View Single Post
Old 04-28-2009, 10:15 PM   #13
Ted Craven
Grade 1
 
Ted Craven's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Nanaimo, British Columbia, Canada
Posts: 9,264
MNR 04/28 race #3

Scott,

This comes after the race, but the screenshots were created this afternoon (didn't have time to upload). This discussion is NOT about selections (there is a whole forum for that), but about process - how to use the tools, how to apply concepts consistently.. So let's not worry about the notion of 'redboarding'. In that vein, here are some thoughts about race #3.

I agree with all your paceline selections except for horse #1 (the $4.80 winner), for whom you could take an (important) alternate stance: if you are going to call him a contender (i.e. forgiving the last race), you should consider a consistent approach where you rate it off its BEST recent line (i.e. what can this horse do now, if required). That line for the #1 horse is line 3, not line 2, which looks like this:

Name:  mnr0428#1.jpg
Views: 436
Size:  107.9 KB

Name:  mnr0428-3.jpg
Views: 417
Size:  44.7 KB

Actually, it doesn't much matter if you do use line 2 for the #1 horse, as that would look like this:

Name:  mnr0428-3a.jpg
Views: 405
Size:  45.9 KB

In either case, I believe further analysis on the #4 and #6 is required, thus (I know you have the PPs, but for others' benefit):

Name:  mnr0428#4.jpg
Views: 405
Size:  106.2 KB

Name:  mnr0428#6.jpg
Views: 434
Size:  108.2 KB

One must choose a consistent approach, always, and if being suspicious of a horse's BEST EVER line (except perhaps for a lightly raced improving horse whom you would expect to be showing best-ever's with each next race - i.e. not #4), I must be suspicious of the #4's last race race best ever 169 Total Energy (or 83 Speed Rating) and either use a worse line, or mentally deprecate it in my mind. Notice how since February it alternates with a good race/bad race culminating with its best ever last. Perhaps it can win twice in a row, or perhaps it will only finish in the money. At closing odds of 25-1, either an across the board bet, or a Place and Show bet (ŕ la Bill V ) is in order.

I must also be suspicious of the #6 to win, off a 156 a layoff and no recorded works in 31 days. This is a less likely candidate to win at first asking.

This leaves the more likely win contender to be the #1, whether you used its line 2 or line 3. Before the race, I recorded a win for the #1 (at 4-1 M/L) and #4, with a place and show bet on the #4. A natural exacta was the box of #1, #4, #6. At bet time (I wasn't there), one might consider skipping the #1 at < 2-1 and go with the across the board on the #4.

I think it is important to observe that the #1 was a likely win contender regardless of using line 2 or line 3, and regardless of it appearing consequently ranked #1 or # 4 on the BL/BL readout. Not betting it, was a natural decision (which was what you chose). Deciding between the remaining horses of the top 3 was the decision process.

Again, this deals with adopting a consistent analysis approach, not post-mortem picking the winner. Visible for all to see was the #4 which you called clearly, Scott. I hope you backed it up to place/show at those odds - a classic Sartin wagering approach. The other nuance here, which I think important, was to use the #1 horse's best recent line, using Total Energy, Perceptor Total, or SR to identify that.

I think it's worth repeating a concept clarified by 'Buzz' elsewhere recently: we deal in random, or chaotic, or stochastic events here within an overall, coherent pattern. We don't know precisely when our method will hit, but over time, keeping records, we do gain an idea how frequently it will hit. If we regularly demand price before entering a wager - and apply a consistent analytic approach, using the same rules/guidelines situationally over and over (e.g. per above: suspect best ever lines, back up longer odds horses to place, show, bet), we will certainly reach a consistent ongoing profit.

Hope that helped.

Ted
__________________

R
DSS -
Racing Decision Support System™
Ted Craven is offline