|
Difference between Val3c and Val2006.
Val3c used a formula for applying DTV to running times and for extracting the Intertrack Variant from the TM Speed Rating and also applying it to running times - based on 1 SR or DTV point = 1/5 second. In February 2006 Equibase changed the unit of measure of DTV and SR from 1/5 to 1/10 seconds. They also changed the scale of SR values from 30 - 100 to 0 - 130.
The effect on Val3c of this change was that a) twice the DTV was being applied to running times and b) he formula for deriving the ITV was totally wacked.
As an exercise in understanding this change fully, I modified the internal formulae in Val3c in accordance with the above changes and then asked a few people to test it to see if their results seemed more in keeping with what they were experienceing with Val before the change. In some cases the difference was minimal and in some cases it was noticeable. As Dick summed up earlier, since Val traditionally used HALF the DTV, changing the denomination of units from 5th to 10th had the effect of using the FULL DTV, so the formula change for Val2006 had the effect of reverting back to Doc's intended HALF DTV. In essence, it is exactly what Val3c was before the Equibase change: nothing more, nothing less.
I'm gateful to Ellis Starr, now at Equibase and to Jim Vanderbosch at TrackMaster for listening to my questions and helping me to understand their forumlae.
We sent the write up of results to Doc Sartin and he seemed pleased that the formula had been corrected. Although I asked what if anything I should do with this Val2006 experiment, and described how I was moving forward with the corrected formulae in my new RDSS work, he declined to give any direction about Val2006, so I have taken the position that I will make it available rather as part of RDSS.
A further interesting note is that in working on this Val2006 enquiry into correctly deriving the Inter Track Variant number from the TrackMaster Speed Rating, it became clear to me that Speculator never made any use at all of the ITV value, and in my opinion, suffered from that omission. The ITV adjusts all tracks, distances and surfaces to a hypothetical norm for today's race, thus for example, making 1 turn and 2 turn mile pacelines more equal, inherently fast and inherently slow tracks more equal, turf to dirt, etc, etc. You can do without it, but arguably you can do better with it. Spec160 was released as an update to Spec150 almost solely to incorporate that missing ITV.
The ITV is still inaccurate as it is derived by a formula, not supplied as a value, and that formula may have once been accurate but is now less so. In conversation with TrackMaster, after I tabulated a few dozen ITV values for different distances, tracks, surfaces, they said (and I think with some surprise that I had these numbers at my fingertips), that they were in the ballpark though some had drifted badly over 10 years. (BTW, I must thank Dick aka 'socantra' and my friend and PnC alumnus 'Brian Wade' for their help over the past year or so in zeroing in on some of the math related to this).
I requested and for RDSS have negotiated with TrackMaster that they supply the actual current ITV values used for each paceline in a horse's Past Performance, updated annually or more frequently as track changes or inter track relationships warrant. Whether one feels these numbers are the industry best or not, or whether one thinks they are even necessary, is a separate issue, proven, IMO, entirely by (admittedly labourious) tracking one's own individual handicapping results.
I hope that answered a question about Val3 / Val2006 differences.
Ted
__________________
RDSS - Racing Decision Support System™
|