FTL,
A very good elaboration on the dangers of using only one screen, or
one section of a
Summary screen (i.e. the BL/BL screen). I agree it can be a costly 'shorthand' to refer to 'RDSS Ranks' meaning the BL/BL sort, when a Matchup analysis will clearly show that, either from a positional or an energy distribution point of view, we need to be focusing on either the Early or the Other Than Early (OTE) rankings. That's why the BLBL Summary screen conveniently has Early rankings, Late rankings, some compound rankings (TS+F3, VDC, CPR) and E/L differentials. Folks could be forgiven for considering it a one-stop-shop destination - but don't just look at the friendly numbers in the middle of the screen

.
If 'Alice' is trying to get one or 2 comprehensive numbers which fit in a broad number of race categories, I would urge him to break it down not only by distance and surface (which he's probably doing), but also by Matchup scenario (bias toward early, bias toward late).
It's true that aggregate BLBL, VDC and CSR values can probably get you 4 bona fide contenders 80+ percent of the time, but knowing when and WHY to focus on Early and when and WHY on Late (what to speak taking a consistent and repeatable approach to picking fair pacelines for the horses) - is the secret to winnowing that down further. By watching the toteboard, you can probably make money dutching 3 or 4 of those horses in exactas a lot of the time, but being able to narrow it down to 3, or 2 (let alone 1) horse makes it so much easier (and profitable).
I do take your point about the 'not a black box', and (still) heartily concur.
Ted