View Single Post
Old 11-20-2013, 01:01 PM   #27
Mark
Grade 1
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 318
Bill, I am in complete agreement with the implications of your questions. The CSR is highly flawed and to handicap a race by using it as your contender selection method as we did in the old days with APV is a very questionable approach. What it rewards is high adjusted speed ratings from the last 4 "usable" races. That is not handicapping and what you will get is heavily bet horses. At least with APV you have the influence of historical purse values that the horse competed in and won purse money.
Here's the perfect example: today is a 8.2 mile route. Horse A has two races since returning from a 250 day layoff. His last two races are sprints in which he ran close to the lead before fading beaten 12 lengths and another in which he showed a 5 length stretch gain but finished beaten 8 lengths. His two races prior to the layoff where poor route races, indicating the horse was hurting and needed time away to recover. This horse has been classically prepped for a top effort yet his CSR is in the dumpster. He wins easily at 10/1.
We can't check our brain at the door when we open the handicapping program or racing form. Prices on obvious horses today are hammered down. In the early 90s I played the entire Santa Anita winter meet and can count on my fingers and toes the number of horses at 6/5. I remember Farma Way shipping out for the Santa Anita Handicap when he was at the top of his game and he only went to post at 6/5.
Look at the Beulah and Finger Lakes cards yesterday in some of the worst races carded in North America, absolute plow horses. 3/5, 4/5, even money and I am sure all these horses had top CSR #s. These type of standout horses in cheap races so skew the statistics that it makes them unusable in my opinion.
Each horse has a set of past performances, examine them top to bottom and bottom to top. Find the good races, see how the horse likes to run, what early pace can he succeed against? Look at his pattern of activity and the efforts of his trainer to coax an improved performance previously and today. No esoteric factor can do what your eyes and brain can.
Don't use questionable factors because they are there. You are competing against big money syndicates that spare no software programming expense. Most of us don't get the 7% - 9% rebates on every dollar they wager. You have to find horses that computer algorithms can't.
One Man's Opinion
Mark is offline   Reply With Quote