR won 20%, the #2 rank won 21%, #3 - 8% and #4 - 13% and #5 - 12%. Curiously, the win percentages overall shrank as horses recorded a race over the Del Mar track.

This does not sound like it correlates to your study, hence the question about which tracks you are using in your research.

Interested in your insights.

Thanks,

Bill

I would be curious to know what the win percentages by CSR rank are from your study.

rmath 02-05-2014 02:20 PM

CSR study
 
Mowens33 & Bill L.
My stats are are taken from several diverse tracks.
Aqu, AP CD, CT, FL, PM, SA, REM, Prx, Suff, Ind, Mnr, Crc, Haw,WO , & Kee.

I try to avoid tracks that run short meets like Dmr,& Sar., because as you have found the numbers are not as reliable.
I prefer tracks that run the longer meets.

Bill, I will have to break down my ranks by the numbers to answer your other question.
I base my plays off the combination of VDC and CSR numbers, paying close attention to the horses that have a 1 or 2 in either vdc or csr and also have the other ranking as well.
Horses with 1-1, 1-2 ,1-3, or 2-3 are the strongest plays to win or place.

I will work on breaking the CSRs down by rank and post them later.

rmath

rmath 02-05-2014 03:12 PM

Bill
 
Bill, here is the breakdown on my csr study.
#1: .311
#2: .228
#3: .158
#4 : .123
#5: .073
Top 5 .893 wins

Bill,my question to you is : What setting are you using in RDSS for the DTV?
I have found that a setting of 100 works much better than 50.
I did two different studys of 500 and 600 races using the 50% setting and the 100% setting.
There was a big difference in the results. I had a better than 10% improvement in the top 5 csrs.

Hope this helps.

Bill Lyster 02-05-2014 03:14 PM

Thanks Richard,

One of my "to do"s is to go back and handicap the DMR races and correlate my version of VDC ranks with CSR, but obviously results will be weighted higher toward VDC results (assuming I handicap well enough), but still there is the chance that top VDC supported by top CSR may be more in line with your published info.


It will take a while, but I will report back when done.

Bill

Bill Lyster 02-05-2014 03:16 PM

When I did this study I used 100%, cleared the cache of all previous info and started anew, so my results were made with the same settings that you and Bill Varone discussed at the time you two were discussing this info.

Bill Lyster 02-05-2014 03:23 PM

I did have one further question. Did you ever look to see if there was a critical differential in CSR that horses could not overcome? or a range from which the winner came from?

So if the #1 CSR horse is 0.0 did you find that anyone with a CSR of say within 15.0, or within 10.0 or any other number, irrespective of rank, could win? If you found such a limiting number it might tighten up the contender selection.

Bill

rmath 02-05-2014 03:47 PM

Bill, I use the actual ranks and not the differencein them.
Although this is something that could be incorporated in another study.

mowens33 02-05-2014 08:54 PM

Richard, thanks for getting back to me so quickly. I have been using rdss2 for about a mouth know. I bet one track, Santa Anita, I've created a few models and have had some luck using Best VDC, last 3 and Best Preceptor, Last 3 compared, mainly for dirt sprints. Can't seem to find anything on the Turf?? Using the 2 horses to win methodology I am hitting (at this time) 42% of my wagers with a profit margin of 14%.
My hope is to improve my win percentage (and hopefully a few good combinations) by adding NewPace.
Thanks for the tip on the DTV (100%), I will give it a try!!
Any other tips you and Bill can give me will be much appreciated!!
thanks again, Mike

mowens33 02-05-2014 09:47 PM

Thanks
 
Richard, thanks for getting back to me so quickly. I have been using rdss2 for about a mouth know. I bet one track, Santa Anita, I've created a few models and have had some luck using Best VDC, last 3 and Best Preceptor, Last 3 compared, mainly for dirt sprints. Can't seem to find anything on the Turf?? Using the 2 horses to win methodology I am hitting (at this time) 42% of my wagers with a profit margin of 14%.
My hope is to improve my win percentage (and hopefully a few good combinations) by adding NewPace.
Thanks for the tip on the DTV (100%), I will give it a try!!
Any other tips you and Bill can give me will be much appreciated!!
thanks again, Mike

rmath 02-06-2014 09:35 AM

Mike
 
Mike, glad to help in anyway I can.
14% is a good starting point on your roi.
I have found Turf to be a little tougher to use Csr on.
I avoid turf races from my own personal play.
I try to limit my plays to Non Maiden races with 8 or more horses, at 5.5f to 8.5f. Also watch out for any race where several horses have less than 3 or 4 North American running lines as the Csr numbers are less likely to be as accurate.
I hope this helps. If you have any other questions feel free to ask.
I am always willing to help if I can.
Richard

mowens33 02-06-2014 04:17 PM

Rich, thanks!
Im sure there will be many questions to come!!
Mike

mowens33 02-10-2014 12:49 PM

NewPace Advanced
 
Richard, do you know if we're using NewPace or NewPace Advanced?

thanks, Mike

Ted Craven 02-10-2014 01:10 PM

Mike,

RDSS implements the original NewPace, not the Advanced version. Dave Svhwartz mentioned last year he was thinking of releasing yet another update to NewPace (NP 3.0 ?) , so I kind of just let it lie for now until that happened (though I never heard further, so I'm not sure what's happening with that, if anything).

However, FWIW, in this particular thread started by Richard, there's not really anything about using the NewPace readouts at all - just VDC and CSR. I think that's because originally, CSR (Composite Speed Rating) appeared only on the NewPace screen. Now it is in the general version of RDSS.

I think I'll just relocate this thread to the public RDSS Forum ... There has also been enough discussion elsewhere about usage of CSR ranks to help in Contender identification.

cheers,

Ted

mowens33 02-10-2014 01:47 PM

Ted, thanks for the update!
Mike

rmath 02-10-2014 06:44 PM

Mike
 
Mike, Ted answered your question before I could.
I do NOT use New Pace any more in my testing.
Rmath

mowens33 02-11-2014 10:07 AM

Richard, thanks for getting back to me!!

OldPR65 02-23-2014 11:55 AM

I'm very new to the forum and the RDSS2 software. I'm unable to find the VDC rating. Can someone help? Thanks in advance, Carlos

rmath 02-23-2014 08:35 PM

Carlos, welcome to pace and cap.
The Vdc rating is found on the BL/BL screen< it is right beside the BL/BL ratings.
Rmath

mowens33 02-23-2014 09:26 PM

Welcome
 
Carlos, welcome to RDSS!

Don't forget to check out the Sartin library, make sure you take the time to watch Dr. Sartin's video's.

Good Handicapping!!

Mike

OldPR65 02-23-2014 10:34 PM

Thank you for the help. I found it!
Carlos

rmath 02-23-2014 11:27 PM

Carlos, if you have any questions feel free to ask them. There are many people on this site that will help you or anyone else to get answers.
Good Luck.
rmath

OldPR65 02-23-2014 11:36 PM

I want to thank you rmath and the rest of the group for welcoming me and offering your help. I'm getting my feet wet with RDSS2. I studied Sartin way back in the 90's but then other things came up and now that I'm retired I want to enjoy it again. Thanks all!

OldPR65 02-24-2014 11:38 PM

When looking at the New Pace tab, what do all the different headings mean and which are the most important ones? Which horse is ranked highest within New Pace?

Thanks in advance, Carlos

rmath 02-25-2014 09:44 AM

Carlos
 
1 Attachment(s)
Attachment 36788


Carlos, here is a screen of the 4th at Parx for today.
The 4 NP horses are 10 & 1a Early
6 & 9 late.
In my opinion the most important numbers are the Comp SR #s in the last column. The top five are the 1-10-9-7 - & 1a , by ranking.
I concentrate on these top 5 and ties (when there are ties)
Most winners are found in these horses.
I rarely look at any of the other numbers on the NP screen.

Hope this helps.
Richard

OldPR65 02-25-2014 09:56 AM

Thank you Richard, Carlos

Ted Craven 02-25-2014 03:04 PM

Welcome Carlos!

The components of the NewPace system are covered in the videos you purchased from Dave Schwartz, so you should review them again to understand the concepts behind his system. Some of the gory detail calculations are not shown on the RDSS NewPace screen on the theory that people don't want to know what goes on under the hood, they just want the summary - or actionable - info. hence the layout you see.

Richard likes the Composite Speed Rating, though it is indeed a minor aspect of NP. CSR appears elsewhere in RDSS (Entries screen, BLBL screen) and is not strictly a component of NP. Though important, even useful is some circumstances, CSR has limitations and using it is not a substitute for understanding the matchup of running styles and energy disbursement abilities of the horses.

NP attempts to mathematically, and rigorously, quantify horses' Early tendency and ability and thus identify the 2 best of those Earlies, and be extension, the 2 best Late. These 4 horse are identified as Richard explained.

There is not a quantification in NP as to which of those 4 horses are better, nor is it a ranking of the 4 - merely the 2 best Early, and 2 best Late - according to the NP concepts - which can be flawed in individual races but at least are coherent over many races.

NewPace is not an aspect of the Sartin Methodology - but it is included as an alternate take on 'pace', and one independent of what paceline you may use to represent the horse today.

One tip: if you can find an early horse (especially the #1 Early), who appears otherwise compromised in the Early matchup - beginning at the break and the first fraction - and you can eliminate it from the win position - then your 4 horse collection becomes a 3 horse collection and whatever (for example) Exacta strategy you may use to capitalize on whatever insights NP may give you - becomes correspondingly cheaper.

I recommend you study the basic components of the Matchup Forum (Hat Check Forum) to identify how to eliminate compromised early horses. Also, check recent posts by kahunab on using Quirin Speed Points (QSP) to identify when there is too much early pressure on the Early horses (including the 2 NP Earlies) - and so to identify when the race will more likely go to the Other Than Early (OTE) type horses (sometimes co-inciding with the NP Late horses).

Many of Richard's (rmath) posts can also help explain the best use of Composite SR.

Hope that points you in some good directions.

cheers,

Ted

Dorianmode 03-29-2014 10:01 AM

One of the problems, (and I may be wrong, but I think not) with NewPace, was that in the computation he "lopped" off the top two, and bottom two SR's. (Schwartz doesn't really know much about statistics). It WAS a statistically legitimate thing to do, (for what he was/is doing), but there is a FAR better (statistically legitimate way) to do it. Schwartz says his method is 90 % "predictive". Well using a slightly different method, by definition, one can easily get 95 % behavior prediction. BUT there is no "free lunch". IF the last, (or any recent SR) is from a bad effort, or "fluke" race, or inappropriate (class or distance) race entered by the trainer, the SR can't be used, and must be deleted from the computation. There IS NO way to avoid actually doing the "handicapping" work. There is no "black box" that pops out a winner. Statistics are fun and very useful, but actually handicapping is ALWAYS necessary. I've talked with Ted about future versions of RDSS being enabled to delete SR's from these computations, meanwhile I do my own. They are FAR better. I used to use 10 SRs to get my "standard deviation range" (my own version of the "range" you see on the NP screen), but that's a lot of numbers to enter ... so I'm down to 5 SRs, for about 4 or 5 contenders, and I get just as good results... but it's better as it's more "recent", and SRs from races that should be tossed are eliminated.
A personal "readout" of my own "range" + a correctly (selectively) adjusted CSR has the winner in 95%+ of the top 3 horses. BUT, because of the poor odds offered these days on dirt sprints, I now only handicap large fields of turf races, so that's all I really have stats for. I use the entire "business" as a "confirmatory" thing ... if these numbers DON'T agree with what I was otherwise seeing, then I would likely pass the race.

Cheers.

Segwin 03-29-2014 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dorianmode (Post 96251)
One of the problems, (and I may be wrong, but I think not) with NewPace, was that in the computation he "lopped" off the top two, and bottom two SR's. (Schwartz doesn't really know much about statistics). It WAS a statistically legitimate thing to do, (for what he was/is doing), but there is a FAR better (statistically legitimate way) to do it. Schwartz says his method is 90 % "predictive". Well using a slightly different method, by definition, one can easily get 95 % behavior prediction. BUT there is no "free lunch". IF the last, (or any recent SR) is from a bad effort, or "fluke" race, or inappropriate (class or distance) race entered by the trainer, the SR can't be used, and must be deleted from the computation. There IS NO way to avoid actually doing the "handicapping" work. There is no "black box" that pops out a winner. Statistics are fun and very useful, but actually handicapping is ALWAYS necessary. I've talked with Ted about future versions of RDSS being enabled to delete SR's from these computations, meanwhile I do my own. They are FAR better. I used to use 10 SRs to get my "standard deviation range" (my own version of the "range" you see on the NP screen), but that's a lot of numbers to enter ... so I'm down to 5 SRs, for about 4 or 5 contenders, and I get just as good results... but it's better as it's more "recent", and SRs from races that should be tossed are eliminated.
A personal "readout" of my own "range" + a correctly (selectively) adjusted CSR has the winner in 95%+ of the top 3 horses. BUT, because of the poor odds offered these days on dirt sprints, I now only handicap large fields of turf races, so that's all I really have stats for. I use the entire "business" as a "confirmatory" thing ... if these numbers DON'T agree with what I was otherwise seeing, then I would likely pass the race.

Cheers.

Good post, thanks. If you get the chance I'd like to see you post an example of how you adjust your CSR (but understand if you don't).

vderdak 03-29-2014 08:02 PM

Segwin, not sure if Dorianmode will show his method or the way he does things and I wouldn't blame him. The last time I remember him showing his way he was subjected to a host of other people disagreeing and arguing with him about his method and what they didn't get was he was not telling them his way was the way for them to use new pace, only it was how he used new pace so if he does show anything this time around I hope everyone is more respectful to say the least.

Segwin 03-29-2014 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vderdak (Post 96267)
Segwin, not sure if Dorianmode will show his method or the way he does things and I wouldn't blame him. The last time I remember him showing his way he was subjected to a host of other people disagreeing and arguing with him about his method and what they didn't get was he was not telling them his way was the way for them to use new pace, only it was how he used new pace so if he does show anything this time around I hope everyone is more respectful to say the least.

That would be a shame. Only through the open exchange of ideas can we grow (not just in this sport). There are many different ways to skin the cat. Perhaps Ted exploing the pick 4 may prove profitable, perhaps not, however the exploration shold be encouraged. Not so long ago the Fulcrum horse was frowned upon here but now accepted.

We need to understand change is inevitable and not a personal attack. As I read through the followups the Doc was always undergoing change. I can only imagine where the state of things might be now. It's not personal, only perhaps a better widget.

Minds are like parachutes, they only function when open.

Dorianmode 03-29-2014 08:42 PM

Sorry for the delay ... I wasn't correctly linking into this discussion for some reason ?? Anyhoo, I'm quite happy to share my calculation method. Let me think about how to explain it best. I can add an Excel tool to make the "range", the corrected CSR, and a couple other things that "fall" out of it. I have races to prepare for tomorrow ... I'll try to get it posted by tomorrow evening.

Segwin 03-29-2014 08:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dorianmode (Post 96272)
Sorry for the delay ... I wasn't correctly linking into this discussion for some reason ?? Anyhoo, I quite happy to share my calculation method. Let me think about how to explain it best. I can add an Excel tool to make the "range", the corrected CSR, and a couple other things that "fall" out of it. I have races to prepare for tomorrow ... I'll try to get it posted by tomorrow evening.

Outstanding, thank you.

Dorianmode 03-31-2014 10:20 AM

working on this
 
Turns out my Excel tool that does these things, is full of links to other "sheets" that import and export things, so I have to clean it up, so it operates independently. So it's going to take a bit longer to prepare. I'm working on it.

Segwin 03-31-2014 11:34 AM

No problem - whenever you get the chance.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:33 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.