Quote:
Originally Posted by Dorianmode
Hi Mike, .....um.....not exactly. The standard deviations, (NP) of the 3, the 6, and the 7 tell me that it is 95% probable that they will run WITHIN their NP range. It is highly unlikely, (only 5%...statistically speaking), that one of them will, all of a sudden, "jump" out of that range in that race, and even if they did, it wouldn't be good enough to win). I don't really use NP for "handicapping", only for elimination-efficiency. The remaining 4 I look at, in their RDSS screens. Does that make sense ?
|
Hi DM,
I have to admit that most of what you've written is this thread doesn't seem to hold together. First, the 95% confidence interval is a fairly useless way to measure the value of a horse's performances, if you're only looking at speed figs, since the range is so wide that it does nothing to separate the performances of the contenders, which is all that really matters. Also, you seem not to understand Dave's reasoning in weighting low variance (aka 'good form') as heavily as he has - especially in cheap races, such as this one, where it can be as valuable as a speed rating in evaluating win probability. Personally, I think Dave has weighted it too heavily, but the low-variance factor can produce high-price winners, precisely because the crowd wieights speed figs so heavily.
Your elimination method basically seems to involve throwing out all the non-NP horses and then checking the remainder vs. RDSS. Why you or anyone else would do this mystifies me, since NP is a much weaker handicapping factor, with an average hit-rate of .18. The top two choices hit RDSS (either TE or V/DC) hit 60% of winners, whereas the top four of NP (which offers no rank-order) hit only 74%. To put it another way 97% of NP winners are already contained within RDSS. So, if you are going to go to the trouble of handicapping with RDSS, why bother to 'confirm' it with NP? To apply your elimination standard, RDSS eliminates only 15% of winners, whereas NP eliminates 26%.
Cheers,
B Jennet