Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted Craven
Pino,
Well, bingo! I think that was the original point of this Topic, so thanks for re-focusing us! I'm sure 80% of it can be stated rather succinctly - it's the other 20% (as always) i.e. the exceptions, the notwithstandings, which burn the words. I hope we can restate it, when all is said and done.
Best of the Last 3 comparable (proposed):
1. try to use the same distance structure, same surface, same track when you can
2. except for Turf and returning from long layoff (could be debated) review the past 3 lines as stated in #1; skip intervening opposite surfaces, skip intervening opposite distance structures; if you can't skip them, use them (gingerly) or trust whatever DTV and ITV adjustments you have available (i.e. adjust the POR figures as little as possible, but do so when you must); if there's clear trouble recently (clipped heals, bumped, etc) go back further - but not too far back
3. Using metrics like Adjusted Sartin Speed Rating, or Total Energy, or Line Score (e.g. Perceptor in RDSS), look for the best numbers in the above range of pacelines; beware of best ever numbers, excepting perhaps improving young horses (that's what they do...); try to find mutliple examples of the line stengths you propose to use (e.g. from further back in its record); if you have access to E/L or ESP energy disbursement figures, try to makes sure the candidate line is typical of how the horse commonly (or recently) disburses its energy; make sure the horse 'participated' in the race, i.e. that the Total Energy or E/L distribution was not just of the POR and our horse was merely sucked around the track behind the real contenders
4. Do a line for every horse: their energy disbursement style or Total Energy could be masked behind a blah performance, but they may finish ITM against today's matchup
5. More...
FWIW, there's enough regularity to at least the above 'rules' that 'Best of Last 3 comparable' can be programmed fairly rigourously (and has been, certainly). As well, of course, as other paceline selection schemes, alternate to or variations on the above.
Ted
|
I agree and I'm sorry. I didn't realize the over or under 45 day issue would promote so much attention. I was simply wondering if the over 45 days since last race horses were worthwhile using or not. I should say that my focus is always on "the win" aspect of the race.
It seems to me that entering horses who are really not players in the race can only "muddy up the water". This applies to other situations as well. To me, using lines from 6,7,8,or 9 races ago just distort the picture. I have noticed that most of the lines used are from races that basically represent the horses "best ever" or something close to that, no matter how far back one has to go in order to find it. Of what value is entering a horse off a line that it can't possibly run back to based on it's current form and condition?
Let me entertain a best of last 3 scenario.
Today's race is a 10k nw3l at 6f on the dirt(or poly, whichever you choose)
last race - 10K nw3l - same distance, surface, no sign of life, no toruble
2nd back - 10k nw3l - same distance, surface, no sign of life, no trouble
3rd back - 10k nw2l - won
In today's race, is it prudent to use the best of last 3? (3rd line back) And for the sake of agrument, let's say the use of the 3rd line back would propel the horse into a primary contender in the race. How much of your hard earned cash do you want to wager on that 3rd line back after 2 very subpar performances?
At what point do you just plain "throw out" a horse?