View Single Post
Old 04-18-2016, 06:59 PM   #19
Mitch44
Grade 1
 
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: The Villages, Fl.
Posts: 3,872
The flip side of that coin is the horse the same horse that ran that better line? There are Derby winners that never win another race. And everyday horses that run one too many races or an overtaxing race that never repeat it. So using more that one race can be dangerous. Its a judgement call as to weather its the same horse or not. You'll be right at times and wrong at other times.

On pg. II of the yellow manual Sartin states; " On page 16 in the Basic Phase III manual we state that averaging can be dangerous at best. While certain individuals can use averaging, for most it is a disaster. DO NOT AVERAGE. We have better tools for selecting a PREDICTIVE PACELINE." Mark obviously your the exception but for the average Joe probably not a good idea.

I agree variants are difficult to make and would be a full time job with no time for handicapping. But there is a big difference between tracks & variants and how different makers compute this stuff. Regardless they do it by a consistent method which is about as good as it gets. Its just insane to think one doesn't need these adjustment as you'll win more with them than without them.

By going to three fractions and compounded ratings it lessen the need for accurate adjustments. I said lessen not elimate them. It insane to think you can compare Calder with a race from SA or not use variants for off track or on turf courses that aren't firm. I never have agreed on where they distribute the variant E.g. 2/3rs early and 1/3 late or equally to each FR. Myself I would distribute to where it accelerates as that is where it'll effect the horse the most. I.e. if early than all on that part for that horse and if an S or L all on HE for that horse. Regardless its like the Doc said ;"it doesn't make any difference what you use for a beaten length as long as its consistent." All these variants and track to track adjustments are the same as long as all tracks and methods are consistent. The commercial makers like BRIS and Trackmaster do this on a consistent procedure by computer without mans prejudices.
I do agree with you Mark on the POR and its effect on the horse. A horse going against a weaker POR amounts to a huge class drop that is hidden from the public. Few look at this aspect or factor. Additionally it is really easy now that RDSS rates every race in the horses chart for a total pace rating and the POR for that line also. They should use it more in context to todays POR that it'll encounter in todays matchup.

Mitch44
Mitch44 is offline   Reply With Quote