View Single Post
Old 01-31-2012, 01:30 AM   #67
Dorianmode
always learning
 
Dorianmode's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Minneapolis / Rancho Santa Fe
Posts: 277
1/30 Good evening, Mr. Jennet

Thanks for posting this. If you... one of the leading lights here, have these questions, it makes me think I have done a very poor job explaining myself.

"the 95% confidence interval is a fairly useless way to measure the value of a horse's performances, if you're only looking at speed figs"

Correct. I don't just look at speed figures. One dimensional handicapping is not for me. I use NP to make SOME easy eliminations. The range may be wide, (and often is), but statistically, a horse with a significantly different range than another, requires that BOTH, (ie the probability is multiplied).. have to run outside their (95% SD) range, (if something "different" is going to happen). I only use it to help identify the non-contenders. I DO understand Mr. Schwatrz's reasoning, it does not appeal to me, entirely, using it the way he does. The reason I suggested there needs to be the calculation of a Confidence Interval, and a Neyman Construction, is to complete the probability picture, (as I said in one of my first posts. I care MORE about my win percentage, and frequent wins, than I do about high priced, less frequent wins.

Your elimination method basically seems to involve throwing out all the non-NP horses and then checking the remainder vs. RDSS.

No. I do not even look at whether a horse is a "NP" horse. I only look at the ranges, and the total range picture, to get a feel for the competitive nature of the entire field. Many times NP has as one or more of it's horses, an animal that could not possibly win the race. I would NEVER bet a dime on many of them.

"Why you or anyone else would do this mystifies me, since NP is a much weaker handicapping factor, with an average hit-rate of .18. The top two choices hitRDSS (either TE or V/DC) hit 60% of winners, whereas the top four of NP (which offers no rank-order) hit only 74%."

Exactly. That's why I NEVER use NP to pick winners. After I have made the eliminations, I ONLY use RDSS. The fewer contenders I have, (3 or 4 at the most), the clearer the RDSS picture is.

"To put it another way 97% of NP winners are already contained within RDSS. So, if you are going to go to the trouble of handicapping with RDSS, why bother to 'confirm' it with NP?"

Exactly backwards. I do not use NP to confirm anything. I use RDSS to pick winners, AFTER I have looked at a number of things to pick the the contenders, and eliminate the others, (including NP). I do not use it the way Mr. Schwartz suggests, for the reasons I have written about above. It's statistical validity, as far as it goes, makes sense, and I'm sure he will improve it. For now, all I know is, it help me eliminate non-contenders, quickly and consistently.
Dorianmode is offline   Reply With Quote