View Single Post
Old 11-20-2013, 01:01 PM   #26
Bill V.
The egg man
 
Bill V.'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Carlsbad, California
Posts: 10,005
Its just one calculation

Ted wrote this

Quote:
I just wanted to comment that CSR is not, in my view, some 'magical' number or the 'new' recommended approach to things. There are so many tools, so many consistently applicable approaches possible with RDSS' tools that do not stop working because of some peoples' focus one one particularly interesting method.
I find this point made by Ted to be important. The CSR is easy to rate and test and chart, because the calculations are based on a group of pace lines.
No decision making or analysis is needed. You just look at the rankings.

I suppose Ted used the Adjusted Speed Rating because its the staple of Doc's guidelines on pace line selection.

The speed rating has always been part of the methodology.
"The best of the last 3 speed adjusted speed ratings at a comparable distance and surface" Even back in the Energy /KGEN days
the instructions were to use a paceline with a speed rating over 80
or within 2 of the mean of the speed ratings of the contenders

Anyway What would have happened if Ted use another staple of the methodology Total Energy

Would study's and test of races be just as conclusive as the CSR test ?
Is the CSR any different than what a Composite total energy rating would be?

Here is race 8 using the top 4 Total Energy figures for each horses last 4 usable lines _ I just used basic math but my point is that Ted could have use Total Energy or TPR and probably got similar results as a speed rating calculation,


Bill's Composite Total Energy Rating

Name:  CTE figs.PNG
Views: 1809
Size:  7.3 KB

Name:  CTE ranks.PNG
Views: 1806
Size:  5.7 KB
Bill V. is offline   Reply With Quote