Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   Previous 'Handicapping Discussion' Forum (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   turf line selections (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=6864)

tizlinda 05-25-2010 02:41 PM

turf line selections
 
I am finding it the most difficult to select turf lines because of the number of horses that haven't found their best surface and distance. It seems that I often want to go back further than the last three in order to get a race closest to the surface and distance, but when I look at the models I have that have good corollaries 90 + % of them are from lines I've taken from the last 2 (mostly) or three, so I know the importance of that when it comes to selecting a race that represents the horses current form.

However, I remember reading years ago (not sure where) that when it comes to turf races you can open the book, so to speak, and look at all available lines. So I am struggling with that every time I do one. Can someone help me out with this? Do you take a dirt or poly race at the same distance last out over a long past turf race?

SilentRun 05-25-2010 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tizlinda (Post 66390)
However, I remember reading years ago (not sure where) that when it comes to turf races you can open the book, so to speak, and look at all available lines. So I am struggling with that every time I do one. Can someone help me out with this? Do you take a dirt or poly race at the same distance last out over a long past turf race?

Michael Pizzolla in his book, "Handicapping Magic" advocated to consider
EVERY race in the horses' past performance. (Turf only).

I am not proficient on the turf but I would say, " DO NOT take a dirt or poly race at the
same distance over a long past turf race". This is definitly not "COMPARABLE" which is one of the
cardinal principles of the Sartin Methodology. You can always refer to the "Follow Up"
(Sorry I can't cite the specific issue) and I am sure you will read that this is a "NO NO".

Ernie

Ted Craven 05-25-2010 04:29 PM

I agree with and try to practice Pizzolla's advice about 'opening the window wide' for Turf races - where possible. (For Dirt and Poly I try to stick to BOLT-C, best of last 3 comparable). I do this because I have had good results for years. Half the time, the good Turf lines are recent anyway.

I take the best Turf line, according to either or both Total Energy and Perceptor Total (similar distance structure if possible) from the entire PPs - if the horse appears fit based on running on any surface recently, or if it seems to be floundering on surfaces other than its evidently preferred Turf surface. If the horse has recent Turf lines and demonstrates inability to win, I won't credit it too much with back class by choosing a 2 year old line where it demonstrated consistently higher Total Energy from a group of races than it has recently.

If there are no Turf lines to consider at all, go with what you've got, but my own tendency is to almost always discount for Win a first timer on the Turf (maybe strong betting patterns or Odds will make me pass a race with such a first-time Turfer, or hedge my bets in case such strong odds are really indicating it is well-bred for Turf or from a Turf trainer specialist and I don't know about it).

Even not keeping a Decision Model for Turf races, at least in routes I focus on Hidden Energy and L/ep (as well as BL/BL and VDC of course).

FWIW :)

Ted

tizlinda 05-25-2010 05:09 PM

thanks, I do have handicapping magic so that must be where I read it. What did Sartin have to say about going deep in the pp's for the best turf race? I've read the guidelines in the yellow manual and didn't get confirmation on that strategy.

Ted Craven 05-25-2010 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tizlinda (Post 66394)
What did Sartin have to say about going deep in the pp's for the best turf race? I've read the guidelines in the yellow manual and didn't get confirmation on that strategy.

I can't say that it stands out in my mind Doc's own recommendations for Turf line selection. Hopefully others can cite something specific for us. And just for me, while I am always interested in what Doc had to say on pretty much anything, since he never was and is sure not now responsible for my wins or losses or profits or enjoyment - I'm happy to test out all hypotheses for myself (even unto re-inventing the wheel sometimes :confused:), including begging and borrowing from anyone whose ideas seem to dovetail with (or challenge) my core-beliefs so far. Thus, it almost doesn't matter what Doc (or anyone) said on this Turf line matter, since a certain amount of personal effort can answer the question more decisively and create a more persistent behaviour pattern than (only) going by what anyone else says.

And I suspect you knew that...;)

cheers,

Ted


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.