View Single Post
Old 09-26-2009, 04:42 AM   #2
For The Lead
Grade 1
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,292
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tim Y View Post
Sartin forever suggested all of us forget the horsey talk of class structure
Nice article, Tim. However, with respect to class structure, you will always get an argument from me. Moreover, I can support my argument with facts based on actual race results. In that regard, I would venture a guess that I have more information available to me than Howard did. I seriously doubt that anyone had "millions" of horses race results at their fingertips back in the '80's, with the exception of perhaps the Daily Racing Form.

Can a cheap claimer beat an allowance horse? You can bet it can, but that is a "trick" question. And in order to understand the "trick", one must first have a working knowledge of horse racing and it's class structure, whether one likes it or not.

The "trick" is this.
Once a horse breaks its' maiden, the most logical next race is one for non winners of a race other than maiden or claiming (NW1X) or non winners of two races lifetime(NW2L). Both of these types of races are available in the allowance category, however, only one puts all the entrants on a level playing field and that is non winners of two races lifetime. They are on level ground because all the horses have won only one race, their maiden victory.
In the allowance category, most people would view this as one allowance horse beating other allowance horses. This is an error.

Then there is the allowance race for non winners of a race other than maiden or claiming(NW1X). By the way, this is more common in the allowance category than a NW2L condition. In this race, you can have the same allowance horses that have only won their maiden races and just keep running in this condition because their owners do not want to drop them down into the claiming ranks for fear of losing them through the claim box. These horses can be "1 for 10", "1 for 20" or whatever. Are these legitimate allowance horses? NO! And they should be placed in claiming races and allowed to find a level at which they are capable of competing and even win. It is in these "allowance" races where a claimer can beat an allowance horse, because the "1 for ?" allowance horses in these races are really NOT allowance horses. They are "1 for ?" plugs. A claiming horse, who is also eligible for this race, could have 10 wins, 20, wins or 30 wins as long as they are all claiming race wins and, of course, its' maiden win. Now I ask, which is the better horse, the "1 for ?" who just keeps running in these races and never winning or the claimer that demonstrates the ability to beat fields of horses who also have the ability to beat fields of horses? Personally, I'll take a horse that has demonstrated the ability to beat other horses over a horse that has demonstrated it CAN NOT!

So, in the above case, you can put in a line for an "allowance" horse and a line for a "claiming" horse and if the line for the "claiming" horse shows it can beat the "allowance" horse, then it probably will. However, if you try and convince me that one of these claimers could have beat SECRETARIAT, good luck! I don't think even YOU believe that!!

Does this mean that the "highest class horse" wins every race? Of course not. But facts are facts and the facts are these; under the current class structure of horse racing, the majority of races are won by horses that are either dropping down in class or remaining at the same level as their last race. And as you would say, "PERIOD"!
__________________
"It's suppose to be hard. If it was easy, everybody would do it." Jimmy Dugan, A League of Their Own
For The Lead is offline   Reply With Quote